Leading California Professors Warn of Pitfalls in Campus AI Expansion
Leading California Professors Warn of Pitfalls in Campus AI Expansion

Artificial intelligence is reshaping college classrooms, prompting some of California’s best-known professors to revive an decidedly low-tech safeguard: handwritten work on paper.

The California Post spoke with professors at UCLA, USC, UC Berkeley and Stanford about AI’s impact on their courses. Some said they are largely eliminating the technology and grading only written assignments completed in class without digital assistance.

Others, however, are incorporating AI into their teaching and view it as a potentially valuable addition to the classroom.

“The technology has been shoved down all our throats and we’re all just dealing with the fallout,” Morgan Polikoff, a professor at USC Rossier, told the Post.

Polikoff, who is currently on leave from teaching, said he had already intended to move more graded undergraduate work to supervised, paper-and-pencil exams.

He said he might adopt an approach like that of prominent UC Berkeley mathematics professor Richard Borcherds, who drew attention after deciding he would no longer grade homework based on correctness.

Two years ago, Polikoff caught a freshman using AI to write a paper despite a ban on the technology. He said the use was easy to identify, and the student admitted it when challenged. Polikoff then required him to start the paper over.

“I think in general we will need more standardized and AI-proof measures of everything, both in college admissions and once students are enrolled at university,” he said. “It’s become increasingly difficult to know what anyone knows and can do, and that signal is important.”

“I don’t see any point at all in a student completing an assessment by running it through AI and handing in to me whatever it spit out for them—that is a waste of my time and theirs,” he added.

USC leaves AI policy largely to individual instructors, allowing them to establish rules for their own courses. Polikoff said his PhD program is currently discussing a policy, although faculty would still retain discretion over how to apply it.

The university spends about $3.1 million annually on a ChatGPT Edu subscription for 80,000 users. Polikoff described that cost as “pennies” compared with USC’s payment to its football coach.

At UCLA, statistics and data science lecturer Thomas Maierhofer has adopted a middle-ground strategy.

“All exams are in-person on-paper exams without the use of phones or laptops. All work done outside of the classrooms like homework and labs are graded on completion,” he said.

Maierhofer also sees AI’s potential as an instructional resource. He is developing ALISSTAIR, a custom chatbot designed to assist students, while relying on his exam format to protect academic honesty.

“As long as the exams are in-person and on-paper students are only hurting themselves if they use AI to cheat instead of using it to enhance their own learning,” he said.

At UC Berkeley, Borcherds said his grades now depend primarily on in-person exams, with students prohibited from using electronic devices. His decision to stop grading homework for correctness made headlines this fall.

“Online exams are now a waste of time as several students just use AI to answer the questions,” he said. “I cannot tell which students are using AI, but I notice the average score increases a lot in online exams.”

The University of California allows individual campuses and academic programs to establish tougher AI restrictions, particularly in areas such as admissions and academic integrity.

Stanford Law School professor Julian Nyarko takes a more optimistic view of AI—though he is less confident in people.

“I think AI has tremendous potential. I think many humans are not great teachers. So I’m skeptical of human capability, more so than I am overly enthusiastic about AI capabilities,” he told the Post.

“I think there’s great variance in the quality of teachers and I think AI can definitely have a positive impact if we learn to use it well, especially if the counterfactual is having a poor teacher,” he added.

In a study Nyarko led this year, 16 law professors blindly rated answers to common student questions, and they preferred Google’s AI over their own colleagues 75% of the time. The researchers stressed that the study measured answer quality, not whether AI tutors help students learn in the long run.

He also warned that there is a wrong way to use the tech.

“There’s a way to use AI that will harm students, an irresponsible use, which is basically, just write this paper for me or solve this question for me,” he said.

Nyarko has always given in-class exams.

He said many of his colleagues used to assign take-home exams lasting as long as eight hours. With one or two exceptions, they now feel they can’t, out of fear that students will simply hand the work to AI.

