Missouri neighbor accused of killing mother and teen daughter after confronting family over dispute

This story discusses suicide. If you or someone you know is having thoughts of suicide, please contact the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 988 or 1-800-273-TALK (8255).

A Missouri mother and her teenage daughter were fatally shot inside their home after a neighbor came over to complain about a “dispute,” authorities said.

Robert Winkelman, 73, walked from his residence to a nearby home in House Springs, Missouri, on July 25 and confronted 38-year-old Jessica Lashly about what was happening at her house, according to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office.

As Lashly answered him, investigators said, Winkelman drew a gun and shot her in the head.

A woman and a teenage girl smile together outdoors near a fountain, the girl holding a pink rose.

Jessica Lashly, 38, and her 17-year-old daughter, Jersey Greer, were both fatally shot inside their House Springs, Mo., home. (Midlawn Funeral Home & Memorial Gardens)

Lashly’s 17-year-old daughter, Jersey Greer, then tried to come to her mother’s aid, but Winkelman shot her in the head as well, the sheriff’s office said. Authorities said Winkelman, still armed, also chased a third person, though that person was not shot. Lashly and Greer later died at a hospital in the days after the attack.

Deputies responding to the scene went to Winkelman’s home to confront him, but officials said he turned the gun on himself.

Winkelman died at a hospital on Aug. 2, investigators said. Had he survived, authorities said he would have faced two counts of first-degree murder and two counts of armed criminal action.

According to reports, investigators said Winkelman initially went to Lashly’s home to complain about noise. A spokesman for the sheriff’s office characterized the incident to News Outlet as a “dispute between neighbors.”

Investigators learned that Winkelman had “ongoing frustrations” with activities at Lashly’s home.

A booking-style photo of an older man with gray hair against a blue background.

Robert Winkelman, 73, walked to his neighbor’s home and opened fire, according to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office. He later died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)

Justice Greer, the teenage victim’s twin sister, told KSDK, “She was literally just the funniest person ever.

“She could make anybody laugh. She was really supportive about anything and everything. She could always tell when someone was sad or needed uplifting, and she was always the one to do it.

“Jersey’s last moments, she was trying to save my mom. It just shows how brave she is, and I hope I can be half as brave as she is.”

Justice Greer said Lashly was a single mother who did everything she could to support her daughters.

A black Jefferson County Sheriff SUV parked in a lot on an overcast day.

The Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office said Winkelman would have faced two counts of first-degree murder and two counts of armed criminal action. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)

“It was always just us three,” Justice said. “It’s going to be really hard because that’s all I’m used to.”

Abby Feldmann, who coached Justice and Jersey Greer in lacrosse, told KSDK Jersey was someone who could “change your whole perspective on life.”

“There’s not one person who would refuse to follow her,” Feldmann said. “Everyone’s behind her. She’s really an amazing girl.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

High School Basketball Coach Arrested After Attacking Referee Over Foul Call

High School Basketball Coach Arrested After Attacking Referee Over Foul Call

A Connecticut high school girls basketball coach was arrested after allegedly tripping…
Sheriff’s Department Issues Update on Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case Nine Months Later

Sheriff’s Department Issues Update on Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case Nine Months Later

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department said Friday that investigators remain focused on…
Police Update Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case as Month 9 Nears

Police Update Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case as Month 9 Nears

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department said Friday that investigators remain focused on…
Three Killed in Helicopter Collision Near Oregon Airport

Three Killed in Helicopter Collision Near Oregon Airport

Three people were killed Thursday afternoon when two helicopters collided in midair…
Glendale Doctor Sentenced to 15 Years for $45 Million Botox Fraud Scheme

Glendale Doctor Sentenced to 15 Years for $45 Million Botox Fraud Scheme

A California doctor who defrauded Medicare of more than $45 million to…
NYPD Hopeful Killed in Connecticut Crash; Driver Deported Twice

NYPD Hopeful Killed in Connecticut Crash; Driver Deported Twice

A 21-year-old college hockey captain who hoped to become a police officer…
California Unions Win TRO; CHIRLA Gets DOJ List, DOJ Loses

California Unions Win TRO; CHIRLA Gets DOJ List, DOJ Loses

On Thursday, the SEIU and AFL-CIO, which represent election workers across California,…
Karen Bass Makes Final Reelection Push on LAPD and Housing

Karen Bass Makes Final Reelection Push on LAPD and Housing

Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass is acknowledging her mistakes and asking voters…
Zohran Mamdani Invokes Race While Defending Progressive Abdul El-Sayed

Zohran Mamdani Invokes Race While Defending Progressive Abdul El-Sayed

Abdul El-Sayed, the left-wing Michigan Senate candidate who authored research papers warning…
Texas AG Ken Paxton Claims Media Hides James Talarico’s Record

Texas AG Ken Paxton Claims Media Hides James Talarico’s Record

Appearing Friday on FNC’s “The Will Cain Show,” Texas Republican U.S. Senate…
Trump Backs Bill Essayli After Court Rejects Bid to Block California Noncitizen Voting Measure

Trump Backs Bill Essayli After Court Rejects Bid to Block California Noncitizen Voting Measure

President Trump is intensifying his dispute with California election officials, criticizing a…
Lawyer: Alexander Brothers Used Jets, Yachts to Lure and Silence Women

Lawyer: Alexander Brothers Used Jets, Yachts to Lure and Silence Women

Private jets, superyachts, lavish homes and connections to wealthy and influential figures…