Lindsay Clancy prosecutors come across as 'tone deaf,' 'uncaring' and 'snarky,' defense attorney says

A Massachusetts judge has scheduled March 29 for the start of Lindsay Clancy’s retrial on murder charges in the strangulation deaths of her three young children.

Clancy’s first trial ended Sept. 4 after jurors deadlocked 11-1. Only one juror voted to convict her of murder, while the other 11 supported the defense’s argument that she should not be held criminally responsible because of mental illness.

Judge William Sullivan repeatedly urged the parties to select a trial date in March or April. Prosecutors initially sought a May trial before later requesting a date near the end of April. Sullivan ultimately set the retrial for late March.

Lindsay Clancy awaits jury deliberations

Lindsay Clancy looks toward jurors as Judge Sullivan asks them to begin a sixth day of deliberations during her murder trial on Thursday, Sept. 3, 2026, in Plymouth, Massachusetts. (Pool Photo by Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger)

“You’ve all handled retrials, and generally, the sooner a case is retried, the better it is for everyone involved,” Sullivan said.

Prosecutors have not said whether they plan to pursue the same charges. However, Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, said he expects the district attorney’s office to proceed with the existing first-degree murder counts.

Legal experts said reducing the charges could create an opportunity for a plea agreement or a trial decided by a judge rather than a jury.

Reddington told Fox News’ Bryan Llenas in September that if prosecutors lowered the lead charge to second-degree murder, he would seek a bench trial, without jurors, in hopes that Clancy would receive probation.

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy. The three children were killed at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

“I would like to see [Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz] reduce the charge to second-degree murder so we could potentially waive a jury and try the case before a judge,” Reddington said. “I would like to see Tim determine that the case should not proceed and dismiss it, or, alternatively, find a way for Lindsay to receive the mental and physical treatment she needs instead of facing criminal prosecution — because I would not, ever, in a million years, want that woman to go to Framingham State Prison.”

Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and law professor, said a bench trial would require considerably fewer resources than holding a second jury trial. He said prosecutors might pursue second-degree murder charges if they concluded Clancy’s mental illness prevented her from forming the intent necessary for a first-degree murder conviction.

Because Sullivan is preparing to retire, any delay could result in the retrial taking place before a different judge.

“Perhaps this will be the unusual murder trial that proceeds without a hitch,” he told News Outlet. “For instance, have the attorneys confirmed and secured the availability of their experts? That could delay the trial.”

Lu also questioned whether Clancy’s retrial should take precedence over other cases pending in the same court.

“My answer is no,” he said Monday.

Lindsay Clancy's husband, Patrick Clancy leaves court

Patrick Clancy leaves Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, on Monday, July 27, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

“It appears to be pushing older murder trials aside,” Lu said. “I agree with the prosecutor on this point: ‘It is unfair to them.’ ‘Them’ refers to the victims and defendants in other murder cases.”

Assistant Plymouth County District Attorney Jennifer Sprague cited other trials scheduled in the court while arguing for a May date, but Sullivan overruled her objection and set Clancy’s retrial for March.

On Jan. 24, 2023, Clancy’s former husband, Patrick Clancy, returned home from running errands and found her critically injured in their backyard. Inside the home, he discovered their three young children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months — strangled to death.

Prosecutors said Clancy tried to take her own life after killing the children while Patrick was away. Her injuries left her paralyzed, and she has remained hospitalized in Massachusetts while the case proceeds.

Clancy’s defense unsuccessfully raised double-jeopardy claims, which Sullivan rejected last week.

Her final pretrial conference is scheduled for Feb. 18.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Wes Moore accused of fabricating friendship with slain soldier

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore Accused of Fabricating Friendship With Slain Soldier

Maryland Democratic Gov. Wes Moore included an inaccurate account of a fellow…
NTSB details warning whistles and emergency orders before tanker collision capsized New Orleans riverboat

NTSB Details Warnings Before Tanker Collision Capsized New Orleans Riverboat

Federal investigators said Sunday that the tanker involved in Friday’s New Orleans…
Deputy working security at South Carolina gun show fatally shoots customer who shot at him

South Carolina Deputy Working Gun Show Security Fatally Shoots Customer After Being Fired Upon

A South Carolina sheriff’s deputy working security at a gun and knife…
UC Riverside theft: 'Homeless' man with ties to university charged over $800K tech heist

UC Riverside-Linked Man Charged in $800K Technology Theft Case

A man who said he was homeless has been arrested and charged…
Massachusetts bank vice president dies after being struck by bullet amid argument between two other relatives

Massachusetts Bank VP Killed by Stray Bullet in Relatives’ Dispute

A Massachusetts bank vice president died after being struck by a bullet…
Young paraglider dies after reported emergency sends him crashing into field during Illinois flight

Young Paraglider Dies After Reported Emergency Crash in Illinois Field

An Illinois paraglider died in a weekend crash after reportedly suffering an…
Michael John Roberts, 'BoJack Horseman' animator, has died

BoJack Horseman Animator Michael John Roberts Has Died

Michael John Roberts, the Canadian animator known best for his work on…
Vile dad killed baby son who wouldn't stop him crying while he played video games

Father killed baby son for crying while playing video games

A Hawaii father is accused of fatally injuring his 3-month-old son after…
Iranian Boxer on Death Row Wins Human Rights Award — ‘I Will Not Bow Before Oppression’

Iranian Boxer on Death Row Receives Human Rights Award, Vows Not to Bow to Oppression

Iranian boxing champion Mohammad Javad Vafaei-Sani, who faces execution for opposing the…
Everything to know about 2026 CMAs, from who's performing to how to watch

2026 CMA Awards: Performers, How to Watch and Everything to Know

The 60th Annual CMA Awards are only days away, bringing together some…
Charlamagne tha God blasts Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez for ‘beating around the bush,’ presses progressives on backing Hakeem Jeffries

Charlamagne tha God Blasts AOC Over Hakeem Jeffries Support

Radio personality Charlamagne tha God criticized Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., on Friday,…
Emergency crews responding to vessel collision near Port of New Orleans on Mississippi River

Emergency Crews Respond to Mississippi River Vessel Collision

NEW ORLEANS — More than 30 people were injured Friday when a…