Menendez brothers score crucial legal victory in decades-long fight as they await potential freedom

As notorious brothers Erik and Lyle Menendez await their parole hearing in August, they have experienced a legal triumph on a different front, now presenting new evidence they argue might have led to their acquittal.

The duo, who acknowledged killing their parents, Mary “Kitty” and Jose Menendez, during a brutal 1989 shotgun attack in their Beverly Hills residence, have maintained for years that their actions were in self-defense due to a lifetime of physical and sexual abuse.

A July 8 court order obtained by Fox News Digital will force the state to explain why evidence to that effect was barred from their trial. 

Menendez Brothers in a black and white photo outside their Beverly Hills home

Erik Menendez, left, and his brother Lyle, are seen in front of their Beverly Hills home. They are the main suspects in their parents’ murder. (Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)

In an informal response to that petition, filed by Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman’s office in February of this year, prosecutors denied that the letter and the affidavit constituted new evidence. They said that the Cano letter was “untimely.” They also said the Rossello affidavit was “inadmissible, immaterial, and lacks credibility.” 

But the July 8 order, handed down by Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge William C. Ryan, said that the letter and the affidavit constitute a prima facie showing that the brothers are entitled to habeas relief. 

The district attorney’s office is now subject to a “show cause” response in the next 30 days. In their response, Hochman’s office must explain why the brothers’ habeas relief should not be granted. 

Supporters of the Menendez brothers outside court following the favorable ruling in the resentencing hearing.

Attorney Mark Geragos speaks to reporters at the Menendez brothers’ resentencing hearing,  Van Nuys, California, Tuesday, May 13, 2025.  (Derek Shook for Fox News Digital)

The brothers sought a new trial in 2023, but have since shifted their focus to their own resentencing, which they were granted in May. Judge Michael Jesic resentenced the brothers to 50 years to life with the possibility of parole. They were previously serving life without parole. 

Since, the brothers have been eagerly awaiting that parole hearing. After it was initially scheduled for June 13, it was postponed until August 21 and 22. 

They have spent 35 years behind bars. 

You May Also Like

Missouri firefighter mom Sarah Longest dies while off-duty after falling 50 feet in 'tragic accident'

Off-Duty Missouri Firefighter Mom Sarah Longest Dies in 50-Foot Fall

A Missouri firefighter died after falling about 50 feet from a cliff…
NTSB details warning whistles and emergency orders before tanker collision capsized New Orleans riverboat

NTSB Details Warnings Before Tanker Collision Capsized New Orleans Riverboat

Federal investigators said Sunday that the tanker involved in Friday’s New Orleans…
Michael John Roberts, 'BoJack Horseman' animator, has died

BoJack Horseman Animator Michael John Roberts Has Died

Michael John Roberts, the Canadian animator known best for his work on…
Mexico's cartel 'godfather' convicted in American DEA agent's murder dies at age 80

Mexico’s Cartel ‘Godfather’ Dies at 80 After DEA Agent Murder Conviction

Miguel Angel Felix Gallardo, a co-founder of the Guadalajara cartel known as…
2 public safety officers among 3 shot during wellness check at NYC apartment

3 Shot, Including 2 Public Safety Officers, During NYC Apartment Wellness Check

Two peace officers were among three people wounded Monday during a wellness…
Climber trapped on Yosemite's El Capitan for nine days when massive storm hit California

Climber Trapped 9 Days on Yosemite’s El Capitan as Storm Hits

Champion climber Sasha DiGiulian was nearing the end of an ambitious attempt…
Glenn Close, Ridley Scott and Floyd Norman honored at 2026 Governors Awards in Hollywood

Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, Floyd Norman Honored at Governors Awards

HOLLYWOOD, LOS ANGELES (KABC) — Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, animator Floyd Norman…
Everything to know about 2026 CMAs, from who's performing to how to watch

2026 CMA Awards: Performers, How to Watch and Everything to Know

The 60th Annual CMA Awards are only days away, bringing together some…
Elderly homeowner’s hired help turns into squatter nightmare made worse by blue state laws: report

Elderly Homeowner Says Hired Helper Became Squatter as Blue State Laws Complicate Eviction: Report

A 76-year-old California homeowner says a man she hired to repair plumbing…
FBI investigates who placed bomb near Illinois ethanol plant

FBI Investigates Bomb Found Near Illinois Ethanol Plant

The FBI’s Springfield, Illinois, office is directing the investigation and search for…
Mamdani guts elite NYPD tactical unit, backs 'civilian-led approach' to responding to protests

NYC Mayor Mamdani Cuts Elite NYPD Unit, Backs Civilian Protest Plan

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday that the NYPD’s Strategic…
Two public safety officers shot at NYC housing complex; suspect dead

2 Public Safety Officers Shot at NYC Housing Complex; Suspect Dead

Two public safety officers were shot Monday at a New York City…