Susan Smith prosecutor fears her release would put her in grieving father’s face ‘every day’

The prosecutor who helped send Susan Smith to prison says he worries she would seek the spotlight on social media if granted parole, forcing the grieving father of her murdered sons to encounter reminders of the case “every day.”

Smith was convicted of murdering her two sons in 1995 and received a life sentence. Under South Carolina law at the time, however, she became eligible for parole after 30 years. On Thursday morning, a seven-member parole board in Columbia, South Carolina, is scheduled to decide whether she will be released.

Prosecutors said Smith fastened her two young boys into her car and allowed the vehicle to roll into a lake, killing them as part of an effort to rekindle a relationship with a former lover who did not want children. She was ultimately sentenced to life behind bars.

Susan Smith, wearing a navy outfit with her hands cuffed in front, walks down steps surrounded by officials.

Susan Smith is led from a building in handcuffs. She was convicted in 1995 of killing her two young sons, Michael and Alex. (Brooks Kraft LLC/Sygma via Getty Images)

Michael, 3, and 14-month-old Alexander died on Oct. 25, 1994. Smith initially told investigators that a Black man had carjacked her and driven away with the children. Her husband believed the account, and the couple later appeared on national television together, pleading for their sons’ safe return.

Tommy Pope, now the South Carolina House of Representatives’ speaker pro tempore, prosecuted Smith. He told News Outlet that if she is released, he believes she would turn to social media and “love the attention.”

“I think the difficulty is … but I think the difficulty if Susan was out, she would be on social media,” Pope said. “She would love the attention. It would be in David’s face every day, and all he has ever talked about is justice for Michael and Alex.”

Pope said David Smith has tried not to act vindictively toward Susan because of his Christian beliefs and has said he forgives her. Still, he noted that the boys’ father continues to believe they deserve justice—and that he shares that view.

Susan Smith at a parole hearing in 2024

Susan Smith wipes away a tear during a parole hearing on Nov. 20, 2024, in Columbia, South Carolina. It was her first parole hearing since killing her sons in 1994, and she participated by video. (The Island Packet/Getty Images)

Pope said he does not believe Smith was truly remorseful when she killed the children. He also said jurors intended for her life sentence to mean she would remain incarcerated rather than eventually become eligible for parole.

“The jury truly believed they were giving her a life sentence, that she would spend the rest of her time lamenting what she’d done in regard to Michael and Alex,” Pope said. “And I think what we’ve seen is, unfortunately, Susan is more focused on Susan. Her remorse is for her circumstances, not for those boys.”

The parole board rejected Smith’s request at her first hearing in November 2024, despite her expression of regret over the killings.

“I know that what I did was horrible. And I would give anything if I could go back and change it,” she told the board during the Zoom hearing. “I love Michael and Alex with all my heart.”

Lake and memorial cross

Tommy Pope said Susan Smith’s “remorse is for her circumstances, not for those boys.” (Thomas S. England/Getty Images)

“I am a Christian and God is a big part of my life. And I know he has forgiven me,” Smith said.

Pope, who prosecuted Smith, said he plans to attend every future parole hearing and oppose her release.

“I will be with the father of the boys, David Smith, every two years, as long as it takes to keep her where she is now,” Pope said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Florida rainfall supercharged by El Niño floods roads and collapses synagogue's roof

El Niño-Fueled Florida Rain Floods Roads, Collapses Synagogue Roof

A slow-moving storm system unleashed torrential rain across South Florida on Wednesday,…
Irish activist indicted in US over alleged destruction of $60M military plane

Irish Activist Indicted in US Over Alleged Destruction of $60M Military Plane

An Irish anti-Israel activist has been indicted in the United States after…
North Side shootings on bike path, CTA Red Line station stairwell leave 2 dead, 1 critically wounded: Chicago police

2 Killed, 1 Critical in North Side Bike Path, Red Line Shootings

CHICAGO () — Two people were killed and another was critically injured…
Charlotte wants Iryna Zarutska wrongful death lawsuit thrown out

Charlotte Seeks Dismissal of Iryna Zarutska Wrongful Death Suit

The city of Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss a wrongful-death…
US military returns to 2 aircraft carriers in the Middle East

US Military Restores Two-Carrier Presence in Middle East

The US military is once again relying on two aircraft carriers for…
American Airlines passengers thrown into panic when luggage comes out covered in mysterious ‘poop’-like substance after 2-hour delay

American Airlines Passengers Find Luggage Covered in Mystery Goo

Talk about a crappy flight. American Airlines passengers were thrown into panicked…
Skydiving injury leaves 24-year-old tourist Chloe Lowe stranded in Australia on medical no-fly list

Skydiving Injury Leaves British Tourist Chloe Lowe, 24, Stranded in Australia Under No-Fly Order

A 24-year-old tourist says she has been stranded in Australia for weeks…
Northwestern University students fight off dorm intruder Diaunte Adams

Northwestern University Students Fight Off Dorm Intruder Diaunte Adams

A Chicago-area man has been charged after authorities say he bypassed security…
Fairfield water battle ends with China’s second-richest man taking control

Fairfield Water Battle Ends: China’s Second-Richest Man Takes Control

A California city is facing a backlash from residents over a plan…
U.S. indicts alleged Russian agent for spying on Silicon Valley defense firm

U.S. Indicts Alleged Russian Agent Over Silicon Valley Defense Spying

Washington — A federal grand jury indicted a Russian national Tuesday on…
The Post's 225 icons: Joey Chestnut became an NYC legend one hot dog at a time

How Joey Chestnut Became an NYC Legend, One Hot Dog at a Time

As The New York Post marks its 225th birthday, we’re celebrating the…
San Diego Unified backs letting 16- and 17-year-olds vote in school board elections

San Diego Unified Supports Vote for 16- and 17-Year-Olds in School Board Elections

San Diego Unified School District has proposed an unusual approach to shaping…