Lindsay Clancy holdout juror reveals 'tense' moments during deliberations -- but insists he had no reasonable doubt

The only juror who resisted a verdict in Lindsay Clancy’s triple-murder trial described deliberations as “tense,” while maintaining that he personally had no reasonable doubt about her guilt.

Michael Desronvil rejected fellow jurors’ accounts that he harbored reasonable doubt. Even so, he would not agree to find the 36-year-old mother criminally responsible for strangling her three children.

When Fox News host Kayleigh McEnany asked whether he had reasonable doubt, Desronvil replied, “No.”

Lindsay Clancy, confined to a wheelchair, is brought into the Plymouth Superior Court on Friday, Feb. 20, 2026. She is charged with the murder of her three children. USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

“I had a lot of evidence to back up my claim,” he said, adding that, out of respect for the other jurors and the court system, he would set the matter aside for now while the legal process continued.

The court has not scheduled a new trial. Prosecutors also have yet to announce whether they will again pursue the same first-degree murder charges against Clancy.


Here’s the latest on Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial


Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, urged jurors to find her not guilty by reason of insanity. He argued that she was experiencing severe postpartum psychosis and had hallucinated a man’s voice commanding her to kill her children and herself.

Prosecutors offered a sharply different account, arguing that Clancy deliberately planned and carried out the killings of Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, on Jan. 24, 2023.

The jury—nine women and three men—spent seven days deliberating. A judge ultimately declared a mistrial after the panel sent three notes saying it was unable to break the deadlock.

Michael Desronvil, the lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial, speaking in a Fox News interview.

Michael Desronvil, the lone holdout juror at Lindsay Clancy’s triple murder trial, speaks during an interview with Fox News. Fox News

“There were moments that were tense as we were deliberating,” Desronvil said.

Fox News’ full interview with Desronvil is scheduled to air Thursday morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

10 alleged noncitizens indicted in massive California voter fraud investigation

10 Alleged Noncitizens Indicted in Massive California Voter Fraud Case

Ten alleged noncitizens were indicted Wednesday on federal election fraud charges, marking…
Canadian mother and daughter dead after suspected grizzly bear attack on hiking trail

Canadian Mother, Daughter Killed in Suspected Grizzly Bear Attack

A Canadian mother and her daughter died in a suspected grizzly bear…
WATCH: Bodycam captures chaotic response to deadly Citibank shooting in Florida

WATCH: Bodycam Footage Shows Chaotic Response to Deadly Florida Citibank Shooting

Newly released body camera video shows the frantic response as Hillsborough County…
California’s biggest election loser is Dave Regan, union boss who blew $47M on two failed ballot props

California Union Leader Dave Regan Spent $47M on Two Failed Ballot Measures

Labor leader Dave Regan’s campaign to tax California billionaires ended in a…
Nithya Raman widens lead over Karen Bass in LA mayor race

Nithya Raman Widens Lead Over Karen Bass in LA Mayor Race

Nithya Raman widened her lead over Karen Bass on Wednesday in the…
‘DEI is back!’ screams California Dem Ro Khanna after losing Prop 40 tax vote he backed

California Rep. Ro Khanna Says ‘DEI Is Back’ After Prop 40 Loss

California Rep. Ro Khanna celebrated what he described as a resurgence of…
Suspect, victim dead after SWAT responds to 'active threat' at office complex near Tampa, Florida

Suspect and Victim Dead After SWAT Responds to Active Threat Near Tampa, Florida

A suspect died after authorities responded to an active shooter report at…
Heavy rain triggers flash flood emergency in Southern states as cross-country storm shifts east

Heavy Rain Triggers Flash Flood Emergency Across Southern States as Storm Moves East

Torrential rain sparked Flash Flood Emergencies in Polk County, Tennessee, and Fannin…
Attempted car theft by teen leads to multiple Clovis school lockdowns

Teen’s Attempted Car Theft Triggers Multiple Clovis School Lockdowns

An 18-year-old man allegedly tried to steal a vehicle before leading police…
Inglewood Mayor James Butts storms out of interview as reelection hangs by a thread

Inglewood Mayor James Butts Walks Out of Interview as Reelection Race Tightens

Inglewood Mayor James Butts abruptly ended an interview with a Los Angeles…
Indiana murderer Jeffrey Weisheit executed for 2010 double killing first of three scheduled in US

Indiana Killer Jeffrey Weisheit Executed in First of Three US Cases

Indiana executed a man early Thursday who admitted setting the fire that…
17-year-old accused in California Spirit Halloween shooting that killed pregnant woman, injured 6

Teen Accused in Spirit Halloween Shooting That Killed Pregnant Woman

A 17-year-old California boy appeared in juvenile court Wednesday as authorities investigated…