Karen Read trial: Jury asks judge questions about charges and evidence in murder of Boston police officer boyfriend John O'Keefe

BOSTON — A jury asked questions Tuesday as they continue to deliberate in the Karen Read retrial.

Read, 45, is accused of striking John O’Keefe with her car outside a suburban Boston house party and leaving him to die in the snow in January 2022.

According to Read’s attorneys, they allege that O’Keefe, aged 46, was not only brutally attacked and mauled by a dog but subsequently abandoned outside a Canton residence. They claim this was part of a conspiracy by the police, who are accused of fabricating evidence against Read.

Jury deliberations commenced late last week, over a month after the trial initially began. This marked the second complete day of discussions, starting on Tuesday morning and concluding without a decision. Additional deliberations are slated for Wednesday.

The jury signaled their confusion about jury instructions, leaving many searching for clues in the questions they’re asking.

“We received an inquiry from the jurors: ‘If we find not guilty on two charges but cannot come to a consensus on one charge, does that mean a hung jury on all three charges or just on one?'” Judge Canone conveyed to the courtroom.

Read is facing three charges: 2nd degree murder, vehicular manslaughter while under the influence of alcohol, and leaving the scene of an accident causing death.

RELATED: Things to know about the retrial of Karen Read in the killing of her police officer boyfriend

“We don’t answer theoretical questions. I tell the jurors not to be concerned with the consequences of their verdict and that’s exactly what they’re doing here,” the judge said, trying to answer the jurors’ question.

The case against Read has gripped the nation and divided the Boston area, and launching a legion of supporters.

Hundreds of supporters dressed in pink outside the courtroom.

Earlier, the jury asked about the charge of operating under the influence and whether the video clips of Read’s television interviews — including with ABC’s 20/20 — can be used as evidence.

Daniel Medwed, a law professor at Northeastern University who is not involved in the case, said it’s “quite possible it is heading for a compromise or mercy verdict, a split verdict,” in light of the questions.

“My take is that the jury might be homing in the OUI charge, suggesting they might have doubts about whether she struck him at all,” Medwed said.

The defense has said several jurors from the first trial came forward and said the jury was set to acquit Read on two charges but deadlocked on a third, leading to the mistrial.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2025 ABC News Internet Ventures.

You May Also Like

Disney to Cut Up to 200 Jobs Across Its Theme Parks Division

Disney to Cut Up to 200 Jobs Across Its Theme Parks Division

Disney is eliminating as many as 200 positions within its Experiences division,…
Pete Hegseth Fires Top Pentagon War Planner Brett Sylvia

Pete Hegseth Fires Top Pentagon War Planner Brett Sylvia

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has dismissed the Pentagon’s top military planner, a…
Mother Defends Daughter Charged in Brutal School Beating

Mother Defends Daughter Charged in Brutal School Beating

The mother of an 11-year-old girl charged in connection with a brutal,…
Three Noncitizens Indicted in California Election Fraud Takedown

Three Noncitizens Indicted in California Election Fraud Takedown

Three alleged noncitizens in Los Angeles County were indicted by a federal…
Energy Dept. lab fire sparks nuclear scare after 'radiological release' at SC facility

South Carolina Energy Dept. Lab Fire Prompts Radiological Release Alert

A fire at a US Department of Energy nuclear research facility in…
Netanyahu Alleges Fraud as Israeli Arab Parties Make Record Gains, Emerge as Kingmakers

Netanyahu Alleges Fraud as Israeli Arab Parties Make Record Gains, Emerge as Kingmakers

Israel’s two Arab political parties could play a decisive role in determining…
2016 Federal Probe Cited Evidence in Ilhan Omar Marriage Allegation

2016 Federal Probe Cited Evidence in Ilhan Omar Marriage Allegation

Federal investigators uncovered evidence suggesting that Rep. Ilhan Omar entered into a…
Milwaukee Brewers Win First World Series, Beat Rays in Five Games

Milwaukee Brewers Win First World Series, Beat Rays in Five Games

The Milwaukee Brewers are World Series champions at last, defeating the Tampa…
DOJ's Operation Ghostbusters Targets Fake Student Aid Enrollees

DOJ’s Operation Ghostbusters Targets Fake Student Aid Enrollees

The Justice Department announced “Operation Ghostbusters,” an effort targeting an international student…
Nicki Minaj Blasts Gov. Kathy Hochul, Backs Bruce Blakeman in New York Governor Race

Nicki Minaj Blasts Gov. Kathy Hochul, Backs Bruce Blakeman in New York Governor Race

Nicki Minaj called Gov. Kathy Hochul an “evil woman” and said the…
Netanyahu Misses Majority, Leaving Israel With 3 Paths to Government

Netanyahu Misses Majority, Leaving Israel With 3 Paths to Government

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s governing coalition fell well below the 61-seat threshold…
Five Burglary Suspects in Custody After I-290 Chase in Addison

Five Burglary Suspects in Custody After I-290 Chase in Addison

VILLA PARK, Ill. — Five suspected burglars are in custody after a…