Karmelo Anthony Defense Targets Judge Over Murder Verdict Comment - Internewscast Journal
Karmelo Anthony Defense Targets Judge Over Murder Verdict Comment

A Texas judge is set to hear arguments Wednesday on whether the judge who oversaw Karmelo Anthony’s June murder trial should be taken off the case during post-trial proceedings. The hearing comes one day before a separate court date on Anthony’s request for a new trial.

Anthony’s newly assembled defense team, headed by attorney Russell Wilson II, is asking another judge to disqualify Judge John Roach from any further proceedings. The defense contends that comments Roach made publicly after the trial created the appearance that he could be biased.

The recusal hearing is set for 9 a.m. Wednesday. According to court records, Judge Sid Harle has been assigned to preside over the matter.

Anthony is expected to be present for Wednesday’s hearing, a Collin County official told News Outlet. The official also said a bench warrant had been issued in the case.

Karmelo Anthony

Karmelo Anthony is shown after being transferred into the custody of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. He was taken to his assigned facility, the Pack Unit near Navasota. (Texas Department of Criminal Justice)

Anthony was found guilty in June of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, who prosecutors said was fatally stabbed during a confrontation at a track meet in Frisco. A Collin County jury sentenced Anthony to 35 years in prison.

Wilson is leading Anthony’s current legal team, which filed two motions on July 7: one seeking Roach’s recusal and another requesting a new trial. The hearing on the new-trial motion is scheduled for 9 a.m. Thursday.

In its recusal request, the defense argues Roach should not decide Anthony’s post-trial motions because of the remarks he made to reporters after the jury reached its verdict.

Austin Metcalf with father and brother

Austin Metcalf, left, is pictured with his father, Jeff, top right, and with his twin brother, Hunter, bottom right. (Jeff Metcalf)

The filing cites comments in which Roach said the jury “got it right” and defended several trial rulings, including his handling of courtroom access and the dismissal of three Black prospective jurors.

Anthony’s attorneys contend those comments have created the appearance that Roach prejudged the defense’s claims.

The filing does not directly challenge Anthony’s guilt or innocence. Instead, it alleges constitutional and legal errors that the defense says deprived him of a fair trial.

Courtroom sketch showing Judge John Roach at the bench during the Karmelo Anthony trial

A courtroom sketch shows Judge John Roach overseeing proceedings in the Karmelo Anthony murder trial. (Pat Lopez)

The motion argues Anthony’s trial was not open enough to the public. Cameras were barred from the courtroom and only 27 seats were available for members of the public.

Anthony’s lawyers also accuse prosecutors of breaking an off-the-record agreement about character evidence and other alleged acts unrelated to the murder charge. They argue the dispute forced Anthony to decide whether to testify while risking the introduction of evidence they say could unfairly prejudice jurors.

The defense also challenges the jury instructions, arguing they limited jurors’ ability to fully consider Anthony’s claim of self-defense.

Roach referred the recusal request to another judge under Texas procedure.

The outcome of Wednesday’s hearing could determine who handles Anthony’s new-trial motion and other remaining post-conviction matters in the trial court.

News Outlet has reached out to Anthony’s defense team for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Donald Trump's executive order could let California's offshore oil firms abandon drills on seabed

Trump Order May Let California Oil Firms Abandon Seabed Wells

Oil companies operating off the California coast could soon be permitted to…
'Naked and Afraid' star wins big payout after boss downloaded her uncensored pics from show

Naked and Afraid’ Star Wins Payout After Boss Downloaded Photos

A former “Naked and Afraid” contestant received a $175,000 settlement after accusing…
Sean Duffy reveals when airport travel delays should finally end after FAA's nationwide ground stop

US Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy: When FAA Delays May End

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Sunday that the nationwide air travel disruption…
'Purge'-masked suspect accused of killing college student at Halloween bash — before his sister helps nab him

‘Purge’-Masked Suspect Accused of Killing College Student at Halloween Party Arrested After Sister’s Tip

Colorado authorities have identified all of the people shown in security footage…
Duffy: Investigators examining 2 routers after nationwide FAA ground stop, no signs of foreign cyberattack

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy: 2 routers examined after FAA ground stop, no foreign attack signs

Duffy provides update on investigation into cause of nationwide ground stop Fox…
Murder suspect in 'Purge' mask identified -- after student killed on Halloween

Purge-Mask Murder Suspect Identified After Student Killed on Halloween

Colorado authorities have identified everyone shown in security footage released after a…
Harvard scientist pushes back on NASA chief over mystery space object: 'It's not an asteroid'

Harvard Scientist Disputes NASA Chief’s Asteroid Assessment of Mystery Space Object

A Harvard astrophysicist who proposed that a puzzling object racing through the…
San Diego Zoo elephant 'Nipho' dies from ‘unusually fast’ disease

San Diego Zoo Elephant Nipho Dies From Unusually Fast Disease

A 15-year-old elephant at the San Diego Zoo has died from a…
UPS cargo plane collides with commercial airliner at Miami airport

UPS Cargo Plane Collides With Commercial Airliner at Miami Airport

A cargo aircraft struck a passenger jet while taxiing at Miami International…
Climber trapped on Yosemite's El Capitan for nine days when massive storm hit California

Climber Trapped 9 Days on Yosemite’s El Capitan as Storm Hits

Champion climber Sasha DiGiulian was nearing the end of an ambitious attempt…
Virginia parents charged after house party draws hundreds of teens, fireworks and alleged underage drinking

Virginia Parents Charged After Teen House Party Draws Hundreds, Fireworks and Alleged Underage Drinking

A Virginia couple who hoped to provide a safe place for their…
Nationwide FAA ground stop updates: US air travel disruption causes Chicago Midway, O'Hare flight delays, cancellations

Nationwide FAA Ground Stop Disrupts US Air Travel, Delaying and Canceling Flights at Chicago Midway and O’Hare

CHICAGO () — Hundreds of additional flights were canceled at Chicago airports…