Couple concede legal case over their cafes being handed to huge chain

A couple have ended their legal challenge against what they described as an “unlawful” decision to replace the operators of their independent north London cafés.

Patrick Matthews and his wife, Emma Fernandez, who operate three cafés around Hampstead Heath, said they would not continue with a judicial review challenging the City of London Corporation’s decision to award the sites to a restaurant chain.

A judge had previously granted permission for the couple’s case to proceed, finding that their challenge was “arguable and should be heard”.

However, the couple said they had made the decision to withdraw with “immense sadness”.

The family-run cafés have served the area for decades and are known to attract high-profile customers, including A-list actors Benedict Cumberbatch and James McAvoy.

A petition opposing the proposed handover attracted 24,000 signatures.

Australian-inspired restaurant group Daisy Green was chosen by the City of London Corporation in December last year to operate cafés at Queen’s Park, Golders Hill Park, Parliament Hill Lido and Parliament Hill Fields.

Patrick Matthews and his wife Emma Fernandez, who run three cafes in Hampstead Heath, said they would not pursue a judicial process against the City of London Corporation

Patrick Matthews and his wife Emma Fernandez, who operate three Hampstead Heath cafés, said they would not continue with their legal challenge against the City of London Corporation

A petition was signed by 24,000 people in support of stopping the handover

A petition opposing the proposed transfer of the cafés was signed by 24,000 people

Despite the decision, Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez continued running cafés at Parliament Hill Lido, Queen’s Park and Highgate Wood.

After the change was announced last December, Mr Cumberbatch said: “We are deeply concerned by the decision to award a contract to a high-end chain. It is a massive oversight to forget the importance of family-run cafés, which are integral to the fabric of our community. We cannot let this happen.”

Ms Fernandez said at the time that she was unsure what she would do after learning the cafés were due to be handed to Daisy Green.

“Honestly, I have no idea what I’m going to do. It’s one thing that I love to do, and I feel so rooted here,” she said.

According to the City of London Corporation, the existing tenancy agreements were due to expire in February, with Daisy Green expected to take over the cafés in spring this year.

Earlier this year, lawyers acting for the couple brought a judicial review in the High Court, disputing the corporation’s decision to appoint new café operators.

The couple, who live in Kentish Town, said: “The Corporation is the custodian of Hampstead Heath, Highgate Woods and Queen’s Park.

“Ultimately, we cannot continue operating these cafés without the Corporation’s support; the situation is unsustainable.

“The personal and financial costs have become too great; we have reached the end of the road.

The cafes, which have been family run for decades, are regular haunts of A-list celebrities including Benedict Cumberbatch and James MacAvoy

The long-established family-run cafés are popular with celebrities, including Benedict Cumberbatch and James McAvoy

Australian-inspired eatery chain Daisy Green was selected by the CLC in December, last year to run the cafes in the Queen's Park, Golders Hill Park, Parliament Hill Lido and Parliament Hill Fields areas of the Heath

Daisy Green was selected by the City of London Corporation last December to operate cafés at Queen’s Park, Golders Hill Park, Parliament Hill Lido and Parliament Hill Fields

Couple Lose Legal Fight Over Cafes Taken Over by Major Chain

The couple said they could not continue operating the cafés without support from the Corporation because the situation had become unsustainable

“We are immensely grateful to all of you who have supported us for the best part of a decade.”

In March, the City of London Corporation, which manages Hampstead Heath as a charity, said it planned to begin possession proceedings to remove the couple’s company, Hoxton Beach Ltd, from the premises.

The corporation accused the company of “refusing to leave the premises”, saying this was preventing the incoming operator from carrying out “fit outs”, building upgrades and other improvements.

The couple added: “We sincerely wish the best to the new operator and stand ready to work constructively with the Corporation, in a spirit of openness, to secure the best possible outcome for everyone affected, including our beloved staff and colleagues.”

Daisy Green operates a number of cafés across London, including venues on Regent Street, in Soho, Victoria, Paddington and Richmond.

READ MORE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Angler Lands 600-Pound Swordfish After Hours-Long Battle

A New Jersey angler endured a grueling battle lasting more than five…

Charlize Theron Tops Best-Dressed Stars at 17th Governors Awards

Hollywood’s biggest names stepped onto the red carpet Sunday night for the…

New Chinese Weight-Loss Injection Could Challenge Mounjaro

An experimental weight-loss injection could emerge as a serious challenger to blockbuster…

The BBC Boss Accused of Failing to Stop Russell Brand

Lesley Douglas, accused of enabling Russell Brand during his BBC years, has…

Maldon Sea Salt Uses German Rock Salt Despite Essex Origin Claims

Harvested near the Essex town that gives it its name, Maldon Salt…

Jean Ross, the real-life inspiration for Cabaret’s Sally Bowles

In the Oscar-winning 1972 film Cabaret, Liza Minnelli, framed by black fishnet…

Russell Brand’s Former Flatmate Describes His ‘Narcissistic’ Room

Russell Brand’s former flatmate has revisited the London bedroom where the comedian…

Penny Wong Defends COP31 Film Featuring Moana Star Auliʻi Cravalho

Foreign Minister Penny Wong has defended a taxpayer-funded documentary costing almost $3…

Elizabeth Holmes: Idealistic Theranos Visionary or Calculated Fraudster?

Critics have lavished extraordinary praise on the film, calling it “ingenious”, “stupefying”,…

Trump Marks New York Post’s 225th Anniversary as Leaders Pay Tribute

Whether they admire us, criticize us or would happily toss us onto…

Trump Criticizes California Gov. Gavin Newsom for Sparing Death Row Prisoners

Donald Trump has launched a scathing attack on Gavin Newsom after the…

Missing Cat Found After Brooklyn Collapse, Reunited With Owner

A beloved cat feared lost in the rubble of a deadly Brooklyn…