Illustration of a man cutting fish on a cutting board labeled "PM's Flagship Welfare Reforms".

LIKE a fishmonger with a fresh kipper, the Prime Minister laid his key welfare proposal on the table, reached for a sharp knife, and sliced through its core.

He then took this stripped-down piece and offered it to the eagerly awaiting Labour MPs, who were in charge, even though the pared-down Bill managed to pass the crucial Commons vote last night.

Illustration of a man cutting fish on a cutting board labeled "PM's Flagship Welfare Reforms".
Like a fishmonger, Starmer slapped his flagship welfare package on the table, reached for a sharp knife and filleted its guts
Sir Keir Starmer leaving 10 Downing Street.
The shambles that played out in recent weeks has laid bare a deeper dysfunction within the PM’s premiershipCredit: Getty

The slow-motion car crash over Labour’s flagship benefit reforms has been nothing short of a disaster.

It’s troubling that the PM might now shy away from addressing this vital issue again—one critical to the future of British politics—out of fear of a revolt among his supporters.

But the whole sorry saga has also laid bare a deeper dysfunction within Starmer’s premiership that threatens to drive his administration into the deep freeze.

The omnishambles that has played out in recent weeks is worth recapping.

After the Government’s original plans to squeeze benefits were leaked earlier this year, ministers then watered down their ambitions to a paltry £5billion in savings.

Humiliated and bruised

Despite this barely scratching the surface of the ballooning handouts bill, the language from Downing Street was that getting people off benefits was a “moral” mission.

But it was a mission that did not survive an ambush by 120 Labour MPs, who pledged to back a wrecking amendment sinking Starmer’s reforms.

What followed from No10 was a mix of persuasion, scare tactics, angry phone calls and arm-twisting before the inevitable: Keir caved.

By bending to the revolt, the PM not only slashed the projected savings, but appeared as robust as a Mr Whippy ice cream in the current heatwave.

His claim to have been distracted by global events also did little to win favour with a public who rightly expect their leaders to multi-task.

Keir Starmer ‘to BACK DOWN’ on benefits cuts as he faces major revolt from MPs

Humiliated and bruised, at least Downing Street had appeased disgruntled MPs to the point they would hold their noses and let the Bill pass.

Or so ministers thought. Naive Welfare Secretary Liz Kendall’s statement on Monday detailing the weakened package only made things worse.

By hastily redrawing the plans in the face of rebellion, she had, those same rebels bleated, now created a “three-tier system” for benefit claimants while still pushing 150,000 into poverty.

Still high from their initial victory, some blood-scenting MPs refused to fall into line and instead had a crack at extracting further concessions to buy their support.

After a succession of U-turns in the last few weeks, there is a growing sense that Starmer is not in control

Cue another disaster from Kendall, who yesterday paraded the remaining scraps of the Government’s welfare package ahead of the vote.

But it only took another public pasting from her own MPs — and the Government blinked again. In the hours before the vote, the Bill was being watered down even further.

It was left to Kendall’s deputy, Stephen Timms, to deliver the coup de grace from the dispatch box — the central plans to tighten the criteria for disability handouts would be dumped entirely.

The Bill now mutilated beyond recognition, is it any surprise MPs were last night urging ministers to put it out of its misery altogether?

One cabinet minister told me last night: “It hasn’t been our finest hour”.

Liz Kendall, UK Work and Pensions Secretary, speaking in Parliament.
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall paraded the remaining scraps of the Government’s welfare package ahead of the voteCredit: Unpixs
Liz Kendall, Work and Pensions Secretary, speaks in Parliament.
Rebel ringleader Rachael Maskell vowed to press ahead with her bid to block the Bill altogetherCredit: Unpixs
Keir Starmer speaking at a podium.
One year in office, and Sir Keir has had the worst anniversary present possible — a duffing-up by many in his own party, and an unceremonious humiliationCredit: Reuters

You can say that again. How has Starmer found himself in such an invidious position just a year into his premiership?

MPs are grumbling about his all-powerful Downing Street Chief of Staff, Morgan McSweeney, for being too combative and sidelining the parliamentary party.

Suggestions the No10 svengali, credited with banishing the Loony Left and turning Labour into an election-winning machine, would be sent packing were yesterday shut down by Starmer himself.

While admitting “frustrations” with the handling of recent days, an ally told me last night that “we simply wouldn’t be here without Morgan” — a sentiment still shared by many.

Backbenchers grumble that the famously unclubbable PM has failed to press the flesh with them in the tea rooms and bars of Westminster.

After a succession of U-turns in the last few weeks, there is a growing sense that Starmer is not in control.

At Cabinet yesterday morning, he tried to gee up his top team by rattling off their list of achievements one year into the job.

Reasons to be cheerful were: “A cut in NHS waiting lists, investment in transport, major infrastructure decisions, funding for social and affordable housing, extending free school meals and introducing free breakfast clubs.”

In other words, they’ve been very good at spending money — which is now drying up.

The retreat on welfare savings means Chancellor Rachel Reeves will have even less wriggle room in her Autumn Budget.

More tax rises

Worshipping at the altar of the Office for Budget Responsibility means that, despite presiding over an economy worth £3trillion, the extra cost of welfare and winter fuel U-turns has left her scrambling to find another £5billion or so.

