First hearing held on detainees' legal rights at 'Alligator Alcatraz' after judge orders wind down
Share this @internewscast.com

Attorneys representing detainees at an immigration detention center in the Florida Everglades are set for a court hearing on Thursday in Fort Myers. This is the first session following a federal judge’s order to wind down operations at the contentious site, known as “Alligator Alcatraz,” a name reminiscent of the infamous Californian island prison. The order came from a separate environmental lawsuit.

The court will focus on how the decision from the environmental case affects another lawsuit alleging that detainees have been unlawfully denied the ability to meet privately with their attorneys, infringing upon their First Amendment rights.

In the earlier environmental legal proceedings, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams had issued a preliminary injunction mandating the cessation of operations by the end of October. This included the relocation of detainees to other centers and removal of equipment and barriers.

The controversial detention site was established in a rush by Republican Governor Ron DeSantis’ administration in an isolated area of the Everglades as part of efforts to bolster President Donald Trump’s immigration enforcement policies. Its remote location was chosen to serve as a strong deterrent to prevent escapes.

The hearing also represents the case’s debut in Fort Myers, after being transferred from Miami. Last month, U.S. District Judge Rodolfo Ruiz determined that the claim regarding detainees being denied immigration court hearings was moot, since cases were moved to Miami’s Krome North Processing Center.

Judge Ruiz allowed the remaining legal issues regarding the detainees’ inability to have private communications with their attorneys to continue in Florida’s middle district, following a granted motion for a venue change by the state defendants. These issues include delays in scheduling meetings and challenges in having private phone or videoconference meetings with attorneys at the facility, officially known as the South Detention Facility.

Attorneys for the detainees argued in court papers filed Tuesday that the preliminary injunction in the environmental case has no impact on their case since the detention center continues to house detainees.

The state and federal governments have appealed Williams’ ruling, asking that it be put on hold. If their request for a stay is denied, and the facility eventually ceases operations, it could render the legal rights lawsuit moot, according to the federal government in court papers.

On the other hand, if the stay is granted and Williams’ order is put on hold, the state of Florida plans to resume accepting detainees at the facility, state officials said in court papers for the legal rights case.

As part of their appeal of the environmental case, state officials said that only four U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents at any given time are at the Florida-run detention center. The Florida officials said in court papers that the ICE agents “do not control the site.”

The question of who controls the facility is at the heart of the state and federal government’s appeal of Williams’ ruling. Her decision was issued in response to a lawsuit brought by Friends of the Everglades, the Center for Biological Diversity and the Miccosukee Tribe, who accused the state and federal defendants of not following federal law requiring an environmental review for the detention center in the middle of sensitive wetlands.

The federal government claims that it isn’t responsible for the detention center since it hasn’t spent a cent to build or operate the facility, even though Florida is seeking some federal grant money to fund a portion of it. Florida claims that the environmental impact statement required by federal law doesn’t apply to states.

___

Follow Mike Schneider on the social platform Bluesky: @mikeysid.bsky.social

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Transportation Department tightens non-citizen truck driver rules after fatal crash in Florida

New Restrictions Imposed on Non-Citizen Truck Drivers by Transportation Department Following Deadly Florida Accident

The Transportation Department is set to immediately tighten the requirements for non-citizens…
David Huerta Released on Bond for Attempted Obstruction of ICE, Cosplays as Trump's Political Prisoner

U.S. Attorney Essayli Challenges California Over Potential Enforcement of ‘No Masks for ICE’ Law

California Governor Gavin Newsom has recently intensified his fiery rhetoric against ICE…
Trump stakes Gaza peace hopes on 21-point plan as Israel, Houthis continue deadly fighting

Trump Unveils 21-Point Plan for Gaza Peace Amid Ongoing Israel-Houthi Conflict

New York, NY – Amid the circulation of President Donald Trump’s latest…
Random blue city stabbing death fuels new bail bill as ‘activists’ ripped for lack of crime crackdown: expert

A recent random stabbing death in a major city prompts new bail legislation, while ‘activists’ face criticism for not addressing crime, according to experts.

In the wake of the stabbing death of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska…
LA assault suspect plays freeway Frogger to evade arrest: video

Suspect in LA Assault Attempts Dangerous Freeway Escape: Caught on Video

A hop, skip and arrest. A suspect involved in an assault tried…
Trump gets praise at UN as Lithuania’s president warns Putin respects only strength

Trump Receives Praise at UN; Lithuanian President Warns Putin Respects Only Strength

Lithuania’s leader praised President Donald Trump’s United Nations speech on Tuesday, describing…
'General Hospital says goodbye to Monica Quartermaine and the late actress, Leslie Charleson, who played the role for decades

“General Hospital Bids Farewell to Iconic Character Monica Quartermaine and the Late Actress Leslie Charleson”

HOLLYWOOD, LOS ANGELES — “General Hospital” enthusiasts were first introduced to the…
Starbucks closing hundreds of stores: See the list of store closures

Starbucks Shutting Down Numerous Locations: Check Out Which Stores Are Closing

Dozens of Starbucks locations that are closing this weekend have been identified…
Commuter critical in latest blue city unprovoked throat slashing attack; suspect claims 'I just scared him'

Innocent Commuter Seriously Injured in Unprovoked Throat Slashing in Blue City; Attacker Says ‘I Just Wanted to Scare Him’

A New York man accused of slashing a random train rider’s throat…
President Donald Trump attends Ryder Cup in Bethpage for 'Tournament Friday'

Former President Donald Trump Joins ‘Tournament Friday’ at Ryder Cup in Bethpage

BETHPAGE, New York — President Donald Trump arrived on Long Island on…
Inspired by Erika Kirk, Tim Allen Makes Powerful Statement About Forgiving the Man Who Killed His Father

Motivated by Erika Kirk, Tim Allen Shares a Strong Message on Forgiving His Father’s Killer

It has been a little over two weeks since the assassination of…
FWC arrests man accused of illegally capturing, killing, harvesting alligators

Man Arrested for Unlawfully Capturing and Hunting Alligators

The FWC the man and others illegally captured seven alligators from a…