Judge Questions Trump Administration’s Defense of Proposed Arch
Judge Questions Trump Administration’s Defense of Proposed Arch

Washington — The Justice Department and a group of Vietnam War veterans clashed Friday in a Washington, D.C., courtroom over the future of a proposed 250-foot arch that President Trump wants to build between Arlington National Cemetery and the Lincoln Memorial.

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan heard arguments on a preliminary injunction that would halt construction of the arch. Attorneys for three Vietnam veterans and a historian, who sued earlier this year to stop the project, argued that the construction process has been rushed and that the plan lacks proper congressional authorization. They also defended their legal standing to bring the case.

Chutkan said at the beginning of the hearing that standing was the central issue she needed to resolve. Earlier this year, the Supreme Court ruled that plaintiffs in a similar lawsuit challenging construction of a White House ballroom likely lacked the legal right to sue.

In court filings, the Justice Department described the plaintiffs’ arguments as “breathless” and urged Chutkan to follow the Supreme Court’s ruling in the White House ballroom case.

Two plaintiffs, Vietnam veterans Michael Lemmon and Shaun Byrnes, told Chutkan that the arch would alter their experience visiting graves at Arlington National Cemetery. They said they would be harmed by the structure’s size and intended purpose.

Lemmon, who appeared by Zoom, said the idea of placing a tourist attraction outside Arlington National Cemetery was “almost blasphemous.” He told the judge that he walks from the Vietnam Veterans Memorial to the Lincoln Memorial and then to Arlington Cemetery, where he visits the graves of people who served in the Vietnam War.

The arch site is across the Potomac from the Lincoln Memorial.

The proposed arch would stand across the Potomac River from the Lincoln Memorial.

SAUL LOEB /AFP via Getty Images


“It means an intense amount to me to be able to continue to do that,” he said, adding that the proposed structure rising over the gravesites would “change the entire experience in a profoundly negative way.”

Byrnes, who attended the hearing in person, said in a declaration submitted to Chutkan that he would reconsider being buried at Arlington if the arch is built.

The challengers also argued that recent renderings show the structure would disrupt the symbolic relationship between the Lincoln Memorial and the Robert E. Lee Memorial. That sightline was deliberately designed to represent national unity after the Civil War, they said.

According to court filings submitted by the Justice Department earlier this month, work on the arch could begin as soon as Nov. 5 if the National Capital Planning Commission grants final approval that day.

Justice Department attorney Robert Stander asked Chutkan to reject the request to halt construction and dismiss the lawsuit. He argued that this case was “easier than the ballroom case” to dismiss because the veterans’ objections stem from a “deep personal disagreement” with the concept of the arch.

Stander called the arch a “high-priority project” for the White House and suggested that the plaintiffs renew their request after construction starts.

Chutkan questioned Stander about how the project would be financed, noting that its funding has so far remained unclear.

“I don’t even know who is paying for this thing,” Chutkan said. She later expressed skepticism about allowing construction to begin, asking what harm the government would suffer from a temporary delay “apart from the executive’s desire to bedazzle the city.”

Chutkan also challenged the Trump administration’s claim that the arch has national-security purposes, an argument the government raised for the first time in a filing Wednesday. She cited a declaration from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who said the structure could include sensors, communications equipment and defense capabilities. The government also said the arch could draw between 2,000 and 22,000 visitors each day.

“We’re not talking about plans for a cafeteria,” the judge said.

Mr. Trump said in a Truth Social post in September that he had revised the arch plans to make the structure, in part, a “top grade Military Complex” equipped with snipers and drones.

The Trump administration also submitted sworn declarations from Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Hegseth. Both said the arch could be used by the military and Secret Service to protect the nation’s capital from unmanned drone attacks and other potential threats.

Hegseth wrote in his declaration that the proposed structure represents “a generational national defense opportunity” to prevent future threats.

Stander declined to offer additional details about how the arch would enhance national security, but noted that Mr. Trump has faced several assassination attempts since 2024.

“The arch is somehow intended to prevent assassination attempts against the president?” Chutkan asked. “It’s going to be completed three years from now.”

The Supreme Court allowed construction of the White House ballroom to proceed partly because the Trump administration cited national-security consequences that could result from a pause. But Chutkan said that, in this case, the high court’s reasoning “does not make the mention of national security to be talismanic.”

Critics have also warned that the project could interfere with aircraft flying to and from nearby Ronald Reagan International Airport. Arlington County, which borders the proposed site at a currently vacant traffic circle, filed suit in federal court in Virginia seeking to block the project.

The Federal Aviation Administration concluded that the arch would not endanger flights arriving at or departing from the nearby airport. Arlington County has argued, however, that the structure would require changes to flight paths serving Reagan International Airport and has asked a federal judge in Virginia to order an environmental review.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Chinese national caught in LA counterfeit goods smuggling scheme

Chinese National Caught in LA Counterfeit Goods Smuggling Scheme

A Chinese national and two Southern California residents have been arrested in…
Alabama man Reuben Gulley acquitted in murder of TikTok star Ophelia Nichols' teen son

Alabama Man Reuben Gulley Acquitted in Murder of TikTok Star Ophelia Nichols’ Teen Son

An Alabama man who claimed self-defense for shooting TikTok star Ophelia Nichols’…
Trump admin quietly releases government Bigfoot files

Trump Administration Quietly Releases U.S. Government Bigfoot Files

Bigfoot is making an unexpected appearance in newly released government records. Documents…
Dem Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear under fire from state auditor over waste, fraud, abuse fears

Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear Faces State Auditor Scrutiny Over Waste

Kentucky’s top auditor says her office has identified $1.5 billion in taxpayer…
2 killed in separate fires, bringing NYC's fire-related death toll to 90 this year

2 Killed in Separate NYC Fires, Bringing 2026 Fire Death Toll to 90

Two people died in separate New York City fires Thursday, raising the…
Utah mommy blogger Ruby Franke's daughter begs parole board not to let her out of prison: 'she is a monster'

Ruby Franke’s Daughter Urges Parole Board to Keep Utah Mommy Blogger in Prison: ‘She Is a Monster’

Shari Franke, the oldest daughter of convicted child abuser and former Utah…
Lead azide detonation in Iowa by U.S. Army paused indefinitely after lawsuits are filed

U.S. Army Pauses Iowa Lead Azide Detonation Indefinitely Following Lawsuits

A federal appeals court on Friday indefinitely blocked the U.S. Army from…
Stocks enter correction territory, driven by a deepening tech rout

Stocks Enter Correction Territory as Deepening Tech Sell-Off Drags Markets Lower

Technology shares suffered a sharp sell-off Friday, wiping out the optimism surrounding…
Heartbroken family of UGA football commit who died suddenly at 18 reveal teen’s final moments

Heartbroken Family of UGA Football Commit Who Died at 18 Reveal His Final Moments

The family of a promising Georgia football player who died suddenly last…
Pentagon: Reinvigorated Defense Relationship with Canada Is Needed

Pentagon Calls for Revitalized US-Canada Defense Partnership

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s reported shift toward China and Europe is…
Woman, 62, found dead with neck trauma in NYC apartment building

Woman, 62, Found Dead With Neck Trauma in NYC Building

A 62-year-old woman was found dead with neck injuries inside a Lower…
Alabama woman pleads guilty after reportedly using smart glasses to target drug trial witnesses

Alabama Woman Pleads Guilty to Using Smart Glasses to Target Drug Trial Witnesses

An Alabama woman has admitted using Meta smart glasses to covertly film…