Judge rules part of Florida's school book law is unconstitutional

Court Declares Portion of Florida's School Book Law Unconstitutional

U.S. District Judge Carlos Mendoza concentrated on the portion of the law aimed at restricting access to reading materials that “describe sexual conduct.”

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — In favoring publishers and authors, a federal judge on Wednesday found a significant part of a 2023 Florida law resulting in book removals from school libraries to be “overbroad and unconstitutional.”

U.S. District Judge Carlos Mendoza made this ruling in a 50-page document related to a First Amendment lawsuit initiated the previous year against State Board of Education members and the school boards in Orange and Volusia counties, specifically examining the law’s section aiming to limit reading materials “describing sexual conduct.”

The Orlando-based judge observed that the law “fails to assess the work for any comprehensive value” and “does not define the level of detail needed to ‘describe sexual conduct.’”

“According to the plaintiffs, the statute’s prohibitions are ambiguous,” Mendoza noted. “It may disallow content saying characters ‘spent the night together’ or ‘made love.’ It’s uncertain. Defendants haven’t clarified the statute’s intended operation.”

He explained that the Florida Department of Education advised educators to “err on the side of caution,” leading to book removals out of concern that school districts might face repercussions.

“But even a reading of the statute that excludes allusions to sexual activity nevertheless requires the removal of any material that contains even a single sentence that is prohibited by the statute — with no consideration of its overall value,” Mendoza wrote.

Six publishing companies, The Authors Guild, five authors and two parents filed the lawsuit in August 2024 amid controversies in many areas of the state about decisions by school districts to remove books from library shelves or restrict access.

The law (HB 1069) set up a process in which parents could object to reading material that is “pornographic” or “depicts or describes sexual conduct.” It required books that received such objections to be removed within five days and to remain unavailable until the objections were resolved.

In fighting the lawsuit, the state’s attorneys argued, in part, that the selection of library books is “government speech” and not subject to the First Amendment. But Mendoza rejected that argument Wednesday, saying “the removal of library books without consideration of their overall value cannot be expressive activity amounting to government speech.”

“A blanket content-based prohibition on materials, rather than one based on individualized curation, hardly expresses any intentional government message at all,” Mendoza wrote. “Slapping the label of government speech on book removals only serves to stifle the disfavored viewpoints.”

The judge also cited the role of parental objections in driving decisions to remove books.

“To be sure, parents have the right to ‘direct the upbringing and education of children,’ but the government cannot repackage their speech and pass it off as its own,” he wrote, partially quoting a U.S. Supreme Court precedent.

Mendoza also approved interpreting the word “pornographic” in the law as being “synonymous with ‘harmful to minors’ under Florida law.”

The lawsuit cited removals from library shelves of numerous books, such as “The Bluest Eye” by Toni Morrison and “Love in the Time of Cholera” by Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Both of those authors were awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature for their novels and other work.

The plaintiffs in the case are publishing companies Penguin Random House LLC, Hachette Book Group, Inc., HarperCollins Publishers LLC, Macmillan Publishing Group, LLC, Simon & Schuster, LLC and Sourcebooks LLC; The Authors Guild; authors Julia Alvarez, John Green, Laurie Halse Anderson, Jodi Picoult and Angie Thomas; and parents Heidi Kellogg and Judith Anne Hayes.

This story was first published by News Service of Florida.

You May Also Like

Everything to know about 2026 CMAs, from who's performing to how to watch

2026 CMA Awards: Performers, How to Watch and Everything to Know

The 60th Annual CMA Awards are only days away, bringing together some…
DHS chief Markwayne Mullin insists the ‘homeland is secure’ as tech outages hit airline and banking industries

DHS Chief Mullin Says US Secure Amid Airline and Bank Outages

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin sought to reassure Americans Monday, saying the…
Drilling incident sparks explosion at Chiquita Canyon Landfill

Explosion at Chiquita Canyon Landfill Triggered by Drilling Incident

A sudden explosion at a California landfill sent a dense plume of…
Slain woman, 24, discovered on wooded Louisiana walking trail, as her missing dog is found

Slain Louisiana Woman, 24, Found on Wooded Trail; Missing Dog Located

The body of a 24-year-old woman was found “lying in the leaves”…
Illegal alien accused of attempted murder at large after Rikers release despite ICE detainer: DHS

DHS: Migrant Attempted Murder Suspect Freed Despite ICE Detainer

A Guyanese national living in the United States unlawfully remains at large…
Elderly homeowner’s hired help turns into squatter nightmare made worse by blue state laws: report

Elderly Homeowner Says Hired Helper Became Squatter as Blue State Laws Complicate Eviction: Report

A 76-year-old California homeowner says a man she hired to repair plumbing…
Democratic judge under fire for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a ‘direct assault’ on rights

Democratic Judge Slammed Over Violent Releases Blasts Bail Law

An Alabama Democratic judge under growing scrutiny for past decisions involving violent…
Ecuador's president denies US operates military base despite reports of troop buildup

Ecuador’s President Denies US Base Amid Troop Buildup Reports

Trump steps up campaign against drug cartels in Ecuador Dana Perino examines…
Amtrak stops all train service around Washington DC after person struck on the tracks

Amtrak Halts DC-Area Train Service After Person Struck on Tracks

A person was fatally struck by a train just outside Washington, D.C.,…
La Jolla lifeguard rescues stranded bodyboarder in high surf

La Jolla Lifeguard Rescues Stranded Bodyboarder in High Surf

A rescuer being hailed as the “Michael Jordan of lifeguards” was captured…
French troops secretly deployed inside Ukraine as ex-NATO chief praises Macron's 'guts'

French Troops Said Deployed in Ukraine; Ex-NATO Chief Hails Macron

French troops have reportedly been operating covertly inside Ukraine for months, training…
Massive El Niño-powered wave in Morro Bay wipes out group on shore

Massive El Niño Wave Sweeps Group Off Shore at Morro Bay

Massive waves reaching up to 30 feet battered California’s Central Coast over…