Share this @internewscast.com

CHICAGO (WLS) — The lifeguard accused of being involved in a fatal shooting at a West Side park has been ordered by the judge to remain in custody until his trial. The judge cited his poor judgement and potential threat to public safety as reasons for the decision.

Charles Leto, a 55-year-old Chicago resident, faces accusations of shooting two teenagers in Douglass Park, resulting in the death of one of them. His initial court appearance took place on Sunday.

Prosecutors said the Marine veteran purposely targeted and shot two teens, killing one of them.

According to Leto’s defense attorney, the shootings were provoked. The attorney claimed that his client acted in self-defense after the teenagers allegedly threatened Leto and indicated intentions to steal his bike.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Family members said a 14-year-old cousin of Laquan McDonald was wounded in the shooting at Douglass Park that left a 15-year-old boy dead.

Leto has been charged with first-degree murder, first-degree attempted murder, aggravated battery and discharged of a firearm, Chicago police announced Saturday.

The shooting happened around 7:03 p.m. Thursday in the 1400-block South Sacramento Drive in Douglass Park, police said.

The 14-year-old victim was shot in the neck and was taken to a hospital in serious condition, CPD said. Family members identified him as Jeremy Herred, a cousin of Laquan McDonald, who was killed by Chicago police in 2014.

His uncle is Pastor Marvin Hunter of Grace Memorial Baptist Church. His family said Herred is a sophomore at UIC Prep and had only been to the pool two or three times.

The other victim, a 15-year-old boy, was shot in the back and was later pronounced dead. He was identified as Marjay Dotson by the Cook County Medical Examiner’s Office, who ruled his death a homicide.

During a Sunday afternoon detention hearing, prosecutors said Leto, who holds a valid FOID card and a concealed carry license, violated Chicago Park District policy by bringing a gun to work.

Authorities said Leto opened fire on the boys after having words with a third teen who was upset that the pool was closing. That boy was unharmed in the attack.

Leto’s defense attorney countered, saying her client is a decorated veteran who still worked at the park despite earlier incidents she claims lead to several other lifeguards quitting.

Leto’s lawyer claims he was just defending himself when he opened fire on the teens, who he says who had physically threatened him and had already damaged his bike when they tried to steal it.

West side pastor Reverend Robin Hood’s granddaughter knows the teens and was in the park when the shooting happened.

“It just don’t make sense to have a gun at a pool,” Rev. Hood said.

Family of both victims did not speak after the hearing Sunday, but they did pray and comfort one another. On Saturday, they told ABC7 they would like to see Leto also charged with a hate crime.

Leto’s next court appearance is scheduled for Tuesday.

INTERACTIVE SAFETY TRACKER Track crime and safety in your neighborhood

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Feds make 25 more arrests in anti-ICE Minnesota church invasion

Federal Authorities Arrest 25 in Connection to Anti-ICE Demonstration at Minnesota Church

Attorney General Pam Bondi has announced the arrest of 25 individuals in…
California serial child rapist granted parole admitted having pedophilic fantasies as recently as 2021

Outrage Erupts as California Frees Serial Child Rapist with Recent Pedophilic Fantasies

A convicted child rapist from California, who faced widespread public outcry over…
Luigi Mangione escapes federal death penalty after federal prosecutors decline to appeal judge's ruling

Luigi Mangione Dodges Federal Death Penalty: Prosecutors Opt Out of Appeal

Judge rules Luigi Mangione won’t face death penalty In a significant legal…
Notorious pedophile slapped with new charges just hours before he was due to be released from prison

Convicted Pedophile Faces Fresh Charges on Eve of Prison Release

In a dramatic turn of events, a convicted pedophile has been faced…
NY reps silent on accepting pay while 120,000 DHS workers go unpaid during shutdown

NY Representatives Under Fire: Silence on Pay Acceptance Amid DHS Worker Shutdown Crisis

The majority of New York’s congressional representatives are staying tight-lipped about whether…
Pink in consideration to take over Kelly Clarkson’s talk show slot at NBC

Pink Poised to Shine: NBC Considers Pop Icon to Replace Kelly Clarkson’s Talk Show Slot

In a potential shake-up at NBC, the network is considering Pink as…
Ex-nonprofit boss allegedly swiped $1.2M meant for homeless programs to fund lavish lifestyle, DA says

Former Nonprofit CEO Accused of Embezzling $1.2M from Homeless Funds for Personal Luxury

The leader of a city-funded nonprofit in San Francisco is accused of…
Dad stabs wife, daughter to death with massive curved dagger: cops

Tragic Double Homicide: Father Allegedly Uses Curved Dagger in Fatal Attack on Wife and Daughter

A tragic domestic incident unfolded in Virginia when a father fatally attacked…
Asking Eric: Informal music group marred by tone-deaf participant

Discord in Harmony: Tone-Deaf Member Challenges Cohesion of Informal Music Group ‘Asking Eric

Dear Eric: Our circle of friends regularly gathers to enjoy making music…
Savannah Guthrie’s $1M reward mirrors past kidnapping cases solved by cash

How Savannah Guthrie’s $1M Bounty Echoes Historic Ransom Resolutions

Several high-profile kidnapping cases have been resolved recently, with substantial rewards playing…
Crystal Mangum, who falsely accused Duke lacrosse players of rape, freed after killing boyfriend

Crystal Mangum, known for the Duke lacrosse case, released following conviction for boyfriend’s death

Crystal Mangum, once an exotic dancer who gained notoriety for falsely accusing…
How the Susan Rice snafu cost Netflix on home stretch of Warner Bros. Discovery deal

Netflix Faces Setback in Warner Bros. Discovery Deal Due to Susan Rice Controversy

A variety of factors contributed to Netflix’s decision to withdraw from the…