Fix outdoor dining and protect the tip credit
Share this @internewscast.com


Over half a decade has passed since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. During those challenging times, restaurants ingeniously utilized outdoor dining sheds that spilled onto sidewalks and even into curbside lanes, a strategy that proved vital in sustaining businesses when indoor dining posed significant health risks.

However, circumstances have changed.

Now, it’s time to reconsider the presence of these sheds in the curbside lanes. Contrary to this view, the City Council is proposing a different approach. While the Adams administration mandated the removal of sheds from parking lanes from November through April, the Council is advocating for them to be allowed year-round.

Consider the chaos during recent weeks, as New York faced relentless snowstorms that left the city blanketed in ice. Imagine the added complications had these outdoor sheds remained in place throughout the year.

Their presence complicates street cleaning and hampers effective trash collection. And don’t even mention the challenges they pose for snow removal.

These are just some of the reasons I oppose them. Moreover, their existence raises serious questions of fairness and ethics.

Giving restaurants rent-free space while paying only a modest yearly usage fee on city property is nice for those restaurants, but let’s think about this for a minute — is it fair to everyone else?

Is it fair to the clothing store next door that, to begin with, loses a few convenient parking spaces for potential customers, but also can’t use the property in front to display, for example, a row of dresses?

Is it fair to the restaurant down the block that, due to its design, has the same amount of interior space but a narrower façade on the street and, thus, less available curbside space for outdoor tables?

Is it fair to the restaurant that has no street-facing windows — think of those inside Penn Station or Grand Central Terminal, or within a mall or market, for example — that must now compete with restaurants a few blocks away who’ve been given free space and can, perhaps, bring their prices down a little because of it?

These ethical questions apply to every neighborhood and are reason enough for the Council to not only not allow the sheds to fill curbside spaces during the winter, but to do away with them all together.

But in the Belmont neighborhood of the Bronx, where I am chairman of the local Business Improvement District — and also a longtime small business owner — we have additional reasons.

This goes back to a long-term frustration of mine — City Hall and the Council generally treat every neighborhood the same, with the same priorities and challenges, when we all know that every neighborhood in every borough is its own world unto itself. What works in one place doesn’t work in another.

Parking in Belmont — especially along Arthur Ave., an authentic Little Italy — is our most precious shared resource. Approximately 85% of our customers travel here by car; convenient parking is critical to our business model, one where both retail and hospitality draw visitors from across the region.

We are in a transit desert, far from the nearest subway or Metro-North station.

Eliminating parking spaces for a limited number of additional tables, particularly when sidewalk dining is available, risks undermining that balance.

Maybe fighting the Council is a lost cause. So I’m trying a different tactic. I’m asking our restaurants: please don’t put sheds in the parking lanes and thus inconvenience your customers, as well as those of the retail store next door. Just because you can have sheds up all year doesn’t mean you have to.

Who knows? Maybe camaraderie and neighborliness will succeed where the Council’s blindness to our needs failed.

Madonia, chairman of the Belmont Business Improvement District, is former chief of staff to Mayor Mike Bloomberg.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill attends mosque led by Imam accused of Hamas ties

Governor Mikie Sherrill of New Jersey Visits Mosque Led by Imam Under Scrutiny for Alleged Hamas Connections

New Jersey’s Democratic Governor, Mikie Sherrill, recently marked her presence at a…
Democrat Emily Gregory flips long-held Florida GOP House seat that includes Trump's Mar-a-Lago

Democrat Emily Gregory Secures Historic Win in Florida, Capturing GOP Stronghold Including Mar-a-Lago

On Tuesday, Democrats in Florida achieved a significant political shift by capturing…
LA shelter dogs arrive in Chicago to avoid euthanasia after massive animal seizure

Rescued from Euthanasia: LA Shelter Dogs Find New Hope in Chicago After Major Animal Seizure

This week, over 100 dogs were airlifted from Los Angeles, with many…
Air traffic controller involved in deadly LaGuardia plane crash still kept working: 'We have questions'

LaGuardia Crash Sparks Controversy Over Air Traffic Controller’s Continued Employment

In the aftermath of a tragic collision at LaGuardia Airport involving an…
SF house where family was killed hits market for $1.5M

San Francisco Property with Notorious Past Listed for $1.5 Million

A San Francisco residence, which became infamous due to a tragic quadruple…
California Democrats panic as 2 Republicans lead governor's race

California Governor Race Shocker: GOP Candidates Take Unexpected Lead, Democrats Scramble

California Democrats are confronting a daunting challenge in the upcoming 2026 governor’s…
Human Relations Commissioner Nancy Andrade resigns from Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson's administration

Chicago Mayor’s Key Advisor Nancy Andrade Steps Down: Implications for City Leadership

A prominent figure within Mayor Brandon Johnson’s team is set to depart…
Repeat offender with 20+ prior charges allegedly kills 23-year-old in hit-and-run, then walks away

Repeat Offender with 20+ Charges Allegedly Commits Fatal Hit-and-Run of 23-Year-Old, Leaves Scene

A tragic incident in Charlotte has left a 23-year-old woman dead after…
'It's sick' — footage shows masked thugs prowling through posh LA farmers market

Shocking Footage: Masked Intruders Disrupt Upscale LA Farmers Market – What You Need to Know!

A masked gang recorded themselves causing chaos in an organized assault at…
DC Park Police officer shooting arrests two people Darren Foster Asheile Foster

Breaking News: Two Arrested in Connection with DC Park Police Officer Shooting

In a recent development from the nation’s capital, the Metropolitan Police Department…
'House of horrors' suspect accused of holding stepson captive hit with new charges as she denies allegations

New Charges Filed Against ‘House of Horrors’ Suspect Accused of Stepson’s Captivity; She Maintains Innocence

A woman from Connecticut, Kimberly Sullivan, is now facing additional charges in…
Chicago mayor asked about city's immigration policies after illegal immigrant allegedly killed college student

Chicago Mayor Faces Scrutiny on Immigration Policies Following Tragic Death of College Student

On Tuesday, Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson faced questions regarding the city’s immigration…