Untapped Karmelo Anthony evidence cache showed he stalked ex-girlfriend, had 'knives' obsession: prosecutors

Prosecutors said Thursday that jurors who convicted Karmelo Anthony of murder never heard evidence they claim pointed to an alleged history involving knives and violent behavior, as the state urged a judge to reject his bid for a new trial.

The claims emerged during a hearing on Anthony’s request for another trial. Lead prosecutor Bill Wirske told the court that Anthony’s former girlfriend went to his school on the morning of the fatal stabbing and reported that she was scared of him.

Wirske also said prosecutors possessed text messages and other evidence that, in the state’s view, reflected Anthony’s interest in violence and knives. That information was not shown to the jury during the murder trial.

According to the prosecutor, Anthony’s original defense lawyers had a verbal agreement with the state to exclude character evidence related to Anthony, Austin Metcalf and Austin’s brother, Hunter Metcalf, from the proceedings.

Karmelo Anthony

Karmelo Anthony is shown after being transferred into the custody of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. He was taken to his assigned facility at the Pack Unit near Navasota. (Texas Department of Criminal Justice)

Anthony’s current attorneys challenge that version of events. They argue prosecutors failed to abide by the agreement and say the disagreement influenced whether Anthony chose to take the witness stand in his own defense.

The defense also contends jurors were not allowed to consider evidence they believe could have strengthened Anthony’s self-defense argument. His lawyers referenced school records, social media posts and videos that they say suggest previous aggressive conduct by Austin Metcalf and his twin brother.

Defense attorneys pointed to alleged racist remarks, earlier fights and disciplinary issues, arguing that Anthony was aware the brothers had the potential to act aggressively.

The material was not presented to the original jury, and the court has not made findings on the allegations.

Retired District Judge Michael Chitty is hearing Anthony’s motion for a new trial Thursday, after Judge Sid Harle removed Judge John Roach from Anthony’s remaining trial-court proceedings Wednesday.

Harle found that a reasonable outside observer could question whether Roach appeared impartial after Roach said in a post-trial television interview that the jury “got it right” and defended several of his trial decisions.

Austin Metcalf, killed at track meet in Texas

File photo of Austin Metcalf, a junior at Memorial High School in Frisco, who was stabbed in the chest allegedly by 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony, a student-athlete from Frisco Centennial High School. (Courtesy Jeff Metcalf)

Roach’s removal is a significant win for Anthony’s new legal team, but it does not erase his conviction or sentence. The far more consequential question is whether Chitty will grant Anthony a new trial.

Metcalf’s father, Jeff Metcalf, said Roach’s removal did not change his view of the case because it did not alter the evidence that led to Anthony’s conviction.

“It’s just one step in a long journey,” Metcalf said Wednesday on “The Will Cain Show.” “It doesn’t really change the facts.”

Anthony, 19, was convicted in June of murdering 17-year-old Metcalf, who he fatally stabbed during an altercation at a Frisco track meet. A Collin County jury sentenced Anthony to 35 years in prison.

Before Thursday’s hearing, an estimated 75 to 100 people gathered outside the courtroom, with some raising their fists as lead defense attorney Russell Wilson arrived. One man wore a Black Panther uniform.

Members of the Anthony and Metcalf families sat on opposite sides of the courtroom. Metcalf’s father greeted Wirske before the hearing, and Anthony entered in a navy suit and tie with his wrists shackled.

Criminal appellate lawyer Brett Ordiway said motions to remove a judge are difficult and uncommon, but a motion for a new trial is a much steeper legal climb.

“Granting that motion wipes out the conviction and the sentence altogether and gives Karmelo Anthony a new trial,” Ordiway told News Outlet. “It is very, very difficult to win these motions in any case, and I would be surprised if they were successful here.”

Anthony’s attorneys argued Roach could not fairly consider the new-trial request because his public comments addressed the same issues they raise in their motion, including courtroom access.

Austin Metcalf, killed at track meet in Texas

File photo of Jeff Metcalf with his son, Austin Metcalf, a junior at Memorial High School in Frisco, who was stabbed in the chest allegedly by 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony, a student-athlete from Frisco Centennial High School. (Courtesy Jeff Metcalf)

The motion argues Anthony’s trial was not open enough to the public. Cameras were barred from the courtroom and only 27 seats were available for members of the public.

The new-trial motion also challenges the jury instructions, arguing they limited jurors’ ability to fully consider Anthony’s claim of self-defense.

During Thursday’s hearing, Wilson said the defense would present more than 40 exhibits and at least 12 witnesses. He argued that the access restrictions amounted to an unconstitutional courtroom closure and that Roach made critical decisions outside the formal court record.

