NYC woman accused of deed theft claims co-conspirator stole her home: lawsuit

A Manhattan woman charged in an alleged deed-theft plot involving the Queens home of a dying widow is now accusing her purported partner in the scheme of taking her property as well.

Deepa V. Roy, 69, and Victor Quimis, 40, were indicted in August 2025 on deed-theft charges. Prosecutors say the pair worked together to take control of Renuka Bherwani’s Kew Gardens Hills house while the 88-year-old woman was receiving hospice care.

In a lawsuit filed recently, Roy alleges that Quimis engineered an “egregious deed theft scheme” to seize the Flushing home she owned with her late husband. She is seeking at least $1 million for the alleged deed theft, unpaid rent and the loss of personal property.

Deed theft, which New York officials have pledged to combat as reported cases increase, typically involves forged paperwork, false statements or other deception used to unlawfully transfer ownership of a home.

According to a complaint filed Sept. 16 in Queens Supreme Court, Roy turned to Quimis after her husband, Abner Richard Siegel, died in November 2023. She allegedly asked him to help evict squatters from the Queens property that the couple had owned together.

Instead, Roy claims, Quimis exploited her as an elderly woman grieving her husband and prepared two bargain-and-sale deeds that eventually placed the approximately $817,000 property in his name.

The documents were allegedly notarized by a fictitious official identified as “Shereece Rthel Clarke.” The paperwork also reportedly carried the typo-filled stamp, “State od [sic] New York.”

Roy says the final fraudulent deed was dated Jan. 22, 2024.

Quimis eventually removed the squatters in June 2025, but Roy alleges that he then moved his own relatives into the house. The complaint says Quimis, his wife Margot, his mother-in-law and their two children have occupied the investment property without paying rent.

Roy also accuses Quimis of taking or damaging items belonging to her, including a boiler worth about $12,000 that was installed in 2015, large household appliances and antique furniture. She further claims he stripped and remodeled a Golden Dodge Ram limousine that had belonged to Siegel’s father.

“Ms. Roy is not a perpetrator of deed theft; she is its primary victim,” Christopher Anderson, her attorney in the civil lawsuit, told The Post. “Rather than remaining silent, Ms. Roy has taken aggressive, proactive legal action to hold Mr. Quimis accountable.” Quimis and his wife did not respond to requests for comment.

The criminal investigation and prosecution of Roy and Quimis remain active, according to the New York state attorney general’s office. The defendants are scheduled to return to court Nov. 4.

Both have pleaded not guilty to multiple charges connected to the alleged deed theft. Authorities said the case marked the first prosecution brought under New York’s law specifically criminalizing deed theft.

Officials and Bherwani’s relatives allege that Roy and Quimis produced a fraudulent deed dated Oct. 13, 2024, while Bherwani was in hospice care and suffering from dementia. She died at age 88 in June 2025.

Bherwani’s son, Kamal Bherwani, who served as an executive in the administrations of former New York City mayors Michael Bloomberg and Rudy Giuliani, has filed a separate civil lawsuit against Roy and Quimis.

He has rejected Roy’s portrayal of herself as an innocent target and believes she is attempting to distance herself from the allegations involving his mother.

“It’s just ironic that she’s making that statement a few weeks before a criminal trial,” Kamal Bherwani told The Post. He alleged that Roy brought Quimis into the matter, adding that Quimis “is an expert in doing this” and that Roy was the person who identified his mother as a potential target.

Jeremy Saland, who represents Roy in the criminal case, said his client “continues to vigorously fight and dispute the allegations against her.”

He argued that both women could have been victimized, saying, “It’s important to recognize that two unfortunate realities can be true: Renuka Bherwani may very well have been the victim of Mr. Quimis, but so was Deepa Roy.”

Attorneys representing Quimis in the criminal proceedings did not respond to requests for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Mamdani distances himself from DSA's wildest platforms during rapid-fire Fox News questioning

NYC mayoral candidate Mamdani distances himself from DSA on Fox News

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani again sought to distance himself from some…
Ex-police officer accused of stabbing NYC jogger to death appears emotionless in new photos

Ex-NYPD Officer Appears Stone-Faced After NYC Jogger Stabbing Charge

A former NYPD officer accused of killing a Brooklyn jogger was escorted…
The secret turbulence of Charles and Anne Lindbergh's marriage

Inside Charles and Anne Lindbergh’s Secretly Turbulent Marriage

By any standard, Charles Lindbergh and Anne Morrow Lindbergh were remarkable figures:…
Bill Maher Unleashes After Left’s Sweeping Midterms Victory, Warns Democrats

Bill Maher Warns Democrats After Left’s Sweeping Midterm Wins

Bill Maher isn’t celebrating the Democrat Party’s sweeping midterm victories without reservations.…
Georgia teens, adult charged with murder after mom finds son Austin Payne dead in home

Georgia Teens and Adult Charged After Austin Payne Found Dead at Home

Three teenagers and a 22-year-old man are facing murder charges in Georgia…
Dem wins coin toss to break election tie, then takes home the quarter

Democrat Wins Coin Toss to Break Election Tie, Keeps Quarter

It was a victory decided by chance—and a clear sign of change.…
James Talarico crashes 'SNL' cold open days after turning Texas blue

Texas Democrat James Talarico Crashes SNL Cold Open After Win

Newly elected Texas Sen. James Talarico made a surprise appearance in the…
Slain NYC jogger Katie Suarez saved 5 lives as organ donor after brutal stabbing: sources

Slain NYC Jogger Katie Suarez Saves Five Lives Through Organ Donation

Katie Suarez, the Brooklyn jogger who was fatally stabbed in the neck…
North Dakota woman chained to bed, assaulted and beaten for 2 years: police

Police: North Dakota Woman Chained to Bed, Abused for 2 Years

A North Dakota woman was allegedly chained to a bed for two…
Two experienced skydivers die after midair collision entangles their parachutes

Experienced Skydivers Die in Midair Collision, Chutes Entangled

Two experienced skydivers were killed Friday after their parachutes became tangled during…
Gingrich: Dems will fail in 2028 if they don’t work with Trump

Newt Gingrich Warns Democrats: Work With Trump or Lose in 2028

Democrats risk derailing their chances in the 2028 election if they shift…
Jane Kim vows state-run wildfire insurance fund for California

Ex-SF Supervisor Jane Kim Pledges California Wildfire Insurance Fund

California’s incoming insurance commissioner is vowing to transform the state’s troubled insurance…