Ken Paxton’s defeat in Texas represented a political earthquake, as Democrats captured their first Senate seat in the Lone Star State since 1988.
Donald Trump had backed the unsuccessful candidate despite a series of scandals, including an affair with Christian influencer Tracy Duhon, first reported by Our News Outlet.
Republicans are now confronting the challenge of winning the presidency in 2028, with Texas likely to be central to any victory. The state has supported every Republican presidential nominee since 1980, while its 40 electoral votes make it the largest prize on the map after California.
The Paxton debacle has triggered a blame game in Washington over who persuaded Trump to support him in his 12-point loss to Democrat James Talarico. The result represented an almost 26-point swing from Trump’s 2024 performance, the largest shift in any midterm Senate race.
Trump loyalist Natalie Harp and Texas-born Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins are among those being scrutinized.
Trump, however, has shown little appetite for blaming either himself or his advisers.
Instead, the president—known for his focus on appearances—has offered his own explanation to close confidants in the two weeks since the election defeat.
‘What’s up with that eye of his?’ Trump reportedly asked in the Oval Office after the midterm rout, according to a source.
Donald Trump backed Ken Paxton despite a series of scandals, including an affair with Christian influencer Tracy Duhon, first reported by Our News Outlet
Insiders say the appearance-conscious president has blamed Paxton’s lazy eye for the midterm defeat in Texas
Texas-born Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins was among the voices urging Trump to support Paxton
Natalie Harp printed articles favorable to Paxton and placed them before Trump, according to a source close to the president
The president has not focused on Paxton’s impeachment, his divorce or footage obtained by Our News Outlet showing him in London with his alleged mistress, Tracy Duhon, during the campaign.
Instead, Trump has concentrated on the former Texas attorney general’s drooping right eyelid. The condition stems from a childhood injury and reportedly led some members of the 63-year-old’s campaign team to nickname him ‘the lizard.’
‘Wouldn’t you get that fixed?’ Trump asked White House aides. ‘I’ve got a doctor down in Palm Beach who could work something out for that.’
Two additional sources told Our News Outlet that Trump made similar comments about Paxton’s lazy eye in separate conversations.
Paxton was 12 when he was struck in the eye by chinaberries thrown by other boys. He spent nearly two weeks in hospital and underwent five surgeries.
Years later, an elbow during a college basketball game at Baylor shattered bones around the same eye.
The issue was also discussed on the campaign trail, according to insiders.
One Paxton source said: ‘It’s really distracting when you’re around him. All of us joke that he kind of looks like [a] lizard. We fully expect him to use his tongue to catch a fly or something.’
The same source said the injury had severely limited Paxton’s vision: ‘He’s basically blind in that eye. He can’t really see out of it.’
The effort to elevate Paxton over incumbent Republican Senator John Cornyn was reportedly driven in part by Harp, known inside Trump’s circle as the ‘human printer’ and viewed as a key channel into the Oval Office.
According to people familiar with the process, stories that capture her attention often end up in front of the president.
A source close to Trump said Harp printed articles highlighting Cornyn’s calls after 2020 for the Republican Party to move beyond Trump.
Paxton’s alleged mistress, Christian influencer Tracy Duhon, became a central issue in the unsuccessful campaign
Paxton and his wife, Angela, married in 1986 after meeting at Baylor University, a Baptist institution
Trump endorsed Paxton on May 19, during early voting, saying incumbent Republican Senator John Cornyn ‘was not supportive of me when times were tough’
‘Natalie would print it out and put it in front of him,’ the source said.
Cornyn had provided her with ample material. As Trump began rebuilding his political comeback in May 2023, the senator told reporters: ‘We need to come up with an alternative. I think President Trump’s time has passed him by.’
EXPLORE MORE: JD Vance Rushed Into Urgent Talks Over ‘Doomsday’ Blackout Crisis
Caroline Wren, Trump’s Austin-born former national finance director, ‘was pretty involved in sending stuff to Natalie,’ according to a source close to the president.
Mackowiak, a former senior adviser to Cornyn’s Senate reelection campaign, said fellow Texan Brooke Rollins was another influential voice supporting Paxton.
‘You had a lot of good people that did nothing wrong who got beat because of Ken Paxton and Donald Trump and Brooke Rollins,’ he told Our News Outlet.
Two White House insiders confirmed that Rollins favored Paxton but said her position was not the reason Trump ultimately endorsed him.
A source close to Rollins said: ‘Through many years of conversations, Rollins has agreed with President Trump’s assessment of Ken’s leadership for Texas. Rollins and Paxton have been friends and America First partners for 25 years.’
‘She has long been one of his biggest champions. Having said that, she was not asked and did not weigh in on the decision.’
Trump had been expected to support Cornyn after the senator narrowly defeated Paxton in the March 3 primary, according to a report by The Atlantic the following day.
‘Brooke Rollins stepped in and was one of the key—maybe the key—people convincing him not to do it,’ Mackowiak said.
Mackowiak linked her influence to Tim Dunn, a Midland oil billionaire, major Trump donor and longtime Paxton supporter who he said is godfather to Rollins’ children.
Before joining Trump’s first administration, Rollins spent 15 years leading the Texas Public Policy Foundation, where Dunn serves as vice chairman.
‘The Tim-Dunn-MAGA-Ken-Paxton wing hates Cornyn,’ Mackowiak said.
Caroline Wren, Trump’s Austin-born former national finance director, ‘was pretty involved in sending stuff to Natalie,’ according to a source close to the president
The defeat has prompted a Washington blame game over who urged Trump to support Paxton in his 12-point loss to Democrat James Talarico, pictured
The source close to Trump minimized Rollins’ influence, describing her role as ‘more on the fringes, to be honest with you.’
‘She gives political advice based on policies. We should do this or that because of the farmers, or we shouldn’t because of the ag industry,’ the source said.
‘But I have never heard her explicitly say, “Sir, you should endorse this candidate or that candidate.”‘
Trump waited more than two months after the primary before making his endorsement. Right-wing influencers reacted furiously online, while officials told Axios on March 15 that he had been leaning toward Cornyn ‘before MAGA went ballistic.’
‘People were even advocating, “Sir, just stay out of it. There’s no need for you to endorse one way or another,”‘ the source close to Trump said.
‘Let it play out. I think that probably would have been the best route.’
The source said Trump eventually chose Paxton because he ‘didn’t view Cornyn as someone that had been loyal to him or fighting for him.’
Trump endorsed Paxton on May 19, during early voting, writing that Cornyn ‘was not supportive of me when times were tough.’
The endorsement came three years after the Texas House impeached Paxton, then the state’s attorney general, over allegations that he abused his office to assist a donor who had given his mistress a job. The state Senate acquitted him in September 2023, allowing him to remain in office.
His former wife, state Senator Angela Paxton, filed for divorce in July 2025 and accused him of adultery. Paxton attributed the separation to ‘political attacks.’ Their divorce was finalized on November 11.
As the campaign entered its final days, further damaging reports emerged. The Wall Street Journal reported on a Dubai party involving Paxton and his mistress, along with two fugitives facing fraud charges in the United States. The New York Times reported that Duhon was a registered Democrat.
The effort to save Paxton’s campaign consumed more than $281 million in Republican advertising, diverting resources that could have supported candidates elsewhere.
Republicans ultimately lost not only a Senate seat but also their hold on Texas, as Democrats won every statewide office.
Trump ‘ignored advice from hundreds,’ Mackowiak said.
Our News Outlet has contacted Cornyn, Dunn, Harp, Paxton, Rollins, the White House and Wren for comment.