Behind the 'boondoggle' of Newsom's high-speed rail dream

The Complexity of Newsom's High-Speed Rail Vision

We’re a long way from the transcontinental railroad.

In the 1860s, we constructed the iconic American infrastructure project in approximately six years, laying down 1,776 miles of track and creating 15 tunnels through the Sierra Nevada mountains.

Granted, working conditions back then didn’t exactly meet OSHA standards.

However, if current regulations and practices were in place, the project would have been indefinitely delayed somewhere outside of Sacramento, California, mired in extensive environmental lawsuits.

The Golden State’s emblematic, modern infrastructure project was supposed to be a high-speed rail link between its two largest cities.

Don’t expect, though, to see the equivalent of the Golden Spike any time soon, or perhaps ever.

The high-speed rail project has been excruciatingly slow: After roughly 15 years of persistent delays and rising costs, not a single piece of track has been installed, an unparalleled example of inefficiency.

California high-speed rail is the West Coast’s answer to Boston’s notorious Big Dig that took about a decade longer to build than anticipated at a much greater cost, although it was eventually completed.

Now, the Trump administration is cutting off $4 billion in federal funds for the project, arguing that it doesn’t want to pour any more money into a boondoggle. 

The imagined bullet train was always a misfire.

The idea of high-speed rail has a nearly erotic appeal to progressives, who love communal trains over individualized autos and think cars are destroying the planet whereas trains can save it.

High-speed rail is to transit what windmills are to energy — an environmentally correct, futuristic technology that will always under-deliver. 

California voters passed Proposition 1A getting the ball — if not any actual trains — rolling in 2008. The project was supposed to cost $33 billion and connect Los Angeles and San Francisco. 

What could go wrong? Well, everything.

Bad decisions about where to build the tracks, complacent contractors, environmental and union rules— you name it. 

The initial, scaled-back line is now supposed to be completed by 2033, and even that is optimistic.

Elon Musk might put a man on Mars before Gov. Gavin Newsom or one of his successors manages to get even a much less ambitious high-speed rail system underway. 

The current focus is a line between Merced (pop. 93,000) and Bakersfield (413,000).

No offense to the good people of either of these places, but these aren’t major metropolises.

In Northeast terms, this is less a rail connection between New York City and Washington, DC, and more a connection between Newark, NJ, and Bridgeport, Conn.

Passenger estimates for the California system have always been absurd. The fantasy is that ridership will be double what it is now is in the Northeast corridor.

But as Marc Joffe of the California Policy Center points out, population is much denser near Northeast stations, it’s easier to get around cities in the Northeast on the way to or from the train, and a rail culture is much more embedded in the Northeast than car-centric California.

As for reducing greenhouse emissions, the long-running project is itself a significant source of emissions and the benefit of fewer drivers in cars will be vitiated by the fact more and more people in California will be driving electric vehicles. 

The original estimated $33 billion cost is now $35 billion for just the scaled-back line, and more than $100 billion and counting for the whole shebang.

There is no reason that the feds should pour good money after bad supporting a preposterous project that doesn’t have any national significance.

California governor Gavin Newsom — too embarrassed to admit failure or too drunk on visions of European-style rail — remains fully committed. 

In a statement, he said Trump’s defunding decision is a “gift to China,” as if Beijing cares whether people get to Bakersfield by car, plane or high-speed rail. 

The project has already been a distressing object lesson in California’s inability to build anything of consequence, and there’s more where that came from. 

Twitter: @RichLowry

You May Also Like

Texas woman broke into home and took a shower, had meth and other drugs in car: sheriff

Texas Woman Accused of Home Break-In, Showering; Meth Found in Car

Trinity County deputies arrested Stella Baker after they allegedly found her showering…
Florida dad blasts wife, 3 kids before killing himself in murder-suicide

Florida Father Kills Wife and Three Children Before Dying by Suicide in Murder-Suicide

A father fatally shot his wife and their three young children inside…
Charlotte wants Iryna Zarutska wrongful death lawsuit thrown out

Charlotte Seeks Dismissal of Iryna Zarutska Wrongful Death Suit

The city of Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss a wrongful-death…
Mom faked healthy tot's illnesses, forced him to undergo invasive surgery in disturbing Munchausen syndrome case: cops

Mother Accused of Faking Healthy Toddler’s Illnesses, Forcing Invasive Surgery in Munchausen Syndrome Case

The mother of a 2-year-old boy allegedly fabricated a complex story that…
AI is fueling

AI Is Fueling Innovation, Anxiety, and a New Era of Change

The surge in artificial intelligence data-center construction is adding pressure to the…
US military returns to 2 aircraft carriers in the Middle East

US Military Restores Two-Carrier Presence in Middle East

The US military is once again relying on two aircraft carriers for…
‘Looksmaxxing’ influencer ‘Clavicular’ allegedly told teen to lie about age, call vodka ‘water’ before assault

Looksmaxxing Influencer Clavicular Accused of Teen Age Lie Before Assault

Braden Peters, the controversial “looksmaxxing” influencer known online as “Clavicular,” has been…
Nvidia says it will stop selling some AI data center chips to China

Nvidia to Stop Selling Some AI Data Center Chips to China

Nvidia interim CEO Colette Kress said Tuesday that the company has halted…
Bodycam shows 13-year-old on e-bike fleeing Orange County cop

Bodycam Video Shows 13-Year-Old E-Bike Rider Fleeing Orange County Deputy

A 13-year-old Orange County boy apparently believed he could outrun a motorcycle…
Susan Smith prosecutor fears her release would put her in grieving father’s face ‘every day’

Susan Smith Prosecutor Fears Release Would Haunt Grieving Father

The prosecutor who helped send Susan Smith to prison says he worries…
Former Sen. Ben Sasse wrote memoir about surviving pancreatic cancer

Former U.S. Sen. Ben Sasse’s Memoir on Surviving Pancreatic Cancer

NEW YORK — Nearly a year after doctors gave him four months…
Florida DMV worker faces 360 felonies for allegedly helping illegal aliens get licenses without driving tests

Florida DMV Worker Faces 360 Felonies in No-Test License Scheme

DHS and DOT investigate truck-driving schools over allegedly fraudulent licenses Fox News…