Share this @internewscast.com

The proposed TikTok ban working its way through Congress could embolden authoritarian censorship abroad, experts warn, and shatter the United States’ reputation as an international champion of free speech.

The House of Representatives passed the Protecting Americans From Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act on Wednesday. The bill still needs a Senate vote, and then to be signed by President Joe Biden. If signed into law, ByteDance, TikTok’s Chinese parent company, would either be forced to sell TikTok, or the app would be banned from app stores, according to the bill’s proponents.

U.S. officials say the driving motivation to pass such a bill is to prevent TikTok from being used to disseminate Chinese propaganda or collect information on U.S. citizens for Chinese government use.

But to some critics of the bill, a ban would cede America’s moral authority when it condemns other countries over limiting their citizens’ internet access.

“The United States, particularly through the State Department, has been very vocal about other countries when they disable access to either parts of the internet or to social media services and other applications that are predominantly U.S.-based,” said Kate Ruane, who directs the Free Expression Project at the Center for Democracy and Technology, a Washington-based tech policy think tank.

“If we go forward with this and we ban TikTok, that is essentially going to be license to authoritarian regimes around the world to do the same to U.S.-based platforms. And I think we will see a lot of copycat measures as a result of that,” Ruane said.

The U.S. has long promoted the open internet as a soft power tool that promotes freedom of speech and the exchange of ideas, in contrast with more authoritarian countries’ approaches, like China’s Great Firewall, Russia’s RuNet and Iran’s “halal internet.”

The U.S. was a founding member of the Freedom Online Coalition, a 39-nation group that advocates for the international adoption of an internet that’s free of censorship or political disruption. Last year, the White House announced its commitment to “A Declaration For the Future of the Internet,” made by a group of 60 countries opposed to authoritarian control of the internet.

The declaration’s provisions include a commitment to “refrain from blocking or degrading access to lawful content, services, and applications on the Internet, consistent with principles of Net Neutrality subject to applicable law, including international human rights law.”

In 2022, the State Department, alongside other Freedom Online Coalition members, condemned Iran for shutting down internet access as anti-government protests took hold across the country.

The year before, it had formally condemned Nigeria for blocking Twitter, at the time a common platform for people there to air criticism of their government. “As its partner, we call on the government to respect its citizens’ right to freedom of expression by reversing this suspension,” a State Department spokesperson said at the time.

In those cases, those governments went far beyond restricting online access and threatened users. But even blocking access to a popular app like TikTok could embolden authoritarian countries around the world, said Willmary Escoto, policy counsel for Access Now, a U.S.-based nonprofit that advocates for global internet freedom and connectivity.

“It sends the message that this is acceptable. These reactions can really spur internet fragmentation and it could really interfere with access to information and freedom of expression across borders,” Escoto said.

Chris Painter, who served in the Obama administration as the first ever top “cyber diplomat,” or coordinator of cyber issues for the State Department, said he didn’t view the bill as an attempt to shut down speech, but said its advocates should do a better job explaining why a ByteDance-owned TikTok presents such a threat to U.S. national security.

“If the U.S. was certainly trying to shut down a social media platform or something because they didn’t like what was being said on it, absolutely our moral authority would disappear,” Painter said.

“If we tried to shut down social media before an election, which a lot of countries unfortunately do in some parts of the world, obviously that deserves an outcry. We don’t do that. In fact, the U.S. champions exactly the opposite,” he said.

“I think that’s going to be the challenge for the administration or for Congress or wherever it actually moves forward: explaining why it’s necessary,” Painter said.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Mississippi executes a man convicted of raping and killing a college student

Mississippi Carries Out Execution of Man Convicted in College Student’s Rape and Murder

In Parchman, Mississippi, a man convicted of the 1993 kidnapping, rape, and…
WATCH: Food order mix-up triggers brawl at burger joint, leading to seven arrests

Burger Brawl Chaos: Food Mix-Up Sparks Violent Clash and Seven Arrests at Local Diner

A chaotic brawl erupted inside a Texas burger restaurant, culminating in seven…
Central Park Conservancy bigwig blasted by Wollman Rink operator she bragged about dissing in op-ed

Central Park Conservancy Executive Criticized by Wollman Rink Operator Following Op-Ed Remarks

This week, Central Park Conservancy’s CEO, Elizabeth “Betsy” Smith, found herself at…
Evergreen Park, Illinois news: 2 injured in shooting inside Walmart store in Evergreen Park at 95th, Western, police say | LIVE

Two Injured in Evergreen Park Walmart Shooting: Latest Updates and Police Response

In Evergreen Park, Illinois, a typical afternoon turned chaotic when a shooting…
US military to oversee next phase of peace deal from coordination base in Israel

US Military Takes Charge of Peace Deal Progress from New Coordination Hub in Israel

Following over two years of conflict, Israel and Hamas have agreed to…
Owen Shroyer Declares Debating the Left “Fruitless” as Right Must Evolve to Win

Why Debating the Left is a Losing Strategy: Owen Shroyer Urges the Right to Innovate for Victory

In a recent video, Owen Shroyer expressed his belief that engaging in…
Pakistan has a history of harboring terrorists, explains Katie Pavlich

Breaking: Pakistan and Taliban Forge 48-Hour Ceasefire Amid Escalating Conflict

This week, tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan’s ruling Taliban escalated, resulting in…
Passenger allegedly assaults Alaska Airlines crew members, forces emergency landing at Boise Airport

Alaska Airlines Flight Makes Emergency Landing in Boise After Passenger Disrupts Crew

A woman from White Salmon, Washington, found herself in handcuffs following an…
Wife charged with attempted murder after allegedly lacing husband's drink with poison: police

Woman Accused of Attempted Murder for Allegedly Poisoning Husband’s Drink, According to Police

A North Carolina woman is reportedly facing an attempted murder charge after…
Charles Manson follower imprisoned in Hollywood killings gets major ruling from governor

Governor Reverses Parole for Charles Manson Follower in Notorious Hollywood Murders

California Governor Gavin Newsom has overturned a parole board’s decision to grant…
Jaisol's Taco Tour 2025: Heir to carnitas throne, Marcos Carbajal, shares favorite authentic Little Village, Pilsen spots

Jaisol’s Taco Adventure 2025: Marcos Carbajal, Carnitas King Successor, Reveals Top Authentic Spots in Little Village and Pilsen

CHICAGO (WLS) — Back by popular demand, ABC7 meteorologist Jaisol Martinez hit…
Is college worth the cost? Universities work to show the return on investment of a degree

Do College Degrees Pay Off? Universities Highlight Value and ROI for Students

WASHINGTON (AP) — For today’s youth in America, the decision about which…