Supreme Court tells lower courts to take new look at 2 major voting rights cases

Washington — On Monday, the Supreme Court directed lower courts to revisit two significant cases that examine whether private individuals and groups have the authority to sue under a crucial part of the Voting Rights Act aimed at preventing discriminatory voting practices.

In brief orders, the Supreme Court nullified previous lower court rulings and remanded the cases for further evaluation, taking into account its recent significant decision that weakened Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson expressed her dissent.

The core issue in these legal disputes is determining who has the standing to file federal lawsuits addressing possible breaches of Section 2. These cases represent a fresh challenge to the 1965 law and could significantly limit who is eligible to enforce it. If future rulings uphold these constraints, it could diminish the landmark voting law’s effectiveness, which has long been hailed as a cornerstone of the civil rights movement, and restrict voting rights groups and individual voters from pursuing legal action against purported violations.

The ongoing legal battle concerning Section 2 reached the Supreme Court through two separate cases contesting legislative maps drawn in Mississippi and North Dakota following the 2020 census, alleging they violated Section 2.

The case from Mississippi was initiated by the state’s NAACP chapter alongside 14 voters, while the North Dakota case involved the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians, the Spirit Lake Tribe, and three Native American voters. Both groups had favorable outcomes at the district court level.

North Dakota officials contested the district court’s decision, leading to an appeal in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit. The Appeals Court concluded that Section 2 cannot be enforced by private plaintiffs through a different civil rights statute, known as Section 1983, which allows individuals to sue government officials in federal court for alleged rights violations.

In siding with North Dakota officials, the three-judge panel from the 8th Circuit applied an earlier ruling in which it held that when Congress crafted the Voting Rights Act, it only intended for the attorney general, not private parties, to enforce Section 2. The 8th Circuit’s decision covered only the states within its region: Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota and South Dakota.

But lawyers for the Native American tribes argued that its ruling departs from more than 40 years of unbroken practice of individuals suing in courts throughout the country to vindicate their rights under Section 2.

A review of cases brought under Section 2 by Ellen Katz, a professor at the University of Michigan Law School, found that since 1982, private plaintiffs have been party to 96.4% of Section 2 claims that led to published decisions and the only litigants in 86.7% of those opinions. 

Additionally, from 1982 to early 2024, private plaintiffs brought more than 400 cases alleging violations of Section 2 that have led to judicial decisions, while the Department of Justice brought more than 40, government lawyers under former President Joe Biden’s administration said in 2024.

“Everywhere else in the nation, private plaintiffs can rely on an unbroken line of Supreme Court and circuit precedent to enforce the individual rights given to them by Congress in the Voting Rights Act. But not in the Eighth Circuit,” lawyers for the tribes wrote in a Supreme Court filing.

The appeals court, they said, “extinguished the remaining pathway for private enforcement of Section 2 of the VRA within its bounds.”

Meanwhile, the Mississippi case was decided by a three-judge panel, allowing state officials to directly appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court. 

Echoing the 8th Circuit’s decision, Mississippi officials argued that Congress provided a mechanism enforcing Section 2: lawsuits filed by the attorney general.

“Although Congress had ambitious aims for the Voting Rights Act, its ambitions did not extend to buoying private litigation,” they wrote in a filing. “Congress had seen that private litigation had failed to vindicate voting rights. It steered a new course in the VRA — embracing powerful remedies, but not private enforcement.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Markwayne Mullin took his government plane to LSU-Texas game as thousands were stranded in FAA ground stoppage

Sen. Mullin Took Government Plane to LSU-Texas Game Amid FAA Halt

WASHINGTON — While thousands of travelers remained stranded at airports nationwide Saturday,…
Chase Bank outages today: Chicago-area JPMorgan Chase customers impacted by online banking issues, 'software bug'

Chase Outage Hits Chicago as Software Bug Disrupts Online Banking

CHICAGO () — JPMorgan Chase said banking transactions have returned to normal…
New California tax plan targets wealthy after Prop 40 defeat

New California Tax Plan Targets Wealthy After Proposition 40 Defeat

California voters have rejected a billionaire tax, but the debate over how…
Slain woman, 24, discovered on wooded Louisiana walking trail, as her missing dog is found

Slain Louisiana Woman, 24, Found on Wooded Trail; Missing Dog Located

The body of a 24-year-old woman was found “lying in the leaves”…
US intel picks up ‘very specific’ Iranian dirty bomb plot targeting Washington: report 

Report: US Intel Detects ‘Specific’ Iran Dirty Bomb Plot Targeting DC

US intelligence officials have reportedly uncovered an alleged Iranian plan to detonate…
DJ's $100K 'impossible to duplicate' record collection destroyed in Brooklyn building collapse

Brooklyn DJ’s $100K ‘Impossible to Duplicate’ Record Collection Destroyed in Building Collapse

A DJ who lost a vast vinyl collection in the deadly collapse…
Millions of Americans face flash flood threats as rain set to pound parts of Atlantic coast

Millions Face Flash Flood Threat as Heavy Rain Targets Atlantic Coast

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — Millions of residents along Florida’s Atlantic Coast are facing…
Ecuador's president denies US operates military base despite reports of troop buildup

Ecuador’s President Denies US Base Amid Troop Buildup Reports

Trump steps up campaign against drug cartels in Ecuador Dana Perino examines…
Drilling incident sparks explosion at Chiquita Canyon Landfill

Explosion at Chiquita Canyon Landfill Triggered by Drilling Incident

A sudden explosion at a California landfill sent a dense plume of…
Mullin: 'Kind of Makes Sense' That Systems Are Going Down Due to Inability to Handle AI/SI Speed

Sen. Markwayne Mullin Says System Failures Make Sense as AI Outpaces Infrastructure

During Monday’s edition of Fox News Channel’s “Hannity,” Department of Homeland Security…
Robert Pattinson is the next James Bond, taking over the spy role from Daniel Craig

Robert Pattinson Rumored as Next James Bond After Daniel Craig

Robert Pattinson is officially stepping into the role of James Bond. Following…
Fight reportedly breaks out between passengers aboard Chicago-bound flight, FBI responds

Fight Reportedly Breaks Out on Chicago-Bound Flight, FBI Responds

Authorities reportedly responded at Chicago O’Hare International Airport after a physical confrontation…