Ministers last night could not even say how much their newly enfeebled package would save.

But if aides around Starmer think Things Can Only Get Better, they will face a whole new world of political pain should they come back for more tax rises.

Already, speculation is swirling that the Chancellor is eyeing a hike in fuel duty, which would unforgivably betray millions of drivers at a time of volatile oil markets.

He now needs to get an urgent grip, or it won’t be the last time he gets done up like a kipper

She is also considering going back on a promise made just months ago to end the freeze on income tax thresholds.

Asked yesterday if she was still committed to scrapping these stealth taxes, she ducked and weaved.

One year in office, and Sir Keir has had the worst anniversary present possible — a duffing-up by many in his own party, and an unceremonious humiliation.

He now needs to get an urgent grip, or it won’t be the last time he gets done up like a kipper.

Last night dozens of Labour MPs, including half the Cabinet, piled on to the Commons terrace to let off steam.

“It’s been a week, and it’s only Tuesday,” said one weary MP.

GOV.UK benefits website showing information about tax credits, eligibility, and appeals.
The latest concession follows a partial U-turn last week in the face of a possible defeat over the BillCredit: Alamy

The 49 Labour rebels

As many as 49 Labour MPs voted against their own government in the welfare bill.

But this was not enough to defeat the bill as it was backed by 335 votes to 260, a government majority of 75.

Here is a full list of the 49 Labour rebels:

Diane Abbott

Rosena Allin-Khan

Paula Barker

Lee Barron

Lorraine Beavers

Olivia Blake

Richard Burgon

Ian Byrne

Irene Campbell

Lizzi Collinge

Stella Creasy

Marsha De Cordova

Peter Dowd

Neil Duncan-Jordan

Cat Eccles

Clive Efford

Mary Kelly Foy

Tracy Gilbert

Mary Glindon

Chris Hinchliff

Imran Hussain

Terry Jermy

Kim Johnson

Ian Lavery

Brian Leishman

Emma Lewell

Clive Lewis

Rebecca Long Bailey

Rachael Maskell

Andy McDonald

Navendu Mishra

Abtisam Mohamed

Grahame Morris

Margaret Mullane

Simon Opher

Kate Osamor

Kate Osborne

Richard Quigley

Bell Ribeiro-Addy

Marie Rimmer

Cat Smith

Euan Stainbank

Graham Stringer

Marie Tidball

Jon Trickett

Derek Twigg

Chris Webb

Nadia Whittome

Steve Witherden

19 Labour MPs did not vote, according to the House of Commons.

You May Also Like

SF Mayor Daniel Lurie issues dire weather warning to Thanksgiving travelers

San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie Issues Dire Weather Warning for Thanksgiving Travelers

San Francisco residents may not have seen the worst of extreme flooding…
One of Tessa Majors' killers sprung from upstate prison just 6 years after sentencing

One of Tessa Majors’ killers freed from upstate prison after 6 years

One of the teenagers convicted in the 2019 killing of Barnard College…
Mississippi mother, caregiver face charges after refusing to give cancer treatment to toddler

Mississippi Mother, Caregiver Charged Over Toddler’s Cancer Care

A Mississippi mother is facing multiple felony charges, including murder, after authorities…
Donald Trump to deliver keynote address at Reagan Library defense forum in California

Donald Trump to Keynote Reagan Library Defense Forum in California

President Donald Trump is set to bring his America First message back…
DSA fails to open Staten Island outpost

Democratic Socialists of America Fails to Open Staten Island Chapter Office

An effort by Staten Island activists to establish an independent Democratic Socialists…
Graffiti returns to Yolo County’s Stevenson Bridge after $8.3M fix

Graffiti Returns to Yolo County’s Stevenson Bridge After $8.3M Repairs

California taxpayers have spent $8.3 million restoring a graffiti-covered landmark, but the…
ASRA Q. NOMANI: Communist, hard-left groups mount global youth strike to bring 'socialist revolution'

Asra Q. Nomani: Hard-Left Youth Strike Seeks Socialist Revolution

Red hammer-and-sickle flags appeared at demonstrations across Europe on Friday, yet many…
VIDEO: Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

Big Ten Suspends Nine Players After Michigan-Michigan State Hockey Brawl

The Big Ten handed down suspensions to nine hockey players Saturday after…
Princeton student detained by ICE news: Neuroscience Ph.D. student Eva Yi Xie detained at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport after attending Society for Neuroscience conference

Princeton Neuroscience Ph.D. Student Eva Yi Xie Detained by ICE

PRINCETON, N.J. — A Princeton University doctoral student was taken into federal…
Florida man accused of pouring toxic oil into cup of Waffle House sweet tea that a child accidentally drank

Florida Man Accused After Child Drinks Oil-Tainted Waffle House Tea

A Florida man allegedly poured roughly half a bottle of highly toxic…
135 homeless squatters refuse to leave radioactive California Superfund site

135 Homeless Squatters Defy Eviction at California Superfund Site

Dozens of unhoused people have made their homes at a radioactive waste…
Florida man sentenced to death for 'cold, calculated' murder of attorney whose body was never found

Florida Man Gets Death for Attorney Murder, Body Never Found

A former Florida plastic surgeon who represented himself in court was sentenced…