911 call captures chaos after Austin Metcalf stabbing
Newly released court exhibits are offering the public a more detailed look at the evidence jurors reviewed before convicting Anthony in the fatal stabbing of Frisco teenager Austin Metcalf at a high school track meet. Anthony was sentenced to 35 years in prison following the verdict.
Karmelo Anthony’s family is asking supporters to contribute an additional $250,000 for his appeal, after a previous fundraising effort brought in nearly $634,000 and drew scrutiny over how those donations were used. The family announced the new appeal fund during a news conference in Dallas, Texas.
The renewed fundraising effort comes nearly two weeks after a judge rejected Anthony’s request for a new trial. At the Dallas news conference, his family and supporters, including attorney Russell Wilson, laid out their plans to challenge the conviction.
Anthony, 19, was sentenced in June to 35 years in prison after a jury found him guilty of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a high school track meet in Frisco, Texas. Anthony has filed an appeal and says he does not have the money needed to hire an attorney for the appellate process.
Wilson said the new fund is meant to pay for legal representation, expert witnesses and other expenses tied to the effort to overturn or challenge Anthony’s conviction.
Left: Karmelo Anthony is seen in a prison mugshot. Right: Austin Metcalf, who was stabbed to death by Anthony. (Texas Department of Criminal Justice; Jeff Metcalf)
“I think there’s a misconception that the motion for new trial denial would have ended an appeal,” Wilson said. “It actually is part of an appeal.”
According to Wilson, the appeals process could stretch beyond a year. The trial record is expected to be compiled in October, after which both sides will submit written arguments. The Dallas Court of Appeals may then decide whether to hold a hearing.
The request follows a GiveSendGo campaign launched on Anthony’s behalf in April 2025 that raised $633,908 before it was removed from public view following his conviction.
Karmelo Anthony’s mother, Kayla Hayes, speaks at a press conference in April. (Next Generation Action Network via Facebook)
The earlier campaign was organized by Anthony’s mother and initially set a fundraising goal of nearly $1.4 million. Organizers said donations could be used for legal defense, moving the family, basic living expenses, transportation, counseling and security.
GiveSendGo said the money had been distributed over the previous year for lawful purposes, including legal defense and moving the family, and that the campaign was closed after its stated purpose was completed.
The new campaign page says donations will be deposited into an attorney trust account administered by Wilson and that Anthony’s family will not receive or control the money. The page says the funds will be used only for legal expenses, including filings, transcripts, investigators and experts.
Demonstrators showed support for Karmelo Anthony outside the Collin County Courthouse in McKinney, Texas, on the first day of jury selection in his trial on June 1, 2026. (Derek Shook for News Outlet)
The page listed a $250,000 goal and $30,194 raised when viewed by News Outlet. Trinicia Ricks is identified as the campaign’s creator, while Wilson is listed as the person who will receive the funds.
A reporter pressed Dominique Alexander, a civil rights activist who has served as a spokesman for Anthony’s family, about the new request and what happened to money raised through the earlier campaign. The reporter also asked about claims that donations were used to buy a car or house.
“These are deliberate lies,” Alexander said. “Why would we ask the question to a family to answer something that clearly was a lie?”
When asked where the previous money went, Alexander declined to explain the family’s fees or say whether any funds remained.
The GiveSendGo page for the Karmelo Anthony Legal Fund lists a $250,000 goal and $30,194 raised. (GiveSendGo)
Alexander said the original fundraiser also helped the family relocate after they faced threats.
“That fund was established to not only help with the legal process, but also be able to relocate this family to safety,” he said.
Public records reviewed by News Outlet previously showed Anthony’s parents, Andrew Anthony III and Kala Hayes, were connected to business entities in Louisiana and Texas. A Texas entity listing Andrew Anthony III as its registered agent became active 24 days after Metcalf’s death.
The records did not show whether either company generated revenue, held assets or received money from the fundraiser. Anthony’s parents have not been accused of wrongdoing.
Anthony has since described himself in court filings as a “penniless, destitute, and indigent person, too poor to employ counsel to represent me on the appeal.”
Wilson declined to provide additional details about the defense strategy, saying some issues could become important in future proceedings.
Anthony remains in custody while the appeal moves forward.
News Outlet has reached out to Wilson for comment.
