Murdaugh murder retrial could crack open sealed court records tied to infamous ‘egg juror’

The Attorney General’s Office of South Carolina is pushing for transparency by requesting the Supreme Court to release confidential court transcripts related to the dismissal of a juror, known as the “egg juror,” in Murdaugh’s case. They contend that these documents should be accessible to the public following the decision to grant Murdaugh a new trial.

Prosecutors have filed a motion urging the high court to reverse its previous stance and permit the disclosure of the in-camera hearing transcript that led to the disqualification of Juror 785, previously identified as Myra Crosby, just before jury deliberations commenced in Murdaugh’s 2023 trial for double murder.

This motion is the latest development in the aftermath of the overturned convictions of the influential South Carolina lawyer, accused of the June 2021 murders of his wife, Maggie, and their son, Paul, at their vast Moselle estate.

Myra Crosby gained the moniker “Egg Juror” after her light-hearted request to retrieve her purse and a dozen eggs, which sparked laughter in the courtroom, as she was dismissed from the case by Judge Clifton Newman.

Crosby became known as the “egg juror” after she was removed from the panel. As Judge Clifton Newman dismissed her from the case, Crosby asked if she could retrieve her purse and a dozen eggs that another juror had brought to court to give away, prompting laughter in the courtroom.

The South Carolina Supreme Court reversed Murdaugh’s two murder convictions on May 13. The remittitur was issued May 29, formally sending the murder case back to the lower court for further proceedings.

Prosecutors noted that, as of the filing, no circuit court judge had yet been appointed to preside over Murdaugh’s new murder proceedings.

Myra Crosby, known as the Egg Juror, exits the Colleton County courthouse in Walterboro, S.C., on March 2, 2023, after being dismissed for misconduct from the Alex Murdaugh double murder trial by Judge Clifton Newman. (Larry Paci for News Agency)

According to prosecutors, the sealed transcript details a private hearing where Newman removed Crosby from the jury for allegedly discussing the case prematurely.

Those records were initially sealed and restricted under protective orders entered by Newman and later continued by retired South Carolina Chief Justice Jean Toal, who was assigned to preside over Murdaugh’s bid for a new trial after allegations surfaced against former Colleton County Clerk of Court Rebecca “Becky” Hill.

The state said those restrictions previously barred publication or dissemination of the transcript, even though attorneys for the parties and Crosby’s counsel were permitted to review the material.

Alex Murdaugh is escorted from the Colleton County Courthouse in South Carolina on Feb. 8, 2023. (Mark Sims for News Agency)

Crosby has continued to request that the transcripts be unsealed. In September 2024, prosecutors objected, arguing the request was premature because the appeal had not yet been resolved.

The state’s Supreme Court once again denied Crosby’s request in October 2024. But prosecutors now say the posture of the case has changed dramatically.

“Here, a new trial has been granted to Appellant,” the filing states. “There should be no prejudice to any party at this time. Consequently, the scales should now tip to unsealing and removing restrictions.”

Convicted murderer Alex Murdaugh pleaded guilty to 22 financial crimes in Beaufort, S.C., on Nov. 17, 2023. (James Pollard/AP)

The state’s motion says the request is “not about litigation” but instead about public access to court records maintained by the state’s Supreme Court.

The filing asks the Supreme Court to allow the previously protected transcripts from Newman’s private proceedings “supporting the removal of Juror 785” to be filed as a supplement to the public appellate record.

Prosecutors also asked the court to declare prior restrictions on sharing, discussing or disclosing the contents of the transcript moot, which would allow the parties and Crosby to speak publicly about the matter without violating earlier court orders.

The motion comes just weeks after Crosby separately fought to crack open sealed investigative records related to the jury-tampering scandal that helped upend Murdaugh’s convictions.

In that filing, Crosby argued that the public interest would be best served by transparency now that prosecutors have acknowledged the jury-tampering investigation into Hill did not result in criminal charges.

Hill was accused by Murdaugh’s defense team of improperly influencing jurors to secure a guilty verdict. She has denied tampering with the jury.

Murdaugh’s attorneys have argued that Hill’s alleged conduct, including her interactions with jurors, deprived him of a fair trial. The defense has also alleged Crosby’s dismissal was part of a broader effort that affected the makeup of the jury before deliberations.

Toal rejected Murdaugh’s request for a new trial in January 2024 after an evidentiary hearing, finding that although Hill made improper comments to jurors, the defense had not proven that her conduct affected the verdict.

The South Carolina Supreme Court later took up the case and ultimately granted Murdaugh a new trial based on Hill’s interactions with jurors.

Alex Murdaugh standing in a booking photo next to an aerial view of McCormick Correctional Institution

Alex Murdaugh is incarcerated at the McCormick Correctional Institution in South Carolina. (South Carolina Department of Corrections)

Murdaugh, 57, remains imprisoned after pleading guilty to a series of financial crimes that exposed years of theft from clients, his former law firm and the estate of his late housekeeper.

His murder case, however, is now headed back to court.

The South Carolina Attorney General’s Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Mother charged with murder for refusing to give toddler son cancer care

Mother Charged With Murder After Refusing Cancer Treatment for Toddler Son

The mother of a 3-year-old boy who died weighing just 24 pounds…
VIDEO: Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

The Big Ten handed down suspensions to nine hockey players Saturday after…
Zelenskyy says Russia strikes hometown, criticizes Putin-Trump meeting

Zelenskyy Says Russia Struck His Hometown, Criticizes Putin-Trump Meeting

Democratic leaders condemn Trump after Putin-Xi summit in China Steve Yates defended…
Ex-White House press secretary Katie Zacharia criticizes GOP over midterm losses, says party isn’t ‘good at winning’

Ex-White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia Says GOP Can’t Win

Former White House press secretary Katie Zacharia delivered a candid critique of…
Aerial footage shows damage to key bridge in Crimea, Ukraine

European Intel: Ukraine Deals Blow to Putin’s Crimea Lifeline

Putin reportedly ‘very frustrated’ as Ukrainian strikes damage vital Kerch Bridge Fox…
Three killed, one injured in shooting at Ohio baby shower, police say

Ohio Baby Shower Shooting Leaves 3 Dead, 1 Injured, Police Say

Three people were killed in a Saturday shooting at an entertainment venue…
Pelosi dares to utter 'villain' Trump's name in interview

Nancy Pelosi Calls Trump a ‘Villain’ During New Interview

Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) broke her long-standing vow this week…
Masked ICE agents drag passengers off Seattle jet bridge, delaying LA flight

ICE Agents Drag Passengers Off Seattle Jet Bridge, Delay LA Flight

A Thanksgiving trip descended into an airport confrontation after masked ICE agents…
The Post’s 225 icons: George Washington’s surprise attack was America’s greatest Christmas gift

George Washington’s Surprise Attack: Why the Post Calls It America’s Greatest Christmas Gift

As The New York Post marks its 225th birthday, we’re celebrating the…
Florida man sentenced to death for 'cold, calculated' murder of attorney whose body was never found

Florida Man Gets Death for Attorney Murder, Body Never Found

A former Florida plastic surgeon who represented himself in court was sentenced…
SF Mayor Daniel Lurie issues dire weather warning to Thanksgiving travelers

San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie Issues Dire Weather Warning for Thanksgiving Travelers

San Francisco residents may not have seen the worst of extreme flooding…
Jewish legal group urges US to strip visa from Calvin Robinson

Jewish Legal Group Seeks US Visa Revocation for UK Cleric Calvin Robinson

The American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists has asked Yehuda Kaploun,…