Second alleged Guthrie ransom deadline missed, sparking new theories from Bongino, former FBI agent and doctor

TUCSON, Ariz. — A criminal investigation expert has emphasized that while the inquiry into Nancy Guthrie’s case is still active, it is crucial that top forensic experts thoroughly examine her home.

During a discussion on Fox News’ “Crime and Justice” podcast, forensic scientist Peter Valentin shared his insights with host Donna Rotunno on the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. It has been over three weeks since Guthrie went missing after being forcibly taken from her Tucson, Arizona residence on the morning of February 1, as previously reported by Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos.

According to Fox News Digital, DNA evidence collected from Nancy Guthrie’s home was linked to individuals who had legitimate reasons to be there, as confirmed by two federal law enforcement sources. Additionally, DNA from a suspicious glove found two miles away did not match any samples from the home or any profiles in the FBI’s CODIS database.

Valentin, who leads the Forensic Science Department at the University of New Haven’s Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice and Forensic Sciences, suggested on the podcast that new investigators might bring a fresh perspective to the case.

Savannah Guthrie stands beside her mother Nancy Guthrie and poses together for a photo.

In a photograph dated June 15, 2023, Savannah Guthrie is seen with her mother, Nancy Guthrie. (Nathan Congleton/NBC via Getty Images)

“My recommendation would be to assemble the best experts from each forensic discipline to meticulously inspect the house,” Valentin advised. “The goal is to find trace evidence that should be present, or hopefully still remains.”

The forensic expert is very confident that there is some type of evidence left behind by whatever individual is suspected to have taken Nancy Guthrie from her home.

“Because if people went into that home, and we believe they did, right? To take her from that house, there must be evidence of their presence in that home. Where is it? What is that evidence? We need to find it,” he said.

Split image FBI investigators tucson and nancy and savannah guthrie

FBI agents canvass homes near Nancy Guthrie’s home in Tucson, Friday, Feb. 6, 2026. Guthrie was last seen on Saturday night as an investigation into her disappearance continues. (L) A portrait of Nancy Guthrie and Savannah Guthrie shown in a photo provided by NBC.  (Kat Ramirez for Fox News Digital; Courtesy of NBC)

He also cautioned that the key piece of evidence that breaks the case might not be “obvious.”

“It’s not going be the obvious DNA profile somewhere, it is not going to be the obvious latent fingerprint. It’s probably some of the things that we’ve probably not used as much, right? The hair, the fibers, the other kinds of trace evidence. But we’ve got to start cobbling together all the forensic evidence we have at our disposal to move this case forward, because otherwise it might not move forward,” Valentin said. 

Car passes by in Ring Camera footage

Homeowners on Camino Real, a backroad out of the Catalina Foothills, say they have a camera facing the street that was not previously checked by authorities. (Courtesy of Elias and Danielle Stratigouleas)

Investigators got a fresh lead on Thursday when Fox News Digital exclusively reported that a resident in the Catalina Foothills neighborhood, about 2.5 miles from where Nancy Guthrie lives, has a Ring camera that captured 12 cars passing by on the morning of her suspected abduction. Some of the activity took place around 2:30 a.m., when authorities say the 84-year-old Guthrie’s pacemaker device last synced with her iPhone.

In a new Instagram story posted on Friday, Savannah Guthrie pleaded with people to send in tips, and to “be the one who brings her home,” referring to her mother, Nancy Guthrie.

Investigator searching the grounds of Nancy Guthrie's property in the Catalina Foothills.

A law enforcement agent checks vegetation areas around Nancy Guthrie’s home in Tucson, Ariz., Wednesday, Feb. 11, 2026. (Ty ONeil/AP Photo)

Guthrie posted a segment from the “Today” show where viewers were shown how to submit tips anonymously. She said that tips can be anonymous “and likely paid in cash.”

People with information about Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance are asked to contact 1-800-CALL-FBI. 

Related Article

Nancy Guthrie disappearance: Former FBI agent reveals amount of time likely needed for advanced DNA testing

You May Also Like

DSA fails to open Staten Island outpost

Democratic Socialists of America Fails to Open Staten Island Chapter Office

An effort by Staten Island activists to establish an independent Democratic Socialists…
Married Florida deputy Matthew Pippin fired for sexting women while on duty in Osceola

Osceola County Deputy Matthew Pippin Fired for Sexting Women While on Duty

A married Florida sheriff’s deputy was dismissed after investigators allegedly found him…
VIDEO: Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

The Big Ten handed down suspensions to nine hockey players Saturday after…
Trump says Sen. John Cornyn is doing a ‘tremendous disservice’ by blocking Texas judicial pick

Trump Blasts Sen. John Cornyn Over Blocked Texas Judicial Pick

President Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America” that outgoing Texas Sen.…
Three killed, one injured in shooting at Ohio baby shower, police say

Ohio Baby Shower Shooting Leaves 3 Dead, 1 Injured, Police Say

Three people were killed in a Saturday shooting at an entertainment venue…
Mississippi mother, caregiver face charges after refusing to give cancer treatment to toddler

Mississippi Mother, Caregiver Charged Over Toddler’s Cancer Care

A Mississippi mother is facing multiple felony charges, including murder, after authorities…
Georgia’s historic Glore House destroyed in fire — weeks after city stepped in to save property

Georgia’s Historic Glore House Destroyed by Fire Weeks After City Moved to Save It

A historic Georgia home once owned by the city’s first mayor was…
Harvard scientist pushes back on NASA chief over mystery space object: 'It's not an asteroid'

Harvard Scientist’s Mission to Prove Mysterious Space Object’s Origin Is Scrapped

A Harvard astrophysicist who believes a puzzling object racing through the solar…
Delta Air Lines outage delays thousands of flights in pre-Thanksgiving travel chaos

Delta Air Lines Outage Delays Thousands of Pre-Thanksgiving Flights

Hundreds of flights were delayed Sunday at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, the…
LaGuardia shuts down runway for second time in weeks after pavement issue resurfaces

FAA Lifts Ground Stop on Delta Flights Bound for Atlanta After System Outage

Travelers walk through Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on Friday, Nov. 7, 2025,…
Wintrust Magnificent Mile Lights Festival returns to Chicago this weekend; ABC7 Chicago to air special

Wintrust Magnificent Mile Lights Festival Returns to Chicago This Weekend, With ABC7 Special Airing

CHICAGO — Chicago’s Wintrust Magnificent Mile Lights Festival returned Saturday, Nov. 21,…
Gruesome new details emerge in shocking Chinatown killing — as possible motive revealed

Gruesome Details Emerge in Chinatown Killing as Motive Revealed

Alexander Florentino, the homeless man accused in a gruesome Chinatown killing, allegedly…