First off, I really don’t listen to K-pop, J-pop, or any kind of pop, but I have to say something on this. 

The recent controversy involving K-pop group Kiss of Life’s hip-hop-themed live stream has ignited intense debate, with allegations of cultural mockery and racism aimed at the group. The four members—Julie, Natty, Belle, and Haneul—celebrated Julie’s 25th birthday on April 2 with a YouTube live stream that embraced “old-school hip-hop vibes.” They wore oversized chains, snapback hats, and cornrows, lip-synced to 50 Cent’s “In Da Club,” and adopted nicknames such as “Lil Taco Belle” and “Bob Sky.” The backlash was immediate, with some fans labeling it as “modern-day blackface” and others accusing the group of treating Black culture like a “Halloween costume.” Kiss of Life issued a heartfelt apology on April 5, acknowledging their cultural insensitivity and pledging to educate themselves. However, this incident prompts a broader question: when does cultural appreciation become racism, and are judgments too hasty?

Never Forget ✊🏾 pic.twitter.com/wBVt0AqwS6

— sage (@hissirenseong) May 13, 2025

From a Kansas man’s viewpoint, the rush to label this incident as racist neglects the group’s stated intent and the complexities of cultural exchange. Kiss of Life highlighted that their objective was to celebrate old-school hip-hop, a genre that significantly influences their music. Hip-hop, originating in Black communities, has evolved into a global phenomenon, influencing music, fashion, and culture worldwide. For a K-pop group to draw inspiration from it is not innately malicious. The members’ choice of attire and playful nicknames, albeit possibly misguided, represents an effort to honor a style they admire rather than to mock or demean it. Accusing them of racism presumes ill intent without proof, overlooking the possibility that their misstep resulted from ignorance instead of malice.

Kiss of Life really ruined their whole career with one live.

— вrie ⁸ ♡ SEEING SKZ & ATZ VIP!! (@3hyunyeol) May 16, 2025