'Humiliated' lawyer apologizes over ChatGPT court flub
Share this @internewscast.com

A New York attorney who used ChatGPT to write a legal brief — citing bogus cases — profusely apologized in court Thursday, becoming emotional as he explained being “duped” by the artificial intelligence chatbot.

Steven Schwartz, of Tribeca law firm Levidow, Levidow & Oberman, told a Manhattan federal judge that he was “humiliated” by the flub, saying he believed he was using a “search engine” and never fathomed the AI app would provide fake case law.

“I would like to sincerely apologize to your honor, to this court, to the defendants, to my firm,” Schwartz said during the packed court hearing.

“I deeply regret my actions in this manner that led to this hearing today,” Schwartz said, voice shaking. “I suffered both professionally and personally [because of] the widespread publicity this issue has generated. I am both embarrassed, humiliated and extremely remorseful.”

Schwartz used ChatGPT to help him find case law to bolster his client’s lawsuit, but the bot completely fabricated the cases, unbeknownst to the attorney.

He ultimately filed the legal brief citing the fictitious cases in court, prompting Judge Kevin Castel to haul him into court for a hearing on whether to sanction the firm over the snafu.


Steven Schwartz outside of court.
Steven Schwartz faced a grilling by a judge about using ChatGPT to help with a legal brief, resulting in bogus case law.
Steven Hirsch

Schwartz was forced to pause and compose himself as he made the apology.

“I have never been involved in anything like this in my 30 years,” said Schwartz, who was forced to pause and compose himself as he made the apology.

“I can assure this court that nothing like this will happen again,” he insisted to the judge.


Steven Schwartz outside of court.
Schwartz profusely apologized to the judge over the snafu.
Steven Hirsch

Schwartz had filed the court brief in his firm’s 2022 case representing Robert Mata, who sued Colombian airline Avianca claiming he was injured when a metal serving cart hit his knee on a flight to New York City.

Some of the fictitious cases that Schwartz cited included, Miller v. United Airlines, Petersen v. Iran Air and Varghese v. China Southern Airlines.

Castel grilled Schwartz for roughly two hours Thursday on how he could have allowed such a mishap to happen.


Steven Schwartz
Schwartz said he never believed the chatbot would turn up fake case law.
Steven Hirsch

Schwartz repeatedly insisted he never imagined ChatGPT would completely fabricate case law.

“I just never could imagine that ChatGPT would fabricate cases,” Schwartz said. “My assumption was I was using a search engine that was using sources I don’t have access to.”

Schwartz said that ChatGPT didn’t specify the cases weren’t real, adding “I continued to be duped by ChatGPT.”


ChatGPT
Schwartz said he thought the AI bot was like a search engine.
REUTERS

“It just never occurred to me it would be making up cases,” he explained. “I just assumed it couldn’t access the full case.”

Schwartz said he never would have submitted the brief if he thought the case law wasn’t real, but admitted he should have done further due diligence first.

“In hindsight, God I wish I did that, but I didn’t do that,” he said.


Steven Schwartz
The lawyer said he has been “humiliated” by his legal snafu.
Steven Schwartz / LinkedIn

Schwartz also admitted that he couldn’t find the full cases on the internet, but said he thought they could have been on appeal or unpublished cases.

At one point Castel read an excerpt from one of the made-up cases and pressed Schwartz: “Can we agree that’s legal gibberish?”

“Looking at it now, yes,” Schwartz admitted.


ChatGPT: optimizing language models for dialogue.
Schwartz vowed he’d never use ChatGPT again.
AP

Schwartz swore off using the app in the future and also said he’d taken an AI training course to improve his knowledge of technology.

Thomas Corbino, another lawyer at the firm, told the judge the company had never been sanctioned before and that Schwartz had always been a standup lawyer.

Another lawyer at the firm, Ronald Minkoff, told the judge lawyers are notoriously bad with technology.

“There was no intention misconduct here,” Minkoff said. “This was the result of ignorance and carelessness. It was not intentional and certainly not in bad faith.”

The judge said he would rule on whether to issue sanctions at a later date.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Birmingham Public Safety Advisory Committee holds 1st meeting since creation over 2 years ago

Birmingham Public Safety Advisory Committee holds 1st meeting since creation over 2 years ago

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (WIAT) — Two-and-a-half years after its creation, the Birmingham Public…
After NATIONAL FILE Investigation, Reuters Publishes Report on Zelensky Corruption Allegations

After NATIONAL FILE Investigation, Reuters Publishes Report on Zelensky Corruption Allegations

Last Updated on September 20, 2023 Reuters is reporting on corruption allegations…
Alex Murdaugh pleads guilty to federal financial crimes

Alex Murdaugh pleads guilty to federal financial crimes

CHARLESTON, S.C. (WCBD) – Alex Murdaugh pleaded guilty to 22 federal financial…
Boston College suspends swimming and diving teams due to hazing

Boston College suspends swimming and diving teams due to hazing

Boston College indefinitely suspended its men’s and women’s swimming and diving teams…
Giants Week 3 report card: Offense implodes again

Giants Week 3 report card: Offense implodes again

Grading the Giants’ 30-12 loss to the 49ers on Thursday night. Offense Not much…
A fascinating reworked world map reveals the most popular tourist sites in almost every country around the world

What the world wants to VISIT: Fascinating map shows the most popular landmarks in (almost) every country, from Stonehenge to the Statue of Liberty

A fascinating reworked world map reveals the most popular tourist sites in…
Alex Murdaugh indicted on financial fraud charges related to housekeeper's death

Murdaugh pleads guilty to federal financial crimes but may face lie detector test

CHARLESTON, S.C. — Convicted murderer Alex Murdaugh pleaded guilty in federal court…
Shake Shack testing recipe tweak for select items, including fan-favorite

Shake Shack testing recipe tweak for select items, including fan-favorite

(KTLA) – Shake Shack is testing recipe adjustments to a few of…
Friday Flyover: Reavis High School

Friday Flyover: Reavis High School

BURBANK, Ill. (WLS) — This week, we feature Reavis High School on…
Sophie Turner grabs dinner with Taylor Swift again in NYC after filing lawsuit against estranged husband Joe Jonas

Sophie Turner grabs dinner with Taylor Swift again in NYC after filing lawsuit against estranged husband Joe Jonas

The Queen of the North is turning heads with her second meetup with her…
Athlete of the Week: Pinson Valley volleyball player Anna Ruffin

Athlete of the Week: Pinson Valley volleyball player Anna Ruffin

by: Chandler Bland Posted: Sep 21, 2023 / 11:19 PM CDT Updated:…
San Marcos apartment fire that killed 5 started with a lit mattress in a breezeway, affidavit reveals

Hays County DA: Unindicted Individual Accused of Fatal 2018 San Marcos Apartment Fire Released on PR Bond

SAN MARCOS, Texas – The suspect in the 2018 Iconic Village apartment…