Share this @internewscast.com

A federal appeals court on Wednesday shot down former President Donald Trump’s attempt to use presidential immunity in the upcoming E. Jean Carroll defamation trial, finding he’d waited too long to raise the defense.

Trump had argued he couldn’t be sued for the 2019 comments he made about the writer and her sexual assault claims against him because he was president at the time he made them and, he contended, they related to his duties because he needed to speak out and assure the public her accusations were untrue.

In a unanimous ruling, a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found Trump had waited too long — three years —to raise the defense.

“We hold that presidential immunity is waivable and that Defendant waived this defense,” the ruling said.

The panel noted that Carroll first filed her defamation suit in November of 2019 and Trump filed his response in January of 2020. He didn’t raise the presidential immunity defense until January of 2023. To allow him to use the defense now would cause “undue prejudice” to Carroll, the judges said.

Trump attorney Alina Habba said the court’s ruling “is fundamentally flawed and we will continue to pursue justice and appropriate resolution.”

Carroll lawyer Roberta Kaplan said she was “pleased” with the decision and “that we can now move forward with trial next month on January 16.”

The trial will be Carroll’s second against the former president. In the other, she accused Trump of raping her during an encounter in the dressing room of a New York department store in the 1990s and then defaming her after he left office by calling her claims a made-up “con job.”

That jury found Trump had sexually abused and defamed Carroll, and awarded her $5 million in damages in May.

That case, which the judge has referred to as Carroll II, had actually been filed before the case going to trial in January. The one that was the subject of Wednesday’s ruling was initially tied up in appeals over whether Trump’s 2019 comments were protected under the Westfall Act, which gives federal employees “absolute immunity” from lawsuits based on conduct “in the course of their official duties.”

U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan has found Trump liable for defaming Carroll given the verdict in the earlier trial, so January’s trial will be focused solely on what money damages Carroll is entitled to. Kaplan denied Trump’s immunity argument in a ruling in June, where he wrote that presidential immunity is “not a ‘get out of damages liability free’ card.”

Trump has also raised presidential immunity as defense in the criminal election interference case brought against him by special counsel Jack Smith. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan ruled earlier this month that he was not immune to the criminal charges. Trump has appealed that ruling to the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., and Smith has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to decide the matter.

Trump has pleaded not guilty in the election case.

 

 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Chemical plant emitting smoke over a grassy field.

Residents Frustrated by Year-Long Odor Issue from Rendering Plant Causing Unbearable ‘Rotting Flesh’ Smell

RESIDENTS of one city have been plagued by a foul-smelling issue for…
Woman found dead in clothing donation box: Florida cops

Florida Authorities Investigate Woman Discovered Deceased in Donation Box

A homeless woman was discovered deceased in a clothing donation box in…
Breaking: US Senate Holds Procedural Vote on Trump 'One Big Beautiful Bill'

Update: US Senate Conducts Initial Vote on Trump’s ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’

On Saturday evening, the U.S. Senate made an initial yet significant advance…
Antoine Massey captured by US Marshals, Groves remains on run

Antoine Massey Arrested by US Marshals, While Groves Still at Large

Massey’s capture ends a weeks-long manhunt; fugitive Derrick Groves is now the…
UK authorities seize cocaine worth more than $130 million from a ship at London port

UK Officials Confiscate Over $130 Million in Cocaine from Ship at London Port

British authorities seized 2.4 metric tons of cocaine in a ship arriving…
Iranian foreign minister reiterates 'serious damage' to nuclear facilities, despite ayatollah's comments

Iran’s Foreign Minister Emphasizes Significant Harm to Nuclear Facilities, Countering Ayatollah’s Statements

Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi admitted in an interview on state TV…
University of Newcastle upon Tyne campus.

Government Funds Allocated for Research on Whiteness and Support for Women Labeled as ‘Witches’

TAXPAYERS’ cash is being blown on studying whiteness in South America and…
Chicago protesters oppose ICE, Alejandro Orellana charges; Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi introduces bill to limit military deployments

Chicago Demonstrators Rally Against ICE; Alejandro Orellana Faces Charges; Congressman Raja Krishnamoorthi Proposes Legislation to Restrict Military Deployments

CHICAGO (WLS) — Another protest against ICE got underway in downtown Chicago…
Israel-Iran latest: Week of shifting descriptions of US attack on Iran spark ongoing questions about extent of damage, goals

Recent Developments in Israel-Iran Tensions: A Week of Changing Reports on US Strike Raises Questions About Damage and Objectives

WASHINGTON — One week after President Donald Trump authorized an attack on…
It’s Time to Pass the Big Beautiful Bill to Unlock the Golden Era of American Housing

Unlock a New Golden Era in American Housing: Pass the Game-Changing Bill Now

By Daniel Keenan A family that frequently comes to mind is the…
Shedeur Sanders already low on Browns' QB depth chart

Shedeur Sanders Drops Further Down Browns’ Quarterback List

It looks like Shedeur Sanders is finding himself in some struggles in…
Israeli strikes in Gaza kill at least 49 people as ceasefire talks inch closer

Israeli Airstrikes in Gaza Claim at Least 49 Lives Amid Ceasefire Negotiations

The strikes come as U.S. President Donald Trump says there could be…