The death of California’s most recognizable bald eagle has ignited an emotional dispute over where she should rest, as grieving admirers press officials to return her to the mountain habitat that made her a beloved online icon.
Jackie, the famed Big Bear bald eagle whose nest drew millions of viewers on a round-the-clock livestream, died Aug. 10 following three weeks in intensive care and a prolonged struggle with anemia.
Her remains are now expected to be transferred to the National Eagle Repository, a federal facility that supplies eagle feathers, parts and whole bodies to members of federally recognized Native American tribes for religious and cultural use.
For many of Jackie’s loyal followers, that plan has been devastating.
A Change.org petition urging authorities to halt the process and consider a lawful option to preserve Jackie for educational, scientific, conservation or memorial purposes has already collected more than 1,200 signatures.
“I fully respect the purpose of the National Eagle Repository, but before Jackie’s remains are irreversibly separated and distributed, please PAUSE AND FIND a lawful way to bring Jackie Home,” one supporter wrote.
Another supporter urged that Jackie be laid to rest near the tree where she was born and where she spent her life raising eaglets alongside her mate, Shadow.
“She deserves this basic dignity,” the person wrote, saying the idea of her remains being sent elsewhere and “divvied up” was “an intolerably painful thought to bear.”
Sandra Sehl, a 53-year-old Connecticut resident who watched Jackie and Shadow for about seven years, launched one of the petitions.
Sehl told the Los Angeles Times that she envisioned Jackie being taxidermied and displayed beside a replica of her nest so visitors could learn about the famous bird.
“I just want to give her a chance to go back home,” Sehl said. “I think that’s where she would want to go.”
But the campaign has triggered a backlash of its own, with other Jackie fans arguing that her celebrity shouldn’t give her special treatment.
Sherri Griffin wrote a Facebook post criticizing those seeking an exception which has garnered more than 14,000 likes, arguing that doing so would effectively ask officials to bend protections created for Native American communities simply because the public became emotionally attached to Jackie.
“As an Osage Indian eligible to be on the registry, thank you for your educational response and kind words,” one supporter commented on the post. “I assure you we treat Eagles with the highest regard for their revered status between people and Wakondta our ‘Great Spirit’. She will be cared for most likely for generations beyond anyone living today.”
MORE STORY: Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck Reportedly Avoid Awkward Run-In
The National Eagle Repository was established to provide tribal members with eagle materials for religious and cultural practices. Federal protections for bald eagles date back to 1940, when the birds were being slaughtered in large numbers.
There have been rare exceptions for scientific research. Raptor biologist Pete Bloom, for example, previously helped obtain permission to study the bones of an unusually old golden eagle.
But Bloom warned that giving Jackie special treatment could create a major precedent.
Other famous eagles have huge online followings, he noted, meaning fans could make similar demands whenever another celebrity bird dies.
“You now have an additional management issue with not only designating who gets one and who doesn’t but then making sure it stays there,” Bloom told the Los Angeles Times.
The Friends of Big Bear Valley, the nonprofit behind Jackie and Shadow’s livestream, hopes Jackie’s remains will go to the Yuhaaviatam of San Manuel Nation, a tribe with historic ties to Big Bear Valley.
But the organization has acknowledged that the ultimate decision isn’t up to them. The nonprofit is also discussing a possible memorial with local agencies.
Jackie’s death has been especially painful because the eagle was once a rare force for unity.
For years, viewers watched her and Shadow raise their eaglets, turning their nest into an online phenomenon. The nonprofit has even raised more than $10 million to purchase and protect land around the eagles’ home.
But after Jackie was rescued in July and taken to the Ojai Raptor Center, tensions began boiling over. Some fans demanded more information about her condition and accused caretakers of withholding updates. After her death, a new bird’s appearances with Shadow sparked another wave of online speculation.
Wildlife experts say the intense attachment may be part of the problem.
“It’s a good reason for not naming animals,” Bloom said of the infighting. “People get too involved.”
Jenny Voisard, a spokesperson for Friends of Big Bear Valley, pushed back against the idea that the organization’s storytelling created the controversy.
“Virality is difficult,” she told the outlet, arguing that social media algorithms can amplify outrage.
For Jackie’s millions of fans, however, the fight over her remains is anything but a sideshow.
