Share this @internewscast.com

A federal appeals court on Wednesday shot down former President Donald Trump’s attempt to use presidential immunity in the upcoming E. Jean Carroll defamation trial, finding he’d waited too long to raise the defense.

Trump had argued he couldn’t be sued for the 2019 comments he made about the writer and her sexual assault claims against him because he was president at the time he made them and, he contended, they related to his duties because he needed to speak out and assure the public her accusations were untrue.

In a unanimous ruling, a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found Trump had waited too long — three years —to raise the defense.

“We hold that presidential immunity is waivable and that Defendant waived this defense,” the ruling said.

The panel noted that Carroll first filed her defamation suit in November of 2019 and Trump filed his response in January of 2020. He didn’t raise the presidential immunity defense until January of 2023. To allow him to use the defense now would cause “undue prejudice” to Carroll, the judges said.

Trump attorney Alina Habba said the court’s ruling “is fundamentally flawed and we will continue to pursue justice and appropriate resolution.”

Carroll lawyer Roberta Kaplan said she was “pleased” with the decision and “that we can now move forward with trial next month on January 16.”

The trial will be Carroll’s second against the former president. In the other, she accused Trump of raping her during an encounter in the dressing room of a New York department store in the 1990s and then defaming her after he left office by calling her claims a made-up “con job.”

That jury found Trump had sexually abused and defamed Carroll, and awarded her $5 million in damages in May.

That case, which the judge has referred to as Carroll II, had actually been filed before the case going to trial in January. The one that was the subject of Wednesday’s ruling was initially tied up in appeals over whether Trump’s 2019 comments were protected under the Westfall Act, which gives federal employees “absolute immunity” from lawsuits based on conduct “in the course of their official duties.”

U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan has found Trump liable for defaming Carroll given the verdict in the earlier trial, so January’s trial will be focused solely on what money damages Carroll is entitled to. Kaplan denied Trump’s immunity argument in a ruling in June, where he wrote that presidential immunity is “not a ‘get out of damages liability free’ card.”

Trump has also raised presidential immunity as defense in the criminal election interference case brought against him by special counsel Jack Smith. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan ruled earlier this month that he was not immune to the criminal charges. Trump has appealed that ruling to the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., and Smith has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to decide the matter.

Trump has pleaded not guilty in the election case.

 

 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Convicted Minnesota sex offender, 22, accused of posing as high school student on football team

Minnesota Sex Offender, 22, Allegedly Impersonated High School Football Player

A 22-year-old man with a criminal history of indecent exposure allegedly posed…
Massive fire erupts at Chevron refinery near Los Angeles

Huge blaze breaks out at Chevron refinery near Los Angeles

A fire erupted at the Chevron oil refinery near Los Angeles on…
Trump administration cuts nearly $8B in clean energy projects in blue states

Trump Administration Reduces Clean Energy Funding by $8 Billion in Democratic-Leaning States

The Trump administration is cutting $7.6 billion in grants that funded numerous…
Starmer’s digital ID work requirement sparks uproar from UK's left and right

Starmer’s Proposal for Digital ID Work Requirement Faces Backlash Across UK Political Spectrum

The United Kingdom’s political spectrum, from right-wing to left-wing, has united in…
Homeowners await Rebuild Florida aid 8 years after Irma

Eight Years After Irma, Homeowners Still Waiting for Rebuild Florida Assistance

State Senator Clay Yarborough is calling for action after seeing firsthand the…
Trump uses government shutdown to dole out firings and political punishment

Trump Utilizes Government Shutdown to Issue Terminations and Political Reprimands

President Donald Trump has taken advantage of the government shutdown as a…
Jacksonville man arrested for possession of CSAM

Jacksonville Resident Charged with CSAM Possession

Police said that the man had over 400 files on various devices…
UK synagogue attack and Hamas hostage crisis underscore deadly Yom Kippur

Deadly Yom Kippur Marked by UK Synagogue Attack and Hamas Hostage Crisis

The ongoing menace of antisemitism was tragically highlighted on Thursday when two…
Israel claims Greta Thunberg's flotilla seeking to break Gaza blockade has Hamas ties, cites documents

Israel Alleges Greta Thunberg’s Flotilla Attempting to Break Gaza Blockade is Linked to Hamas, According to Documents

Israel says it has proof linking Hamas to the Global Sumud Flotilla…
Russian leader responds to American conservative's murder: 'A disgusting atrocity'

Russian President Condemns the Killing of U.S Conservative: ‘Appalling Act’

Russian President Vladimir Putin expressed his views on Thursday, describing the assassination…
Prince William gives rare Kate Middleton cancer update in vulnerable talk with Eugene Levy

Prince William Shares Heartfelt Update on Kate Middleton’s Cancer Journey in Candid Conversation with Eugene Levy

Prince William provides a rare update on his wife, Kate Middleton, after…
Missing woman's body found behind secret attic entrance in Northern California home

Remains of Missing Woman Discovered Behind Hidden Attic Door in Northern California House

Police say they found the body of a missing woman behind a…