New York Democrats scored major victories in this year’s elections, benefiting from a law that moved several local contests onto even-numbered years, when they appear on the same ballots as federal races.
The 2026 elections marked the first test of the change since the law took effect in 2023. Under the new schedule, town and county races that had traditionally been held in odd-numbered years were shifted to even years, when voter participation is typically stronger.
Supporters say the move encourages more people to vote. Critics, however, argue that local concerns can be overshadowed by national politics and that the new calendar gives Democrats an advantage in heavily Democratic New York.
“We’ve had great success,” said state Democratic Party Chairman Jay Jacobs, a longtime advocate of the change. He said he had spent 11 years pushing to move local elections to even-numbered years, when statewide and federal contests draw more Democratic voters to the polls.
Republicans, meanwhile, continue to seek a return to the former election schedule.
The Republican Party sued to stop the law, contending that the new timing makes it harder for local candidates to focus on community issues and was designed to improve Democratic performance in traditionally low-turnout elections.
New York’s Court of Appeals upheld the law. Republicans then brought the dispute to federal court, where the case remains pending.
For now, Democrats are enjoying the political payoff from the legislation, which was approved by the party-controlled state Legislature and signed by Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul.

Jacobs pointed to several Democratic breakthroughs following the scheduling change, including historic victories in the races for Hempstead town supervisor and clerk, a win for Erie County clerk and the capture of three legislative seats in Dutchess County.
Hochul was the most recent Democrat to win the Erie County clerk’s race before this year, taking the office in 2010.
MORE STORY: Who is Kelsey Mitchell Dating? Is She Married in 2026? Relationship With Caitlin Clark
A campaign strategist said the decision to hold local elections in even-numbered years has placed Republicans at a disadvantage, a dynamic reflected in this year’s results.
The challenge could grow in 2028, when a presidential election is expected to produce the nation’s highest voter turnout — especially among Democrats.
“It’s going to be more challenging for Republicans to win back seats they lost this year,” said O’Brien Murray, a strategist who has managed campaigns for candidates from both parties.
Murray said additional Republican-held seats could also become vulnerable in 2028.
“There’s greater Democratic turnout in even-year elections. That’s always been the case,” he said.
Murray also said he believes combining municipal and county elections with higher-profile contests is a mistake because local debates can “get lost in the clutter” of federal and statewide campaigns.
Democrats hold more than a two-to-one voter-registration advantage across New York, with roughly 6.5 million enrolled Democrats compared with 3 million Republicans, according to state Board of Elections data.
That margin is driven largely by New York City, where Democrats outnumber Republicans by about 3.5 million to 578,000, the data shows.
Even outside New York City, Democrats maintain an advantage of approximately 471,000 registered voters.
Democrats also outnumber Republicans in 15 counties, including Erie, Nassau, Onondaga, Orange, Rensselaer, Rockland, Schenectady, Ulster and Westchester.