In a significant move, a New York federal judge has assumed control over the problematic Rikers Island jail complex, known as one of the largest and most well-known jails in the country, currently holding about 7,000 inmates.
In a 77-page decision, Judge Laura Taylor Swain decreed that the infamous jail, along with the entire jail system of the city, would be overseen by an independent officer accountable only to the court. She reached this decision after determining that the conditions within the jail remain dangerously unconstitutional, citing ongoing failures by the NYC Department of Correction (DOC) leadership to carry out court-ordered reforms.
“The unsafe and dangerous conditions in the jails… have become normalized despite the fact that they are clearly abnormal and unacceptable,” Swain noted.
The entrance to Rikers Island. A federal judge in New York has taken the extraordinary step of seizing control of the jail complex, one of the nation’s largest and most famous jails, which houses around 7,000 criminals. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
New York City Mayor Eric Adams had vigorously opposed a federal takeover but said on Tuesday that he would comply with the federal judge’s decision.
“If the federal judge made a determination that they want to do something else and they don’t like what we’re doing, it’s a federal judgement,” Adams said at a press briefing Tuesday on a different issue. “We’re going to follow the rules.”
In 2017, former Mayor Bill de Blasio initiated a plan to close the prison within 10 years aimed at reducing the city’s jail population and replacing Rikers with four modern, borough-based jails located in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx. De Blasio said the goal was to address systemic injustice, improve jail conditions and support decarceration and bail reform.
But the plan appears unlikely to come to fruition anytime soon due to significant delays, with the first of the replacement jails not scheduled to finish before 2029, according to the New York Post.
The de Blasio plan was approved by the City Council and prohibited capital investments in the facility, which Adams said tied his hands in relation to improving conditions, although he said that the problems there are decades old and that conditions improved under his leadership with fewer stabbings, assaults and absenteeism.
The Rikers Island jail complex stands with the Manhattan skyline in the background. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
“I’m hoping [the judge] looked at the funding plan we had… we should be able to spend capital dollars to improve the facility.”
Swain acknowledged that these limitations were part of the context but did not accept them as valid excuses. She said the Nunez Remediation Manager could raise issues of capital spending with her.
The court’s decision was praised by Mary Lynne Werlwas of The Legal Aid Society, and Debra Greenberger, partner at the law firm Emery Celli Brinckerhoff Abady Ward & Maazel.
“For years, the New York City Department of Correction has failed to follow federal court orders to enact meaningful reforms, allowing violence, disorder, and systemic dysfunction to persist in the jails,” they said.
“This appointment marks a critical turning point—an overdue acknowledgment that City leadership has proven unable to protect the safety and constitutional rights of incarcerated individuals.”
