When will I finally learn, especially when it comes to women?
Apparently, not today. I joined my first online community for mothers with nothing but optimism.
I imagined finding like-minded parents who could offer thoughtful advice on the best ways to care for my children.
The Facebook group, ‘Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products,’ had almost half a million members.
I expected warmth, encouragement and practical tips. Sunshine and rainbows, essentially.
Instead, rather ironically for a community devoted to ‘low-tox living,’ I encountered cruelty, hostility, judgment and bullying on an almost radioactive scale.
My opening post was hardly controversial. I simply asked how other mothers were limiting their children’s exposure to plastic at school.
More than 10,000 views and 600 comments later — many of them mocking me or calling me a terrible mother — I had learned a useful lesson: when it comes to female spaces, nowhere is necessarily safe.
When I joined my first online community for mothers, I imagined finding like-minded people who could offer advice on caring for my children
I was hoping for practical tips, kindness and plenty of wholesome encouragement
In my experience, the harshest behavior has often come from spaces that claim to promote health and wellness.
That is particularly disappointing because I genuinely care about low-tox living. I was once the complete opposite: a heavy drinker, a junk-food devotee and proudly anti-hippy. But after struggling to conceive my second child, I began looking into research about possible links between certain chemicals and fertility.
I credit Rebecca Fett’s book It Starts With The Egg with helping me conceive my daughter. Since then, I have become fairly evangelical about avoiding potential hormone disruptors, including phthalates — chemicals commonly found in plastics — and synthetic fragrances. In other words, substances present in countless everyday household products.
The Netflix documentary The Plastic Detox is worth watching if you want to learn more about concerns surrounding microplastics. That is why I replaced most of our kitchen utensils with glass or stainless steel. It is also what led me to join the Facebook group.
My first post was simply a request for advice.
‘I’m fairly sure I’m being overly neurotic,’ I wrote. ‘But after removing virtually all plastic from our kitchen at home, I went to have lunch at my son’s school — very sweetly — and noticed that he eats from plastic plates every day. Would it be completely mad and impractical to send him to school with his own stainless-steel plate?’
RELATED: One of Tessa Majors’ killers freed from upstate prison after 6 years
Within minutes, my phone began flashing with notifications — though there was nothing warm or festive about them. Without intending to, I had opened a battlefront. Two distinct camps quickly appeared. One was made up of mothers even more alarmed than I was, some of whom suggested I withdraw my son from school and homeschool him.
The other, considerably stranger group consisted of women who strongly opposed ‘crunchy living’ and appeared to have joined solely to provoke the community’s members.
I was told I would destroy my son’s life by behaving like a ‘helicopter parent.’ I was called a ‘psycho,’ and one commenter claimed my son ‘looked miserable’ in a photograph of us together. He is four years old and simply was not looking at the camera.
I can blame no one but myself for making the fatal mistake of responding to one commenter who was being particularly vicious.
I care deeply about low-tox living and expected the Facebook group to offer sensible advice
One member told me I would ruin my son’s life by being a ‘helicopter parent’ and called me a ‘psycho’
When I opened her profile, I laughed out loud. Her cover image featured a Jimi Hendrix quote: ‘When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace.’ I could also see that she had spent the entire day commenting on strangers’ posts in a group she clearly had no interest in, apparently for the entertainment of it.
It was bizarre, but perhaps I should not have been surprised. I spent more than a decade working as a travel journalist, reviewing some of the world’s most luxurious hotels. The worst guests were consistently found at wellness resorts and detox retreats. Wherever yoga, affirmations and sound baths are abundant, there also seem to be highly strung, intensely judgmental women concealing their disapproval — not very convincingly — behind broad, artificial smiles.
Meghan Markle is, to me, the poster girl for this type. I endured the first season of her Netflix series, With Love, Meghan, because I had been asked to review it, and nearly came away with PTSD. I have encountered many women who glide through life with an outwardly sugary manner, yet somehow leave a trail of enemies behind them.
Why, then, do mothers seem especially prone to this kind of mean-girl behavior? Actress Ashley Tisdale wrote about the subject for The Cut earlier this year, explaining why she had left a friendship circle that included Mandy Moore and criticizing it as being ‘too high school.’
‘Mom groups can be toxic,’ she later wrote on Instagram. ‘You’re allowed to leave.’
I intend to follow that advice and leave ‘Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products’ behind.
I suspect my life will feel considerably ‘cleaner’ without an army of opinionated keyboard warriors attacking me whenever I ask a genuine question.
And no, I will not be sending my son to school with a stainless-steel plate. Clearly, I was having a difficult day and had lost some perspective — as every mother does from time to time.
Still, I would rather care too much about my children than too little. And when the next difficult day arrives, I would prefer to handle it alone than share my worries with an online girl gang and hope for kindness in return.