SANTA ROSA, Calif. — A California woman is suing Costco for over $14 million, alleging that a heavy liquor cabinet display fell on her and caused significant injuries.
Sadie Novotny has initiated the lawsuit against Costco Wholesale Corporation due to an incident on March 22 at its Santa Rosa store in northern California.
Court filings reveal that Novotny was walking through an aisle when she claims a large, heavy cabinet meant for liquor display unexpectedly fell on top of her.
The lawsuit claims Novotny suffered multiple severe and permanent injuries, including a traumatic brain injury. She is seeking $9 million for pain and suffering, $5 million for emotional distress and additional damages for medical expenses and lost wages.
Shoppers emerge from a Costco warehouse late Sunday, Feb. 16, 2025, in Sheridan, Colo.
AP Photo/David Zalubowski
The case, originally filed in Alameda County Superior Court, has been moved to federal court at Costco’s request. A case management conference is scheduled for Sept. 4 at the San Francisco Federal Courthouse.
According to the lawsuit, the cabinet was displayed on what’s described as a defective or worn wooden pallet. The filing argues that this created an unsafe situation for shoppers, claiming the display was “set up in an unreasonably dangerous manner.”
The lawsuit alleges Costco failed to properly inspect and maintain the display, arguing the company should have known about the danger and either fixed it or warned customers about the risk.
ABC News has reached out to Costco Wholesale Corporation for comment.
Claude Armand Wyle, Novotny’s attorney, claimed to ABC News that a Costco representative told him they have a video of the incident, but won’t send it to him to review.
“The employee told me that the video didn’t happen the way I explained it,” Wyle said. “I told her, ‘Well, send it.’ She then said, ‘Oh no, you can only get that video through discovery.'”
“That meant I had to file a lawsuit,” he added. “I couldn’t investigate any further. I was stuck. If I wanted to get to the truth, I had to file a lawsuit.”
Wyle told ABC News that Novotny went to the hospital an hour after the incident after she told her husband she felt “really bad.”
“When she arrived at the hospital, doctors diagnosed her with a concussion,” Wyle said. “She suffered a head injury. We don’t know how bad it is yet.”
Wyle said his client feels slightly better but still suffers from headaches and vision problems.
The lawsuit is seeking compensation for current and future medical expenses, estimated at $2 million, along with lost earnings and future earning capacity losses of approximately $2 million. Additional damages are being sought for loss of household services.
Copyright © 2025 ABC News Internet Ventures.
