A New York City banjo player says baggage handlers damaged his century-old instrument and destroyed its vintage case, leaving him “singing the blues.”
David Fryer, 38, of the Upper East Side, traveled to the UK earlier this month for performances in London and Bristol. During the first leg of his TAP Air Portugal journey, he said, he was allowed to place his 1925 Lange plectrum banjo in its original case in the overhead compartment.
But on his return flight to Newark on Wednesday, the airline took a different approach. Crew members aboard flight EP1329 from Gatwick told Fryer he had to gate-check the valuable instrument, despite his claim that it “fits easily in the overhead compartment.” They assured him it would be handled carefully, he said.
“I very emphatically impressed upon them that this is a 100-year-old banjo and it can’t be put on the conveyor belt, it can’t be thrown around or anything,” Fryer said. He described the vintage instrument as “quite rare” and “priceless to me.”
After a layover in Porto, Fryer arrived in Newark and said he heard a “loud slam” just before workers brought out the banjo.
“They brought it out and the case was falling apart; the two sides, the top and bottom of the case, were basically falling off,” Fryer recalled.
“On the bottom there are metal studs that keep it stable when you put it on the ground. One of those was impacted, pushed in, so the bottom of the case was also broken.”
Fryer said the airline workers offered neither an apology nor compensation, prompting him to file an online complaint.
“They lied to me, and tossed around a precious vintage instrument and piece of history from the 1920s,” Fryer said. He added that similar banjos can sell for as much as $3,500 on the secondary market.
The New York native, who performs around the city as Urban Orangutan and with the blues band Hyllus & the Veligers, posted photos of the damage online and described the experience as “horrific.”
“I hope, for one, that any musicians considering traveling with TAP Air and bringing their instruments should know they can’t be trusted,” the plectrum player said.
“And if they’re trying to make you gate-check your instrument and they promise it will be handled in an acceptable manner, they should know that that is a lie.”
Fryer said the banjo remains playable for now, but “time will tell” whether the impact caused damage that could create problems later.
TAP Air Portugal did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
A US law enacted in 2015 requires domestic airlines to permit musicians to carry small stringed instruments in the cabin. However, the rule does not apply to flights that originate or end outside the United States.
The incident follows a separate episode earlier this year in which a baggage handler at LAX was filmed throwing guitars across the tarmac.
In 2024, singer Madi Diaz accused Delta of deliberately smashing her guitar, leading the airline to apologize.