Family matriarch dies day after rescue from remote island that saw family swim ashore to escape boat fire

A day after being rescued by the U.S. Coast Guard, a woman who, along with her family, was stranded on a secluded island in Massachusetts after fleeing a burning boat, has passed away. The incident occurred when their vessel caught fire while anchored overnight in a cove.

Cynthia Sullivan, aged 73, succumbed to her injuries on Thursday, as confirmed by a family member’s Facebook post shared the following day. Boston 25 News reported on the unfortunate outcome.

The family’s dog, who alerted Cynthia, her husband Patrick Sullivan, 72, and their 37-year-old son, Tyler, to the blaze as they slept on their 30-foot powerboat, The Third Wave, did not survive the fire.

Upon waking to find their boat engulfed in flames, the Sullivans swam to Naushon Island, a small landmass located about four miles from Martha’s Vineyard.

Injured and scorched, the family sought refuge inside a barn on the island. They remained there for over 24 hours until a marine radio washed ashore on Wednesday morning, which allowed Tyler to call for assistance.

Coast Guard helicopter landing on island

The U.S. Coast Guard conducted a helicopter rescue operation this week, saving the family of three from the isolated island. They had been forced to swim there after their boat was consumed by fire, according to the agency.

“Mayday, mayday, mayday, our ship went down in Tarpaulin Cove,” Tyler is heard saying in a radio transmission to the Coast Guard. “Our ship burned while we were sleeping, and we barely escaped.”

A Coast Guard helicopter rescue crew soon arrived and airlifted the family to Cape Cod Hospital in Hyannis.

A family member had reported the Sullivans missing when they didn’t arrive home Tuesday and calls to their cellphones, which went down with the boat, went straight to voicemail.

Multiple agencies searched the area Tuesday night and early Wednesday, and were unable to get accurate pings from the family’s submerged phones until Tyler reached them on the recovered handheld radio, according to the Coast Guard.

Helicopter flying away from island

The Coast Guard airlifted the family to Cape Cod Hospital in Hyannis. (USCG)

In a Facebook post, Chris Sullivan memorialized his mother and provided updates on his father and “hero” brother. 

“She went in peace. We played her some John Mellencamp as she passed, he was her absolute favorite, she adored him,” Sullivan wrote. “This hurts more than anything I could have ever imagined, I am leaning on my close friends and family and my two young children. We will get through this together.

“My dad is awake and breathing on his own. My brother saved both of them, he was able to get them off the boat under extremely chaotic circumstances, he doesn’t want to be called a hero, but he is. Again, thank you for all the support, it means the world.” 

Martha's Vineyard aerial

The island is about four miles from Martha’s Vineyard.  (John Greim/LightRocket via Getty Images)

“Quick thinking and having quality equipment allowed the family to survive and call for help,” Scott Backholm, a search and rescue mission coordinator from Coast Guard Sector Southeastern New England, said in a statement. “Mariners are encouraged to pursue first aid training and ensure their vessels are outfitted with proper safety equipment.”

The Sullivans had left nearby Falmouth, Massachusetts, last Friday and had planned to return Tuesday afternoon.

You May Also Like

Mamdani's Pied-a-Terre Tax Puts NYC Business Leaders on Edge - Internewscast Journal

Mamdani’s Pied-a-Terre Tax Puts NYC Business Leaders on Edge

New York City’s business community has shown little appetite for an open…
Painful Mishap Ends Idaho Unicyclist’s Guinness Record Bid - Internewscast Journal

Painful Mishap Ends Idaho Unicyclist’s Guinness Record Bid

An Idaho record-chaser aiming to land a Guinness World Record by juggling…
Husband of NC Woman Missing in Grenada Doubts Foul Play - Internewscast Journal

Husband of NC Woman Missing in Grenada Doubts Foul Play

The husband of a North Carolina woman who vanished last week during…
Cheltenham High Football Hazing: 6 Players, 4 Coaches Charged - Internewscast Journal

Cheltenham High Football Hazing: 6 Players, 4 Coaches Charged

CHELTENHAM, Pa. — Ten people are facing criminal charges tied to an…
New Global Report: Antisemitic Violence Deadliest Since 1994 - Internewscast Journal

New Global Report: Antisemitic Violence Deadliest Since 1994

A stark new report has found that 2025 marked the deadliest year…
Kern County Teen Murder Victim Finally Identified After 50 Years - Internewscast Journal

Kern County Teen Murder Victim Finally Identified After 50 Years

Nearly five decades after a teenage girl’s body was found buried in…
Todd Blanche Nomination Stalls as Two Senate Republicans Block Vote on Trump DOJ Pick - Internewscast Journal

Todd Blanche Nomination Stalls as Two Senate Republicans Block Vote on Trump DOJ Pick

Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche’s path to confirmation hit a major setback…
Cold Case Breakthrough: Teen Buried in California Vineyard Identified After Nearly 50 Years as Family Warns Killer Remains Free - Internewscast Journal

Cold Case Breakthrough: Teen Buried in California Vineyard Identified After Nearly 50 Years as Family Warns Killer Remains Free

A teenage girl found buried in a shallow grave beneath a California…
China, Russia, Iran and North Korea form 'axis of aggressors' that could overwhelm US, book warns

New Book Warns China, Russia, Iran and North Korea Could Overwhelm US as ‘Axis of Aggressors’

China, Russia, Iran and North Korea are increasingly operating like a coordinated…
Louisville Teen Killed in Shooting After Saving Harassed Girl - Internewscast Journal

Louisville Teen Killed in Shooting After Saving Harassed Girl

A Louisville high school student who was praised earlier this year for…
Nolan Wells Case: New Audio Shows No Nefarious Clues, Ex-FBI Says - Internewscast Journal

Nolan Wells Case: New Audio Shows No Nefarious Clues, Ex-FBI Says

A former FBI agent says newly surfaced audio tied to the disappearance…
Terrifying Dashcam Shows Armin K. Hastings Reversing in Beaverton Road Rage - Internewscast Journal

Terrifying Dashcam Shows Armin K. Hastings Reversing in Beaverton Road Rage

BEAVERTON, Ore. — A frightening road rage encounter in Beaverton, Oregon, was…