Stephen A. Smith questions why activists are still defending Karmelo Anthony after guilty verdict

Stephen A. Smith is not backing away from his position on the Karmelo Anthony verdict.

The sports commentator and host of the “Straight Shooter” podcast has again used his platform to directly address those continuing to support Anthony.

During his latest episode, Smith asked why some people are still disputing the jury’s decision.

split image shows Smith on left, and Anthony on right

Stephen A. Smith recently addressed the Karmelo Anthony case publicly, saying, “Karmelo Anthony murdered Austin Metcalf.” Anthony was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 35 years in prison. (Dave Kotinsky / Texas Department of Criminal Justice)

“When we sit up here and we think about the battles that need to be fought, we gotta be mindful of what’s worth fighting for and what’s not worth fighting for,” Smith said.

Anthony was convicted earlier this month and received a 35-year prison sentence. He was found responsible for fatally stabbing 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a high school track meet in Texas last year.

photo shows Jeff Metcalf on left with Austin Metcalf on right

Jeff Metcalf, the father of Austin Metcalf, who was stabbed and killed by Karmelo Anthony, spoke with News Agency. (Matthew Symons for News Agency / Jeff Metcalf)

In the podcast episode titled “We’re Fighting the Wrong Battle!”, Smith maintained his stance on the verdict.

📩 Want me to investigate? kelsie.cairns@fox.com

🎥 Facebook: Kelsie Cairns

“He killed someone and his argument of self-defense in the jury’s eyes didn’t hold weight,” he said.

A folding pocketknife with dark blade and gray handle lying on a surface.

Authorities photographed a folding pocketknife with a dark blade and gray handle used in the murder of Austin Metcalf in Texas. (Collin County Courts)

News Agency previously reported the commentator said, “Karmelo Anthony murdered Austin Metcalf. There is no other way to slice it,” in another podcast episode.

While Smith is calling on “viewers to think critically,” activist and founder of the Next Generation Action Network Minister Dominique Alexander started a movement titled “Stand with the Anthony Family.”

In a recent social media post advertising the initiative, Alexander said in part, “It is important that people have access to accurate information, meaningful opportunities to participate, and a way to stay connected to the movement. We cannot allow misinformation, division, or confusion to define this moment.”

Karmelo Anthony handcuffed inside a police vehicle with blood on his left-hand finger.

Karmelo Anthony is photographed handcuffed inside a police vehicle with blood visible on his left-hand finger. (Collin County Courts)

Smith referred to the recent violent spike in deadly shootings that happened over the weekend in Chicago as an example of battles not being fought.

“We can try to fight and fight and fight over that. But you know what? If you’re gonna fight as vigilantly, as diligently over that, how come we not fighting about what’s happening in Chicago? Why we ain’t fighting about that?”

A representative for Smith could not be immediately reached by News Agency.

News Agency has reached out to Alexander, who has been acting as a spokesperson for the Anthony family, but did not immediately hear back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Brea police issue warning after spying device found in neighborhood bushes

Brea Police Warn Residents After Hidden Spying Device Found in Neighborhood Bushes

A hidden surveillance camera found tucked inside neighborhood bushes has raised concerns…
Fiancée sticks by accused serial rapist as special agents defend tailing him for restaurant DNA stakeout

Fiancée Stands by Accused Serial Rapist While Agents Defend Restaurant DNA Stakeout

Matthew Nilo, a New Jersey attorney accused of raping or sexually assaulting…
The $152 crypto mistake by Nancy Guthrie detectives

Detectives Trace Nancy Guthrie’s $152 Crypto Mistake

Investigators searching for those responsible for Nancy Guthrie’s alleged kidnapping have had…
Rock legend Billy Idol and guitarist Steve Stevens are inducted to the Hollywood's Rockwalk

Billy Idol and Steve Stevens Inducted into Hollywood’s RockWalk

HOLLYWOOD — Billy Idol is having a milestone year. The rock icon…
Chicago teen takeovers: Local youth to weigh-in on how to prevent mass gatherings, enforce curfews, amid violent summer 2026

Chicago Youth to Help Shape Curfew Enforcement Plans as City Tackles Teen Takeovers in Violent Summer 2026

CHICAGO (WLS) — Young people from across the city are set to…
Teen killed in Central Park horse carriage crash was all smiles moments before death: video

Video Shows Teen Smiling Moments Before Fatal Central Park Horse Carriage Crash

An 18-year-old who died after being thrown from a horse-drawn carriage in…
Ex-LAFD Chief Kristin Crowley sues Mayor Karen Bass for defamation

Former LAFD Chief Kristin Crowley Files Defamation Suit Against LA Mayor Karen Bass

Former Los Angeles Fire Department Chief Kristin Crowley is accusing Mayor Karen…
FBI adds 2 fugitives to 'Most Wanted Fraudsters' list amid historic $6.5B healthcare takedown: Patel

FBI Adds Two Fugitives to Most Wanted Fraudsters List in $6.5B Health Care Fraud Crackdown

FBI Director Kash Patel said Tuesday that the bureau is placing two…
Trump says he'll resurface the bottom of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, turning it blue

Trump Plans to Resurface Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool Bottom in Blue

President Trump’s latest renovation push has extended to one of Washington’s most…
South Carolina fitness trainer’s autopsy raises more questions about mysterious death

South Carolina Fitness Trainer’s Cryptic Instagram Posts Surface After Her Body Is Found

A South Carolina fitness trainer who was missing for nearly a week…
Senate adopts House-passed Iran resolution in symbolic rebuke of Trump

Senate Passes House-Approved Iran Resolution in Symbolic Rebuke of Trump

Washington — The Senate on Tuesday passed a resolution previously approved by the…
Suspected California library gunman influenced by Columbine shooting and wore matching shirt, officials say

California Library Shooting Suspect Influenced by Columbine, Wore Matching Shirt, Officials Say

Todd Blanche slams Illinois governor for refusing federal help in Chicago Acting…