New court filing argues NCAA fix to roster-limit rule does not go far enough

Recent court filing claims NCAA's update to roster-limit rule is insufficient

The new court filing argues the solution proposed by the NCAA and plaintiffs “fails in numerous respects” to protect walk-on and other athletes.

In a recent court filing concerning the multibillion-dollar college sports lawsuit, it is argued that the suggested solution for the roster-limit rule doesn’t adequately safeguard walk-on and other athletes who lost their positions when schools began reducing players ahead of the settlement’s potential approval.

Lawyers for Michigan walk-on football player John Weidenbach and Yale rower Grace Menke submitted a brief last week addressing the proposal that athletes losing their spots due to the roster-limit rule should not be counted against the cap once it is implemented next school year.

It is the constraints of the roster caps that have stalled U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken from approving the $2.78 billion settlement. This settlement is intended to permit schools to start paying players directly later this year.

Wilken suggested any athlete already on a roster be “grandfathered in” for the rest of their college career, so as not to count against the new roster limits. The limits, while expanding scholarship opportunities across all sports, are expected to cost thousands of athletes — most of them walk-ons or on partial scholarships — their spots on rosters.

Wilken is accepting objectors’ filings through Tuesday, then giving the NCAA and plaintiffs through Friday to rebut those arguments.

The court filing on behalf of Menke and Weidenbach argues the solution proposed by the NCAA and plaintiffs “fails in numerous respects” to protect those athletes.

Among its arguments is that the proposed remedy makes restoring players to roster spots completely optional for the schools that cut the players. It also says the directive for schools to make a list of players it cut because of roster limits — the list would then be used to determine which players should not count against the new caps — leaves room for the teams to make up other reasons for cutting the players.

“It provides student-athletes with no opportunity to challenge those decisions or prove that roster caps, rather than something else, caused them to be cut,” the filing said.

The NCAA and plaintiffs argue that since none of these roster spots was ever guaranteed, a provision allowing players back on their old teams to compete for their spot leaves them in no worse a situation than before they got cut.

But the filing argues the damage has already been done by schools that cut players with the expectation that Wilken would approve the settlement — an assumption the judge said was incorrect.

“Counsel continues to hear from many athletes and their families whose lives are being turned upside down as a result of the implementation of roster caps,” the filing said. “Defendants’ indifference, when simple fixes were offered to address a problem of their making, is stunning.”

Among the objectors’ proposed fixes was for schools to automatically restore players to their old roster spots, while giving them “discretion to cut athletes for legitimate reasons unrelated to the roster cap, such as conduct violations and poor athletic or academic performance.”

Under the latest proposal, the players would be able to either go back to their old schools or find a new one, but either way, they would not count against that school’s roster limit.

Copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.     

You May Also Like

Mother charged with murder for refusing to give toddler son cancer care

Mother Charged With Murder After Refusing Cancer Treatment for Toddler Son

The mother of a 3-year-old boy who died weighing just 24 pounds…
Heartbroken family of UGA football commit who died suddenly at 18 reveal teen’s final moments

Heartbroken Family of UGA Football Commit Who Died at 18 Reveal His Final Moments

The family of a promising Georgia football player who died suddenly last…
New UFO files show Pentagon contractor planned underground vault for

New UFO Files Reveal Pentagon Contractor’s Underground Vault Plan

Washington — The Pentagon has published another collection of UFO records, including…
$3.3M Encino home targeted by burglars in home invasion

Burglars Target $3.3M Encino Home in Brazen Home Invasion

Two burglars broke into a $3.3 million home in Encino on Friday…
Aerial footage shows damage to key bridge in Crimea, Ukraine

European Intel: Ukraine Deals Blow to Putin’s Crimea Lifeline

Putin reportedly ‘very frustrated’ as Ukrainian strikes damage vital Kerch Bridge Fox…
VIDEO: Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

The Big Ten handed down suspensions to nine hockey players Saturday after…
Denmark accuses Russia of plotting to kill Ukrainian American rapper on Danish soil

Denmark Says Russia Plotted to Kill Ukrainian-American Rapper

Denmark’s security and intelligence agency, PET, has accused Russia of trying to…
Trump says Sen. John Cornyn is doing a ‘tremendous disservice’ by blocking Texas judicial pick

Trump Blasts Sen. John Cornyn Over Blocked Texas Judicial Pick

President Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America” that outgoing Texas Sen.…
Florida man sentenced to death for 'cold, calculated' murder of attorney whose body was never found

Florida Man Gets Death for Attorney Murder, Body Never Found

A former Florida plastic surgeon who represented himself in court was sentenced…
Swift assurances from officials after wave of nationwide outages raises questions, expert says

Officials’ Swift Assurances After Nationwide Outages Raise Questions, Expert Says

A series of high-profile disruptions affecting critical parts of American life unfolded…
Zelenskyy says Russia strikes hometown, criticizes Putin-Trump meeting

Zelenskyy Says Russia Struck His Hometown, Criticizes Putin-Trump Meeting

Democratic leaders condemn Trump after Putin-Xi summit in China Steve Yates defended…
Ex-White House press secretary Katie Zacharia criticizes GOP over midterm losses, says party isn’t ‘good at winning’

Ex-White House Press Secretary Katie Zacharia Says GOP Can’t Win

Former White House press secretary Katie Zacharia delivered a candid critique of…