Menendez brothers: Attorneys rescind motion to have LA County DA Nathan Hochman kicked off resentencing case
Share this @internewscast.com

Attorneys representing Erik and Lyle Menendez have withdrawn their request to disqualify Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman from overseeing the brothers’ resentencing case.

The motion was retracted during a morning court hearing at a Van Nuys courthouse.

Hochman, who opposes the brothers’ resentencing, last week filed an opposition to the recusal motion by attorneys for the Menendez brothers.

He called the efforts to remove him from the case a “drastic and desperate step” that is “devoid of merit.”

“Disagreeing with the opposing side’s position is not a conflict of interest, it is simply a disagreement,” it said.

The reason why the Menendez brothers’ attorneys pulled the recusal motion on Friday morning was not immediately clear.

Initially, the defense focused on Hochman’s actions and sought to have the entire case shifted from the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office. This would have potentially involved the state attorney general’s office stepping in.

This week, California Attorney General Rob Bonta supported Hochman by filing a motion. He noted that the defense hadn’t successfully shown there was a conflict of interest.

For Lyle and Erik Menendez, it’s hard to imagine a hearing more important to them in the past 30 years than the one later this week.

Before the recusal request was rescinded, a statement from the Menendez brothers’ family members said: “This has been a pattern of behavior. It is one thing to try to ignore our rights, but when you use every legal remedy to tilt the scales of justice, it becomes clear that there is more at play than overzealous advocacy.”

Laurie Levenson, a former federal prosecutor and professor of criminal law at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles, previously said that such recusal requests are “almost never” granted.

“Defendants don’t usually get to pick their prosecutors,” she said. “Occasionally an individual prosecutor will be recused, but to recuse an entire office is very rare.”

Generally, it only happens if a prosecutor’s personal family member is involved or if the district attorney’s office received outside payment in a case, Levenson said.

The path to possible resentencing

The brothers were sentenced in 1996 to life in prison without the possibility of parole for fatally shooting their entertainment executive father, Jose Menendez, and mother, Kitty Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home. The brothers were 18 and 21 at the time of the killings. Defense attorneys argued the brothers acted out of self-defense after years of sexual abuse by their father, while prosecutors said the brothers killed their parents for a multimillion-dollar inheritance.

Former L.A. County District Attorney George Gascón had opened the door to possible freedom for the brothers in October by requesting their sentences be reduced to 50 years with the possibility of parole. His office said the case would’ve been handled differently today due to modern understandings of sexual abuse and trauma, and that the brothers had rehabilitated during their 30 years in prison.

But current District Attorney Hochman has said the brothers have not taken full responsibility for their crimes because they have not admitted to lies told during their trials. The Menendez family and lawyers have been heavily critical of the way Hochman has handled the case.

During long-awaited resentencing hearings last month, attorneys engaged in a heated debate over whether material from risk assessments completed by the state parole board at the governor’s order should be admissible in court. The hearings were delayed, and the brothers’ lead attorney Mark Geragos said he would move to recuse Hochman from the case.

In a motion filed April 25, Geragos argued that Hochman’s bias against the brothers and mistreatment of the Menendez family posed a “genuine risk” the brothers would not receive a fair hearing.

The Menendez brothers are still waiting for the full results of a state parole board risk assessment ordered by Gov. Gavin Newsom’s office. The final hearing, scheduled for June 13, will influence whether Newsom grants the brothers clemency.

The perspective of a new generation of people who weren’t even alive during the murders of Kitty and José Menendez shows just how much has changed in three and a half decades.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2025 KABC Television, LLC. All rights reserved.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Jonathan Roldan killed ex-girlfriend's boyfriend, US Army veteran Andrew Garay, in Humboldt Park, Chicago shooting: prosecutors

Humboldt Park Shooting: Man Charged in Fatal Attack on Army Veteran Andrew Garay

A man is facing charges after allegedly shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend’s…
Iran issues dire warning about President Trump's Strait of Hormuz blockade

Iran’s Urgent Warning: Trump’s Strait of Hormuz Blockade Sparks Global Tensions

WASHINGTON — On Sunday, Iran issued a stern warning, asserting that military…
US blockade of Iranian ports via Strait of Hormuz takes effect

US Enforces Strategic Blockade on Iranian Ports as Strait of Hormuz Tensions Escalate

The United States initiated a naval blockade on Monday, effectively preventing ships…
Hungarians vote in crucial election that could unseat populist Prime Minister Orbán

Hungary’s Decisive Election: Potential Shift as Voters Challenge Prime Minister Orbán’s Populist Reign

BUDAPEST, Hungary — On Sunday, Hungarians headed to the polls in what…
Pope Leo XIV says he does not fear President Donald Trump, citing Gospel as he pushes back in feud over Iran war

Pope Leo XIV Stands Firm Against President Trump in Iran Conflict, Citing Gospel Values

WASHINGTON — In response to President Donald Trump’s recent criticism concerning the…
Trump makes wild claim defending Jesus-like AI post, refuses to apologize to Pope Leo over Iran war dispute

Trump Defends Controversial AI Jesus Post Amid Iran War Dispute, Dismisses Apology to Pope Leo

On Monday, President Trump stood firm in his decision not to apologize…
Iran in crisis as US talks collapse, Mojtaba’s ‘mafia’ regime blocks Khamenei burial: analyst

Iran Faces Turmoil: US Negotiations Fail as Mojtaba’s ‘Mafia’ Regime Halts Khamenei’s Burial, Expert Reveals

US ships move to clear mines in the Strait of Hormuz Retired…
Rory McIlroy defends his Masters title, joining Jack Nicklaus, Nick Faldo and Tiger Woods with back-to-back wins

Rory McIlroy Secures Consecutive Masters Victory, Joining Legends Jack Nicklaus, Nick Faldo, and Tiger Woods

Rory McIlroy etched his name deeper into golf’s storied history on Sunday…
Tyler Robinson's defense calls on expert from Kohberger case to argue bias in jury pool

Tyler Robinson’s Defense Enlists Kohberger Case Expert to Challenge Potential Jury Bias

In an upcoming courtroom battle, the defense team for Tyler Robinson, accused…
LA-area street takeover shooting caught on camera; locals scared, vow to move

Shooting at LA Street Takeover Captured on Camera; Residents Express Fear and Consider Relocation

Four individuals were hospitalized after a shooting erupted during a street takeover…
Hamas reps meeting with Egyptian negotiators to discuss Trump's Gaza peace plan

Hamas Engages with Egyptian Mediators to Evaluate Trump’s Proposed Gaza Peace Plan

Representatives from Hamas were anticipated to engage in discussions with Egyptian mediators…
Rep. Eric Swalwell suspends campaign for California governor amid sexual assault allegations

Rep. Eric Swalwell Halts California Gubernatorial Campaign Following Sexual Assault Allegations

California Representative Eric Swalwell has decided to pause his gubernatorial campaign following…