Wirske countered that Anthony’s trial lawyers consented to the security and courtroom-access decisions now challenged by the new defense team. He said the parties relied on paper filings and off-the-record discussions because of threats, doxxing and efforts to disrupt the high-profile case.

karmelo anthony leave jail after being freed on bond

Accused killer Karmelo Anthony walks out of jail after posting bond. (KDFW)

Mike Howard, Anthony’s former lead attorney, testified that the lawyers and Judge John Roach held more than a dozen off-the-record meetings before trial. Howard said Anthony was not present for those discussions and that no pretrial motions were formally filed because the parties used what he described as an “old-school” system of filing materials directly with Roach.

Howard said the defense discussed waiving some public-trial access because of security concerns, but that no Sixth Amendment waiver was made on the record. He testified that the decision not to use an overflow room was tied to technology concerns, not a specific security threat.

Howard testified that the defense understood its oral agreement with the state to allow Anthony to testify, provided the testimony stayed focused on the confrontation under the tent.

But Howard said that changed on the final day of trial, when prosecutors told the defense that the agreement did not cover a testifying Anthony and argued that the defense had already opened the door to character evidence. Howard testified that the dispute led to a heated break in the proceedings and forced the defense to reconsider whether Anthony should take the stand.

Howard said Roach told the lawyers he did not see a legal way to enforce their agreement. The former defense attorney testified that the uncertainty over what prosecutors could raise on cross-examination affected Anthony’s decision not to testify.

Chitty’s timeline is unusually short. Anthony was sentenced June 9, and Texas rules require a judge to rule on a motion for a new trial within 75 days of sentencing. That deadline falls Monday.

“If the judge does not grant the motion by Monday, then by operation of law, the motion will be denied,” Ordiway said.

If Chitty grants the motion, Anthony’s existing conviction and sentence would be set aside. Ordiway said the case would effectively return to the point before Anthony was convicted and sentenced, allowing Anthony to pursue another jury trial or negotiate a plea agreement.

If the motion is denied, Anthony’s legal fight will continue on direct appeal, a process that differs sharply from the fast-moving new-trial request.

A direct appeal is decided by a three-judge panel of the Texas Fifth Court of Appeals in Dallas and can take a year or longer, Ordiway said. Appeals generally focus on legal errors raised and decided in the trial court, while a motion for a new trial gives the trial court an opportunity to correct alleged errors soon after a conviction.

Anthony filed both the recusal motion and his request for a new trial on July 7. Roach referred the recusal request for assignment to another judge under Texas procedure.

News Outlet has reached out to Anthony’s defense team for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Spain's Canary Islands flooded by thousands of migrants as country declares emergency

Canary Islands Declare Emergency as Thousands of Migrants Arrive

Thousands of migrants arrived in Spain’s Canary Islands over the weekend as…
River cruiser seen after tanker collision in New Orleans

New Orleans Cruise Ship Disaster: Tanker’s Troubled Past, Final Minutes

A minute-by-minute account of Friday’s devastating New Orleans collision shows that the…
Vile dad killed baby son who wouldn't stop him crying while he played video games

Father killed baby son for crying while playing video games

A Hawaii father is accused of fatally injuring his 3-month-old son after…
Sen. Bill Cassidy slams RFK Jr. for

Sen. Bill Cassidy Slams RFK Jr. in New Criticism

Washington — Louisiana Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy on Sunday sharply criticized Health…
TikToker arrested after big cat mauls teen to death during video shoot at private farm

TikToker Arrested as Big Cat Kills Teen in Private Farm Video Shoot

A TikToker and a private farm owner have been arrested after a…
Climber trapped on Yosemite's El Capitan for nine days when massive storm hit California

Climber Trapped 9 Days on Yosemite’s El Capitan as Storm Hits

Champion climber Sasha DiGiulian was nearing the end of an ambitious attempt…
Dem Congressman's Claim About Elon Musk, DOGE, and the FAA Stoppage Needed a Serious Fact Check

Fact-Checking a Democratic Congressman’s Elon Musk, DOGE FAA Claim

The FAA imposed a nationwide ground stop on flights Friday. Yet during…
Charlamagne tha God blasts Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez for ‘beating around the bush,’ presses progressives on backing Hakeem Jeffries

Charlamagne tha God Blasts AOC Over Hakeem Jeffries Support

Radio personality Charlamagne tha God criticized Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., on Friday,…
UC Riverside theft: 'Homeless' man with ties to university charged over $800K tech heist

UC Riverside-Linked Man Charged in $800K Technology Theft Case

A man who said he was homeless has been arrested and charged…
Wes Moore accused of fabricating friendship with slain soldier

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore Accused of Fabricating Friendship With Slain Soldier

Maryland Democratic Gov. Wes Moore included an inaccurate account of a fellow…
Young paraglider dies after reported emergency sends him crashing into field during Illinois flight

Young Paraglider Dies After Reported Emergency Crash in Illinois Field

An Illinois paraglider died in a weekend crash after reportedly suffering an…
Iranian Boxer on Death Row Wins Human Rights Award — ‘I Will Not Bow Before Oppression’

Iranian Boxer on Death Row Receives Human Rights Award, Vows Not to Bow to Oppression

Iranian boxing champion Mohammad Javad Vafaei-Sani, who faces execution for opposing the…