TAMPA — An independent psychiatric evaluation concluded that Thomas Markle Sr., the estranged father of Meghan Markle, is mentally competent to face federal child pornography charges and had overstated memory problems in an effort to avoid prosecution.
Markle Sr., 82, appeared in federal court in Tampa on Thursday afternoon wearing an orange jumpsuit. The hearing focused on whether he was capable of understanding the allegations and participating in his defense in the high-profile case involving alleged child sexual abuse material.
According to the report presented in court, a psychiatrist determined with reasonable medical certainty that Markle Sr. has “sufficient ability to understand the nature and consequences of the charges against him.”
Forensic psychiatrist Amie Gerodimos wrote that Markle Sr. — who has three children — gave confusing answers during his evaluation. He allegedly misstated how many children he had and at one point identified his daughter Meghan as his sister.
“I don’t think so. I have two kids. I think Meghan is Samantha, I only have one daughter and one son,” Markle Sr. allegedly said, according to the report.
During another exchange, Markle Sr. again appeared to confuse his daughter’s identity. “Mr. Markle said that he has been seeing a therapist but does not know their name. He said that his sister ‘Meghan’ or his brother could help with that. Then he apologized, acknowledged that he has no sister, and reminded me that Meghan Markle is his daughter,” Gerodimos wrote.
Markle Sr. also referred to his well-publicized estrangement from Meghan, telling the psychiatrist that he had experienced “some family disputes and things like that, not getting along with someone in the family for any number of reasons.”
In the end, however, Gerodimos concluded that Markle Sr. was “malingering,” meaning he was exaggerating or fabricating symptoms to avoid facing the criminal case.
“He understood the seriousness of the nature of the charges,” Gerodimos wrote. “It is my clinical opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr. Markle is malingering because he is exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid criminal prosecution.”
Prosecutors said they accepted the report’s conclusions. Mary Wolf, Markle Sr.’s attorney, said the defense would not challenge the competency finding at this stage of the proceedings.
More coverage of Meghan Markle’s estranged father, Thomas Markle:
Wolf said Markle Sr.’s legal team could later contest his fitness to stand trial after he is transferred to California, where the case is expected to proceed.
MORE ON THIS: El Niño Waves Batter Multimillion-Dollar Seal Beach Homes
The defense attorney also said Markle Sr. “vehemently denies” the allegations.
Markle Sr.’s daughter Samantha attended the hearing with her partner, Mark Phillips. The couple waved and smiled at him as he was brought into the courtroom in a wheelchair.
As she left the courthouse, Samantha Markle said her father was “doing great, thanks.”
Markle Sr. was charged earlier this month in California with federal possession of child pornography. He later faced additional child pornography charges in the Philippines, where he had previously lived.
He was arrested in Florida at the care facility where he had been staying after undergoing a leg amputation in December 2025.
A judge initially permitted Markle Sr. to remain free while wearing a GPS ankle monitor. He was later returned to custody after allegedly removing the device.
Prosecutors allege that investigators discovered child pornography in two California storage units belonging to Markle Sr. Federal authorities said two images appeared to show an adult man, whom a witness identified as Markle Sr., with a nude prepubescent girl.
Markle Sr.’s son, Thomas Markle Jr., allegedly discovered disturbing images of children while sorting through his father’s belongings at his home in the Philippines.
Markle Sr. has previously dismissed the allegations as “sick lies.” He has not yet entered a plea.
Meghan Markle, the 45-year-old Duchess of Sussex, has said she is “deeply distressed” by the accusations against her father.
Markle Sr. is scheduled to return to Tampa court on Dec. 1 for a preliminary hearing. That appearance could change if a grand jury indicts him first, in which case the next hearing would take place in California.