He said that trying to restrict students’ access is a fantasy at this point, since the vast majority already have it.

“AI will require significant change in how we do things,” he said. “We’re basically moving from a world where we kind of thought we knew how education works reasonably well, to a world where we don’t know how to best educate students. We have access to AI, and that requires a lot of figuring out.”

Stanford gives all students free access to ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude through a pilot running until August 2027. Unless an instructor sets a stricter rule, students may use AI to help them learn but can’t pass off its work as their own.

The debate has spilled into next week’s race for state schools chief.

Sonja Shaw, the Republican candidate for California Superintendent of Public Instruction, said over-reliance on AI robs students of the critical skills that colleges and employers demand. She said the fix is a return to academic rigor and objective standards.

“More AI-assisted work and grade inflation made it easier to disguise who actually learned the material and who didn’t,” Shaw said. “Objective testing remains the best means to measure student skills in an environment where they can’t simply rely on ChatGPT to do the work for them.”

“AI should, at best, be viewed like the calculator: it may eventually be useful as a tool, but can be dangerous if you don’t first understand the foundation of what it’s helping you accomplish,” she added.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Megaspeed says Alice Huang left in 2025 as company conducts internal probe over Nvidia fallout

Megaspeed Says Alice Huang Left Amid Nvidia Fallout Probe

Singapore-based cloud computing firm Megaspeed International said Sunday that Chinese businesswoman Alice…
Michael John Roberts, 'BoJack Horseman' animator, has died

BoJack Horseman Animator Michael John Roberts Has Died

Michael John Roberts, the Canadian animator known best for his work on…
Columbia's gates will remain closed to NYC locals, judge rules

Judge Rules Columbia University Gates Will Remain Closed to NYC Residents

Columbia University can continue keeping its gates closed to the public after…
Los Angeles illegal dumping crisi sees 44 million pounds of trash collected as garbage fees soar

Los Angeles Illegal Dumping Crisis: 44M Pounds Cleared as Fees Soar

Los Angeles is being likened to a Third World dumping ground as…
Vile dad killed baby son who wouldn't stop him crying while he played video games

Father killed baby son for crying while playing video games

A Hawaii father is accused of fatally injuring his 3-month-old son after…
Van Hollen boasts he has 'very open lane' take Senate leadership from Schumer

Sen. Chris Van Hollen Sees ‘Open Lane’ to Succeed Schumer

Democratic Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland said Sunday that he has…
Wes Moore accused of fabricating friendship with slain soldier

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore Accused of Fabricating Friendship With Slain Soldier

Maryland Democratic Gov. Wes Moore included an inaccurate account of a fellow…
Blinken warns US ground invasion of Iran would be 'absolute disaster' as Tehran escalates attacks

Blinken Warns US Ground Invasion of Iran Would Be ‘Absolute Disaster’ as Tehran Escalates Attacks

Former Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Saturday that airstrikes alone may…
San Diego Zoo elephant 'Nipho' dies from ‘unusually fast’ disease

San Diego Zoo Elephant Nipho Dies From Unusually Fast Disease

A 15-year-old elephant at the San Diego Zoo has died from a…
Bruce Springsteen fan club shut down by admin after becoming torn apart by political fights, El Sayed endorsement

Bruce Springsteen Fan Club Shuts Down After Fight Over Abdul El-Sayed Endorsement

Administrators have shut down a Bruce Springsteen fan club after reaching a…
Georgia student’s first words revealed after she survived 8-story drunken fall from dorm while listening to Miley Cyrus

Georgia Student’s First Words Revealed After Surviving Eight-Story Dorm Fall While Listening to Miley Cyrus

A Georgia college student who miraculously survived an eight-story fall had been…
Glenn Close, Ridley Scott and Floyd Norman honored at 2026 Governors Awards in Hollywood

Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, Floyd Norman Honored at Governors Awards

HOLLYWOOD, LOS ANGELES (KABC) — Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, animator Floyd Norman…