Supreme Court sides with Black death row inmate who alleged racial discrimination in jury selection

Washington — The Supreme Court delivered a pivotal decision on Thursday, siding with a Black death row inmate from Mississippi who claimed racial bias influenced the jury selection process during his trial.

In a closely split decision of 5-4, the court ruled in favor of Terry Pitchford. Notably, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh joined the court’s liberal justices in the majority. Justice Kavanaugh penned the majority opinion in the case, identified as Pitchford v. Cain.

Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, and Amy Coney Barrett expressed their dissent.

The case originated from a 2004 incident in Grenada, Mississippi, where two Black teenagers, Pitchford and Eric Bullins, were involved in a robbery at a grocery store. The store owner, a White man named Reuben Britt, was shot and killed in the attack. Bullins, who fired the fatal shots, was 16 at the time and therefore ineligible for the death penalty, resulting in a 20-year prison sentence for him.

Pitchford, who was 18 during the crime, faced charges of capital murder, with the state pursuing the death penalty.

During the jury selection in the Mississippi state court, then-District Attorney Doug Evans exercised a peremptory strike to dismiss four out of five potential Black jurors. Pitchford’s defense challenged this action, invoking the Supreme Court’s 1986 decision in Batson v. Kentucky. This landmark ruling prohibits the exclusion of potential jurors based on race and outlines a specific framework for courts to evaluate whether such peremptory strikes are racially motivated.

Evans provided several reasons for excluding the four Black potential jurors in Pitchford’s case, arguing that one returned 15 minutes late to court from a lunch break, two others had brothers convicted of violent crimes and the fourth was similar to Pitchford in that he was young, unmarried and a father.

The trial judge accepted these reasons as race-neutral. But Pitchford’s lawyers argued they were not given the chance to rebut the prosecutors’ reasons as pretextual, as required under Batson’s three-step framework.

A jury composed of 11 White jurors and one Black juror ultimately convicted Pitchford of capital murder and sentenced him to death.

Evans also served as the top prosecutor in the high-profile case of Curtis Flowers, whose murder conviction was overturned by the Supreme Court in 2019. Evans was accused of consistently striking prospective Black jurors from the jury pool.

Pitchford first appealed his conviction and death sentence to the Mississippi Supreme Court, and then sought relief from the federal district court in Mississippi. That court ruled in favor of Pitchford and overturned his conviction.

“The trial court, seemingly eager to proceed to the case itself, quickly deemed the reasons as race-neutral and moved on,” the district court found.

That decision was reversed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit. But in its ruling, the Supreme Court sided with Pitchford, invalidating his conviction. He can be retried by the state.

“In this case, whether due to confusion, oversight, an overly hurried jury selection process, or some other cause, things broke down, and the ordinary trial-court procedure for resolving Batson claims at step three never occurred — notwithstanding the repeated efforts of Pitchford’s counsel to pursue and preserve the Batson objection,” Kavanaugh wrote.

In a dissenting opinion, Gorsuch argued that Pitchford failed to clear the high bar for securing relief under federal law.

The court’s opinion, he said, “errs on the law and the factual record alike.” Still, Gorsuch wrote that the Supreme Court’s decision is a narrow one, applying only to Pitchford.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Delon Raymond Jaundoo, an illegal migrant accused of attempted murder, released from Rikers Island despite ICE detainer: DHS

DHS: Delon Jaundoo Released From Rikers Despite ICE Detainer

A Guyanese national who is living illegally in the United States remains…
Vile dad killed baby son who wouldn't stop him crying while he played video games

Father killed baby son for crying while playing video games

A Hawaii father is accused of fatally injuring his 3-month-old son after…
State Department presses Egypt to respect religious freedom as Christian convert faces possible execution

US Presses Egypt as Christian Convert Faces Execution Over Faith

The U.S. State Department is stepping up pressure on Egypt to uphold…
United Airlines experiences ‘widespread system outage’ days after nationwide FAA ground stop

United Airlines Faces Widespread System Outage Days After FAA Stop

Nationwide FAA ground stop strands passengers on planes Fox News contributor Jonathan…
Pope Leo XIV hit in the face by flying rosary during farewell Mass in Peru, video shows

Video Shows Pope Leo XIV Hit by Flying Rosary at Peru Farewell Mass

Pope Leo XIV appeared to be hit near the eye by a…
Missing DoorDash driver’s wife slams rumors that she's 'in on' her husband's disappearance

Wife of Missing DoorDash Driver Denounces Claims She Was Involved in His Disappearance

The wife of missing DoorDash driver Zachariah “Zack” Schuck has reportedly pushed…
US intel picks up ‘very specific’ Iranian dirty bomb plot targeting Washington: report 

Report: US Intel Detects ‘Specific’ Iran Dirty Bomb Plot Targeting DC

US intelligence officials have reportedly uncovered an alleged Iranian plan to detonate…
Nvidia short-seller warned in May of CEO Jensen Huang's ties to suspected Chinese spy

Elon Musk Among Thousands Backing Jensen Huang Nvidia CEO Petition

Thousands of Nvidia employees and technology leaders, including Elon Musk, have signed…
Massive El Niño-powered wave in Morro Bay wipes out group on shore

Massive El Niño Wave Sweeps Group Off Shore at Morro Bay

Massive waves reaching up to 30 feet battered California’s Central Coast over…
Ro Khanna pitches $1,700 checks for Americans to offset Iran war costs: 'A chance to deliver'

Ro Khanna Proposes $1,700 Payments to Americans to Offset Iran War Costs

Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., on Monday proposed sending every American family a…
River cruiser seen after tanker collision in New Orleans

New Orleans Cruise Ship Disaster: Tanker’s Troubled Past, Final Minutes

A minute-by-minute account of Friday’s devastating New Orleans collision shows that the…
Lindsay Clancy prosecutors come across as 'tone deaf,' 'uncaring' and 'snarky,' defense attorney says

Massachusetts Mom Lindsay Clancy Faces New Murder Trial

A Massachusetts judge has scheduled March 29 for the start of Lindsay…