Man arrested for attempted murder on Christmas in Fort White


Suspect Apprehended in Christmas Day Attempted Murder Case in Fort White

A 53-year-old man named Johnny McNutt has been taken into custody following an incident where he allegedly shot another individual in the head, as reported by the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

FORT WHITE, Fla. — On Christmas Day, law enforcement officers responded to an emergency call that led to the arrest of McNutt and the hospitalization of a victim, according to the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

The deputies were dispatched to a residence on Cullen Avenue, where they discovered a man suffering from a gunshot wound to the head.

While the sheriff’s office has not yet disclosed the victim’s identity or age, they have confirmed he is male. As of the latest update on Friday afternoon, the victim remains in critical condition at the hospital.

After being questioned by authorities, Johnny McNutt confessed to shooting the victim and was subsequently arrested.

The preliminary investigation by the sheriff’s office indicates that earlier in the day, McNutt and the victim were involved in a physical altercation. Following the confrontation, McNutt reportedly retrieved a firearm and approached the victim, who was seated in a chair, and fired a single shot to the head without warning.

McNutt is charged with attempted second-degree murder. 

First Coast News has requested the mugshot and arrest report for additional details.

Anyone with more information regarding this case is asked to contact investigators at 386-719-2005.

You May Also Like

Cockpit recorder capturing doomed Learjet crew's final moments recovered

Cockpit Recorder From Doomed Learjet Captures Crew’s Final Moments

A cockpit voice recorder that may contain the Learjet crew’s final moments…
Ohio State fraternity temporarily suspended after video shows 2 men on fire

Ohio State Fraternity Suspended After Video Shows 2 Men on Fire

The social media footage shows a crowd gathered outdoors, with many people…
Brave Utah teen held captive for a year escaped using popular online video game

Utah Teen Escapes After a Year in Captivity Using Online Game

A teenager who was allegedly abducted by a sexual predator and held…
South Carolina dad left sleeping 6-year-old in line for Pokémon cards at Target: police

South Carolina dad accused of leaving sleeping 6-year-old alone in Target Pokémon card line

Suspected Pokémon card thieves arrested in California amid wave of thefts Matt…
T. Cullen Davis, a Texas oil tycoon acquitted in a 1970s murder trial, has died at 93

T. Cullen Davis, Texas Oil Tycoon Acquitted in 1970s Murder Trial, Dies at 93

T. Cullen Davis, the Texas oil tycoon acquitted in two high-profile murder…
Rescue group removes plastic pumpkin from deer's snout after 10-day search

Deer Freed From Plastic Pumpkin After Rescuers’ 10-Day Search

A Michigan wildlife rescue team has finally freed a young deer that…
Former Massachusetts police officer faces murder trial over pregnant woman's staged suicide

Ex-Massachusetts Cop Convicted of Pregnant Woman’s Murder

A former Massachusetts police detective has been convicted of murdering a pregnant…
Death row inmate unconscious on ventilator after botched execution for teen’s killing: attorneys

Tennessee Warns Christa Pike Execution Could Stall Over Access to Drug Labels, Court Filing Says

Anesthesiologist who advised Christa Pike’s defense criticizes lethal injection process Dr. Joel…
Massie introduces impeachment articles against Hegseth, teeing up vote this week

Rep. Thomas Massie Files Impeachment Articles Against Hegseth

Washington — Rep. Thomas Massie on Monday filed articles of impeachment against…
Alderpersons grill Chicago election officials about glitch that caused ballot shortages on 2026 Election Day

Chicago Aldermen Grill Officials Over 2026 Ballot Shortage Glitch

CHICAGO — Chicago alderpersons sharply criticized Board of Elections officials during a…
This 2014 image provided by NASA shows a Taurid fireball recorded at the NASA All Sky Fireball Network station in Tullahoma, Tenn. (NASA via AP)

Taurid Meteor Shower May Bring Bright Shooting Stars This Week

The Northern Taurid meteor shower is set to reach its peak by…
How Blue Angels pilot Scott Laux's ouster was discovered by eagle-eyed onlookers

Eagle-Eyed Fans Uncover Blue Angels Pilot Scott Laux’s Ouster

The sudden removal of a Blue Angels pilot from the elite flight…