Nancy Guthrie ransom notes exposes sick plot against family, ex-FBI agent claims

Newly surfaced ransom notes, allegedly tied to the kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie, have come to light, adding another layer of distress to her already anguished family. These notes, which were sent to TMZ, claim knowledge of both the identity of her abductors and the location of her remains. A former FBI agent has characterized this as a devious scheme to exploit the family’s grief for quick financial gain.

The timing of these disturbing communications is particularly telling. They arrived just as Savannah Guthrie, Nancy’s daughter, resumed her duties on NBC’s “Today” show after a two-month hiatus following her mother’s disappearance. This calculated move appears designed to further unsettle the family during an already challenging period.

Jennifer Coffindaffer, a former FBI agent, explained to Newsweek, “The timing of these messages was no accident. Sending them as Savannah returned to work was a deliberate attempt to inflict more pain on her and her family.” She added, “It’s clear there’s at least one individual intent on perpetuating this family’s suffering without offering any concrete proof of life.”


A photo of Nancy Guthrie on display at a TV station with handwritten notes and prayers from the public.
Purported ransom notes reveal a sick plot to continue to “torment” Nancy Guthrie’s family for a quick profit, according to a former FBI agent. Getty Images

Nancy Guthrie, who is 84 years old, went missing on February 1st, and investigators suspect she was abducted from her Tucson, Arizona home. Since then, a series of supposed ransom demands have emerged, with several reaching TMZ, but none have provided evidence of her current whereabouts or condition.

Guthrie, 84, has been missing since Feb. 1 after authorities believed she was kidnapped from her home in Tucson, Arizona.

Since her disappearance, multiple purported ransom notes have been reported — including several sent to TMZ.

The pair of notes received by the outlet on Monday was sent from the same anonymous person who, nearly two months ago, demanded one bitcoin in exchange for information related to Guthrie’s abduction.

The first note claimed that Guthrie was dead — but the sender said that their offer to “deliver [the kidnappers] on a silver platter” for the cryptocurrency still stands.

In a second note, they claimed to have seen Guthrie alive with her captors in the Mexican state of Sonora, just across the border from Arizona.


Savannah Guthrie and her siblings making a statement regarding their mother Nancy's disappearance.
The purported notes were sent just as Savannah Guthrie made her “Today” show return. Instagram / Savannah Guthrie

The person said they will surrender the information for half a bitcoin, with another half transferred to their wallet when there is a public arrest.

Coffander believes they’re lying about having any real information because they’re shooting for a single bitcoin, valued at about $71,000, rather than the massive reward that’s been offered by Guthrie’s family and law enforcement agencies.

“The reason this makes sense to me, that they don’t have that knowledge, is because they’re not seeking the $1.2 million. Instead, they’re trying to subvert it with this… quickly paid, no hoops to jump through, just get the money. But I think that these people are scammers.”

You May Also Like
Missing teen Marly Kinney ID'd as body found in Kentucky lake

Authorities Identify Body Found in Kentucky Lake as Missing Teen Marly Kinney

Authorities in Kentucky say the body of a missing teenager has been…
Gallagher Way in Wrigleyville, Chicago hosts free tennis event before Wimbledon 2026 kicks off in London

Gallagher Way in Chicago’s Wrigleyville to Host Free Tennis Event Ahead of Wimbledon 2026

CHICAGO (WLS) — Tennis fans of all ages gathered at Gallagher Way…
Dangerous chemicals, 55-gallon drum, note mentioning Ted Bundy found at home of Philadelphia felon linked to 2 missing women

Dangerous Chemicals and Ted Bundy Note Found at Philadelphia Felon’s Home Linked to Missing Women

A Philadelphia felon under investigation for possible connections to at least two…
Gun-wielding St. Louis couple in viral 2020 BLM standoff speak out after legal saga

St. Louis Couple Armed in Viral 2020 BLM Protest Speaks Out After Legal Battle

A pair of armed homeowners standing outside their St. Louis residence became…
Video shows crocodile that killed Puerto Vallarta man in front of California couple — as new details emerge

Video Shows Crocodile in Fatal Puerto Vallarta Attack Witnessed by California Couple

Disturbing new footage has emerged showing the enormous crocodile believed to have…
Explosive confidential letter reveals why LAUSD chief Alberto Carvalho suddenly resigned

Confidential Letter Reveals Why LAUSD Superintendent Alberto Carvalho Abruptly Resigned

A private letter delivered to Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto…
Mystery as US Marine vanishes off massive ship off California coast

U.S. Marine Missing After Disappearing From Ship Off California Coast

A U.S. Marine is missing after disappearing from an amphibious Navy vessel…
Iran targets US with psychological warfare campaign to manipulate Americans, embarrass Trump: experts

Experts Say Iran Is Using Psychological Warfare to Influence Americans and Undermine Trump

Iranian regime’s ‘hardline rhetoric’ under fire as US deal nears President Donald…
Marine missing from USS Anchorage now focus of recovery mission off California coast

Search for Marine Missing From USS Anchorage Shifts to Recovery Mission Off California Coast

The search for a Marine who disappeared from the USS Anchorage during…
Midair parachute collision leads to tragedy for experienced skydiver

France Skydiving Plane Crash: Investigators Probe Fatal Disaster That Killed Pilot and 10 Parachutists

Plane crash in Missouri kills 11 skydivers and pilot Authorities in France…
Chicago heat wave: Chicago weather tomorrow includes Extreme Heat Warning, Heat Advisory for high heat index values

Chicago Weather Alert: Extreme Heat Warning Starts Monday as Dangerous Temperatures Move In

CHICAGO (WLS) — A stretch of dangerous heat is expected to settle…
Chicago heat wave: Chicago weather tomorrow includes Extreme Heat Warning, Heat Advisory for high heat index values

Chicago Heat Wave: Extreme Heat Warning and Heat Advisory in Effect Tomorrow as Heat Index Climbs

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago is bracing for a stretch of dangerous heat…