Senne Lammens likely returned home on Sunday evening, opened his journal and tried to understand how everything had gone so badly wrong.
Writing helps settle Lammens’ thoughts and gives him a way to move beyond disappointment. His 90 minutes against Aston Villa will rank among the most difficult moments of his Manchester United career.
He may have questioned his decision to use his knees rather than his hands when dealing with Alysson’s shot in the first minute. Three minutes later, he could also have done more than parry an effort straight into Nicolas Jackson’s path for Villa’s second goal. Lammens believes strongly in personal responsibility, and he would not have needed anyone to point out his errors.
The blame for Villa’s third and fourth goals, however, rests firmly with his team-mates — another recurring theme in United’s season.
Even so, this was Lammens’ poorest display in a Manchester United shirt, and the goalkeeper himself is unlikely to argue otherwise. That does not mean he has suddenly become a poor goalkeeper. Quite the opposite.
The focus has understandably fallen on his two expensive mistakes against Villa, but it has also obscured the vital one-on-one save he produced to deny Julio Enciso in United’s opening home fixture against Ipswich Town. The score was 0-0 at the time before United went on to win 5-2.
Senne Lammens has endured a difficult start to the season and was partly responsible for two goals in Manchester United’s 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on Sunday
His two outstanding saves at Fulham, first to keep out Sander Berge and then Josh King, have also faded from memory. The second, brilliantly blocked with his right foot, kept a struggling United level at 0-0.
On the opening weekend, the 24-year-old did superbly to push Oli McBurnie’s goal-bound effort onto the post. Three defenders then switched off, allowing Hull City to score in a match United eventually lost 2-0.
The defensive failures of Bryan Mbeumo against Ipswich Town and Carlos Baleba against Leeds United have received less attention, as have costly errors from Lisandro Martinez, Diogo Dalot and Leny Yoro.
There is no question that Lammens’ form has dipped. Yet no Premier League goalkeeper is currently being exposed more severely by the players in front of him than United’s No 1.
Through 10 Premier League matches, Lammens has faced 52 shots on target — the joint-highest total in the division alongside Newcastle United’s Lukas Hornicek.
It is also significant that no goalkeeper has made more saves in a single Premier League game this season than Lammens’ eight against Chelsea. United still lost that match 2-0.
He has made the fourth-highest number of saves in the league, yet has conceded a competition-high 19 goals. Crystal Palace’s 24 goals against have been shared between Walter Benitez and Dean Henderson.
Last season, Lammens faced 118 shots across 32 matches, an average of 3.69 per game. This campaign, he has already dealt with 52 shots in 10 appearances — 5.2 per match. The increase in his workload is stark.
He faced six or more shots in only two Premier League matches last season. This season, that threshold has already been reached four times.
Lammens raced from his goal and missed the ball as Evanilson rounded him to score Bournemouth’s third at Old Trafford last month
Errors at Everton, Fulham and against Villa have proved costly. His distribution has also become a concern, with Lammens ranking 15th among the 16 ever-present goalkeepers for completed long passes, having found a team-mate with only 37 of his 115 attempts.
Lammens, though, impressed during Belgium’s most recent international break while operating behind a more dependable defence. At United, he does not currently enjoy the same protection.
“Sometimes it comes down to a mistake here or there from someone, but it doesn’t really start with that,” Lammens said earlier this season when discussing United’s defensive problems.
“I think it’s a team thing. The manager has been stressing the importance of defending as a team and being able to press the opposition, especially when dealing with crosses.”
One of Lammens’ greatest strengths last season was the calm authority he brought to goal. He offered United the composure they had often lacked from Andre Onana. This season, that quality has been eroded.
Signs of anxiety have begun to appear. There was the misplaced pass to Kobbie Mainoo against Tottenham Hotspur, a decision that was never really available, although Lammens recovered to make an excellent save from Dominic Solanke. At Old Trafford against Bournemouth, he charged out and missed the ball as Evanilson scored. At Fulham, he chose to use his legs after the ball ricocheted off Martinez and ended up in his own net.
Those incidents have fuelled criticism from pundits and social media users who now believe the goalkeeper may be operating beyond his level.
That is where journaling becomes important. It helps Lammens maintain his belief that circumstances will improve and retain the composure of a player who did not become carried away when he was named the Premier League’s Signing of the Season for 2025-26 — and who is refusing to be overwhelmed by the most scrutinised spell of his career.
“Especially at big clubs, you don’t want a goalkeeper who performs brilliantly one week and poorly the next,” Lammens said in September.
“You want someone who is a rock behind the defence, someone the team can rely on. That is a major goal for me. It is something I want to embody as a goalkeeper.
“You can compare it a little with Edwin van der Sar, someone I admire enormously. The quality I want to take from his game is that calmness.”
Lammens’ confidence was shaken by the mistake that contributed to Belgium’s World Cup exit against Spain, while United’s leaky defence has given him little opportunity to rebuild it
The 24-year-old is known to sacrifice days off for extra training, while sources say he is among the first to arrive and the last to leave
Lammens is renowned for giving up days off to do additional work. Sources say he is usually the first player in and the last to leave training. Some within United even believe aspects of his game have improved since last season.
His confidence took a major blow in the summer when a spill to Mikel Merino helped send Belgium out of the World Cup. The turmoil at Manchester United has since left him with little space to restore that belief.
Kobe Bryant is Lammens’ sporting idol. He wears the late Los Angeles Lakers star’s numbers on his gloves and embraces Bryant’s “Mamba Mentality”. If that mindset offers any lesson, it is that resilience and courage can ultimately overcome adversity.
Lammens is struggling, but he remains the same goalkeeper who earned widespread praise last season. What he needs now is greater support from the defenders in front of him. Without it, United’s back line will remain trapped in a cycle of mistakes and frustration.