Federal judge strikes down workplace protections for transgender workers
Share this @internewscast.com

A federal judge in Texas has invalidated a government agency’s guidance that established workplace harassment protections related to gender identity and sexual orientation.

On Thursday, Judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas ruled that the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) had overstepped its legal powers. This decision followed the EEOC’s issuance of guidelines that advised employers against intentionally misusing pronouns for employees, denying access to restrooms that align with employees’ gender identities, and forbidding the wearing of attire that adheres to dress codes based on gender identity. These acts were emphasized as potential forms of workplace harassment.

The 1964 Civil Rights Act’s Title VII safeguards employees and job seekers from discriminatory practices in employment based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin.


Judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk struck down guidance from a government agency establishing protections against workplace harassment based on gender identity and sexual orientation. AP

The EEOC, which enforces workplace anti-discrimination laws, had updated its guidance on workplace harassment in April of last year under President Joe Biden for the first time in 25 years.

It followed a 2020 Supreme Court ruling that gay, lesbian and transgender people are protected from employment discrimination.

Texas and the Heritage Foundation, the conservative think tank behind Project 2025, in August challenged the guidance, which the agency says serves as a tool for employers to assess compliance with anti-discrimination laws and is not legally binding.

Kacsmaryk disagreed, writing that the guidance creates “mandatory standards … from which legal consequences will necessarily flow if an employer fails to comply.”

The decision marks the latest blow to workplace protections for transgender workers following President Donald Trump’s Jan. 20 executive order declaring that the government would recognize only two “immutable” sexes — male and female.

Kacsmaryk, a 2017 Trump nominee, invalidated all portions of the EEOC guidance that defines “sex” to include “sexual orientation” and “gender identity,” along with an entire section addressing the subject.


This follows the 2020 Supreme Court ruling that gay, lesbian, and transgender people are protected from employment discrimination. Bloomberg via Getty Images

“Title VII does not require employers or courts to blind themselves to the biological differences between men and women,” he wrote in the opinion.

Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts commended the decision in an emailed statement: “The Biden EEOC tried to compel businesses — and the American people — to deny basic biological truth. Today, thanks to the great state of Texas and the work of my Heritage colleagues, a federal judge said: not so fast.”

He added: “This ruling is more than a legal victory. It’s a cultural one. It says no — you don’t have to surrender common sense at the altar of leftist ideology. You don’t have to pretend men are women.”

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton also touted the victory against “Biden’s ‘Pronoun Police’ Rule” in a Friday press release, saying: “The federal government has no right to force Texans to play along with delusions or ignore biological reality in our workplaces.”

The National Women’s Law Center, which filed an amicus brief in November in support of the harassment guidance, blasted the decision in an emailed statement.

“The district court’s decision is an outrage and blatantly at odds with Supreme Court precedent,” said Liz Theran, senior director of litigation for education and workplace justice at NWLC.

“The EEOC’s Harassment Guidance reminds employers and workers alike to do one simple thing that should cost no one anything: refrain from degrading others on the job based on their identity and who they love. This decision does not change the law, but it will make it harder for LGBTQIA+ workers to enforce their rights and experience a workplace free from harassment.”

Kacsmaryk offered a more narrow interpretation of Bostock v. Clayton County, the landmark Supreme Court case that established discrimination protections for LGBTQ+ workers, saying in his decision that the Supreme Court “firmly refused to expand the definition of ‘sex’ beyond the biological binary,” and found only that employers could not fire workers for being gay or transgender.

Employment attorney Jonathan Segal, a partner at Duane Morris who advises companies on how best to comply with anti-discrimination laws, emphasized that legal minds may disagree on the scope of Bostock, and Kacsmaryk’s decision is just one interpretation.

“If you assume that a transgender employee has no rights beyond not being fired for transgender status, you are likely construing their rights too narrowly under both federal and state law,” which would put employers in a risky position, Segal said.

And regardless of whether explicit guidance is in place, employers still need to address gender identity conflicts in the workplace, according to Tiffany Stacy, an Ogletree Deakins attorney in San Antonio who defends employers against claims of workplace discrimination.

“From a management perspective, employers should be prepared to diffuse those situations,” Stacy said.

The EEOC in fiscal year 2024 received more than 3,000 charges alleging discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity, and 3,000-plus in 2023, according to the agency’s website.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
The Big, Beautiful Bill Has Some Suprising Benefits for Alaska

Alaska Reaps Unexpected Benefits from the New Legislation

The expansive, ambitious Bill is currently navigating its way through Congress, and…
Lifeguard Charles Leto, 55, charged with murder after Laquan McDonald's cousin shot, Marjay Dotson killed at Douglass Park: report

Lifeguard Charles Leto, 55, accused of murder after shooting Laquan McDonald’s cousin, Marjay Dotson, fatally in Douglass Park: Report

CHICAGO (WLS) — A lifeguard has now been charged with murder and…
Bears escape wildlife park enclosure and feast on week's worth of honey

Bears Break Free from Wildlife Park Enclosure and Enjoy Week-Long Honey Feast

In a scene reminiscent of “Winnie the Pooh,” two young bears that…
Revealed: The extensive perks UN officials receive amid budget crisis

Uncovered: The Generous Benefits Enjoyed by UN Officials Despite Financial Struggles

United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres has tasked staff with reducing budgets in…
New Florida law requires heart screenings for high school athletes

Florida Implements Mandatory Heart Screenings for High School Athletes

Florida high schoolers will have to get an electrocardiogram before taking the…
Luis Severino trying to block out trade noise amid uncertain A's future

Luis Severino Focuses on Game Amidst Trade Speculations and A’s Uncertain Future

As expected, the A’s are having another rough season.  What might have…
Chicago Pride Bowl LGBTQ+ flag football tournament held at Montrose Beach, presented by Metropolitan Sports Association, Bears

Chicago Pride Bowl LGBTQ+ Flag Football Tournament Takes Place at Montrose Beach, Hosted by Metropolitan Sports Association and Bears

CHICAGO (WLS) — This weekend marked Pride in Chicago, and in addition…
Wooden steps leading to Cabarita Beach in New South Wales, Australia.

Shark Attack at Popular Beach: Teen Boy Sustains Severe Arm Injuries and Rushed to Hospital

A TEENAGE boy has been mauled by a shark at a popular…
Baseball legend Dave Parker dies at 74

Baseball Icon Dave Parker Passes Away at Age 74

Dave Parker, nicknamed “the Cobra,” played for the Pittsburgh Pirates, Cincinnati, Milwaukee,…
Funeral held for Adriana Smith, who gave birth while on life support

Adriana Smith, Who Gave Birth on Life Support, Honored at Funeral

Lawmakers, nurses and family paid tribute to Adriana Smith during her funeral…
Russia launched its largest aerial attack of the war, Ukraine says

Ukraine Reports Russia Conducts Largest Aerial Assault of the War

Russia launched its biggest aerial attack overnight since the start of the…
The damaged interior of a sunken superyacht.

Interior of luxurious superyacht ‘Bayesian’ unveiled as chaotic mess after seabed recovery

HAUNTING pictures of the Bayesian superyacht’s wrecked interior have been revealed –…