Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday will weigh the circumstances under which the government can be found to cross the line from persuasion to coercion, hearing arguments in cases involving two contentious issues: problematic social media posts and gun rights.

The court will first hear arguments over concerns that the Biden administration’s contacts with social media companies, including efforts to have content removed on issues like Covid-19, constituted unlawful coercion.

The justices will then hear a similar case on claims that a New York state official inappropriately pressured companies to end ties with the National Rifle Association, a leading gun rights group.

At issue is a practice known as “jawboning,” in which the government leans on private parties to do what it wants, sometimes with the implicit threat of adverse consequences if demands are not met. Those challenging the government actions say that in each case there was a violation of the Constitution’s First Amendment, which protects free speech rights.

“Both cases are about the extent to which the government should be allowed to interject itself into public debate,” said Alex Abdo, a lawyer at the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University. While the government has a right to participate, it should not have “too much of a hand in distorting our conversations,” he added.

Abdo’s group filed a brief in the social media case supporting neither side but asking for clarity on the issue.

In the social media case, Republican attorneys general in Louisiana and Missouri, along with five social media users, filed the underlying lawsuit, alleging that U.S. government officials went too far in putting pressure on platforms to moderate content. The individual plaintiffs include Covid-19 lockdown opponents and Jim Hoft, the owner of the right-wing website Gateway Pundit.

The lawsuit makes various claims relating to activities that occurred in 2020 and before, including efforts to deter the spread of false information about Covid-19 and the presidential election. Donald Trump was president at the time, but the district court ruling focused on actions taken by the government after President Joe Biden took office in January 2021.

Louisiana-based Judge Terry Doughty in July of last year barred officials from “communication of any kind with social-media companies urging, encouraging, pressuring, or inducing in any manner the removal, deletion, suppression, or reduction of content containing protected free speech.”

The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals narrowed the scope of Doughty’s injunction. But the appeals court still required the White House, the FBI and top health officials not to “coerce or significantly encourage” social media companies to remove content the Biden administration considers misinformation.

When agreeing to hear the case, the Supreme Court in October blocked the appeals court ruling, with three conservative justices noting they disagreed with that decision: Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch.

NRA’s claims against New York

In the NRA case, the group claims that its free speech rights were violated by the actions of Maria Vullo, then the superintendent of the New York state Department of Financial Services.

Vullo’s office had been investigating insurance companies that the NRA had worked with to provide coverage for members. The NRA alleged that Vullo, in meetings with insurance companies, made “back channel threats that they cease providing services to the NRA.”

Speaking out after the 2018 school shooting in Parkland, Florida, in which 17 people were killed, Vullo also urged insurance companies and banks to reconsider any relationships they had with gun rights-affiliated groups.

The NRA is appealing a 2022 ruling by the New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which said Vullo’s actions did not constitute unlawful conduct.

Vullo argued in her defense that it was part of her job to warn companies about the “reputational risk” of doing business with the NRA.

The case attracted additional attention after the American Civil Liberties Union, which often backs liberal causes, signed on to represent the NRA. The ACLU said that while it disagrees with the NRA’s positions, it would defend the gun rights group’s right to speak.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Idaho police release investigation photos of Kohberger's car and crime scene where four students died

Idaho Police Unveil Investigation Images of Kohberger’s Vehicle and Scene of Student Deaths

Idaho State Police have released hundreds of photos from their investigation into…
Man sentenced to 25 years for deadly motorcycle crash on Beach Blvd.

Individual Receives 25-Year Sentence for Fatal Motorcycle Accident on Beach Boulevard.

Diego Hernandez Martinez, 45, was sentenced Friday for causing the Oct. 3,…
Trump ran on a promise of revenge. He's making good on it

Trump Followed Through on His Promise of Retribution

Donald Trump campaigned with a vow to utilize governmental authority to exact…
FBI agents searching John Bolton's home.

FBI Conducts Early Morning Raid at John Bolton’s Residence in Major Investigation Over Classified Documents

SHOCKING footage has captured federal agents storming the home of former National…
Portrait of Letícia Paul.

A young law graduate, aged 22, passes away following a serious allergic reaction during a CT scan; her family honors her as a ‘lively young woman’

A YOUNG law graduate has tragically died after suffering a severe allergic…
Max Fried snaps out of funk to look like ace Yankees need

Max Fried Recovers Strongly, Showing the Yankees What an Ace Looks Like

This was the Max Fried of April, May and June. The ace…
View of Eisenhuttenstadt, Germany, with a church and river.

German City Entices New Residents with Free Apartments, Social Events, and Hiking Adventures Amidst Fierce Competition

A GERMAN city is offering free flats, pub socials and hiking trips…
NATO scrambles warplanes as Russia hits near Romanian border in Ukraine

NATO Deploys Warplanes in Response to Russian Strikes Close to Romanian Border in Ukraine

Two German warplanes were scrambled overnight from Romania after Russia launched a…
Vladimir Putin at a scientific exhibition.

Inside Ukraine’s ‘fortress belt’ that Putin wants for peace – and why Russia might lose 2 million troops trying to conquer it

Lines of dragons’ teeth bollards are established in Ukraine to protect against…
Firehouse Block Party for Peace promotes nonviolence in Lawndale, Chicago

Firehouse Block Party for Peace advocates for nonviolence in Lawndale, Chicago

CHICAGO (WLS) — A hip-hop party in Chicago’s Lawndale neighborhood aims to…
Trump disapproval rating spikes to 56%, survey shows

Trump’s Disapproval Rating Climbs to 56%, Poll Reveals

(The Hill) — After seven months into his second White House term,…
NATO secretary general touts Trump talks with Zelenskyy, EU leaders:

A Russian drone crash lands in Poland; Warsaw objects to airspace breach and intends to file an official complaint

A Russian drone is suspected of having crashed in a field in…