The new signing who's yet to catch fire, the Dan Burn dilemma, the missing sporting director and the Bruno Guimaraes gripe: My key concerns about Newcastle ahead of two crunch fixtures - CRAIG HOPE
Share this @internewscast.com

Newcastle United head into two crunch fixtures ahead of the international break with a chance to get their season up and running.

What feels like a crucial journey to face Belgian champions Union Saint-Gilloise in the Champions League on Wednesday is succeeded by a Premier League clash of similar importance at home against Nottingham Forest on Sunday.

An unsteady beginning has positioned Eddie Howe’s team at 15th in the Premier League and has raised questions about how their season might unfold following a challenging summer.

1. Bruno’s inconsistency 

This season, Bruno Guimaraes has fluctuated between a score of five out of ten and nine out of ten in performances. For a captain playing in midfield, this inconsistency is problematic for a team that is looking for inspiration further up the field.

The Brazilian is always reliable when it comes to effort and character, yet he is not persistently impacting matches in the way he can – and ought to.

Captain Bruno Guimaraes has been inconsistent for Newcastle this season and struggled to impact some games

Captain Bruno Guimaraes has been inconsistent for Newcastle this season and struggled to impact some games

Guimaraes battles with Declan Rice in Newcastle's loss to Arsenal, which the Gunners midfielder dominated

Guimaraes battles with Declan Rice in Newcastle’s loss to Arsenal, which the Gunners midfielder dominated

Consider Sunday’s game against Arsenal. Guimaraes managed 39 touches and seemed almost detached. This contrasts sharply with Declan Rice, who had 104 touches and dominated the midfield.

With Newcastle holding a 1-0 advantage from the 34th minute until the 84th, their midfield needed to maintain control and secure the victory. However, they never managed to dominate the match, and Guimaraes couldn’t assert himself against Rice and Martin Zubimendi.

The frustration for Newcastle is that this was the sort of feisty encounter when he does don his superhero’s cape, as he did when scoring in the 3-2 defeat by Liverpool in August. He was Captain Marvel that night, as he is at his best. 

Right now, though, there are too many matches when he does not impact to game-changing effect. History has shown that Guimaraes grows into a season, but Newcastle need one of their best players to stand tall – and fast.

2. Elanga’s slow start

For perhaps the fastest player ever to wear black and white, this has been a slow start. Elanga, at £55million, is the third-most expensive signing in the club’s history. He was brought in from Nottingham Forest with a belief he could hit the ground running. 

Save for one electrifying half versus Barcelona, his landing on Tyneside has been heavy and not as fleet-footed as Howe would have hoped.

Elanga was the first right winger signed post-2021 takeover and was supposed to be an upgrade on Jacob Murphy, who was signed in 2017. After two matches, though, Murphy replaced Elanga in the starting XI and still appears ahead of the latter in the pecking order.

All new arrivals need a period of adaption, of course, and Howe was right to point out that the Swede would have recorded an assist had the finishing on the end of some of his deliveries been better. As it stands, he has not created or scored a goal in eight appearances, four of which have been starts.

But Elanga is still learning how to use his speed in a new team, and likewise his team-mates are working out what he wants. At Forest, in a side that ceded possession and played on the break, he was perfect. It needs some work before we can say that about his fit at Newcastle.

Anthony Elanga has yet to score or record an assist for Newcastle since he joined the club from Nottingham Forest for £55million

Anthony Elanga has yet to score or record an assist for Newcastle since he joined the club from Nottingham Forest for £55million

3. Big decision on Big Dan Burn

This is a nice problem for Howe to have, but in Burn and Sven Botman he has two outstanding left-sided centre backs, both of whom want and deserve to start in that position. To accommodate both means a compromise.

Against Arsenal, Burn went to left back. Can he perform there? Yes, but his outstanding form at centre back over the past 12 months has deservedly taken him into the England squad. At left back, as we saw against Bukayo Saka, he is at times exposed for a lack of pace. At centre back, his know-how rarely sees him done for toe. Put it this way, he is not an England left back.

One other option is playing three centre backs. However, in a team struggling for goals, removing an attacking player and adding another to an-already solid backline would feel like taking an umbrella to the desert.

And then there is the choice of pairing Botman and Burn together, with the former shifted to the right. They have tried this before and, while Botman is smart enough to adapt, he does look a little awkward and loses a little of what makes him so good. That is why his four starts this season have all come on his favoured side.

This is a dilemma Howe will welcome, but it will not be easy telling one of Burn or Botman they are not first pick for the biggest matches, if this is the call he makes. That’s the life of a manager.

Speaking in Brussels on Tuesday, Howe said: ‘It’s a great problem to have in the sense that you have two outstanding players who bring different qualities but both perform very strongly.

‘It’s great to see Sven back to the form that we know he’s capable of. He is a big player in terms of ball distribution and helping us elevate our game to another level. When he was in his best moment, he was fundamental to our rise two years ago.

‘Dan has just been a giant in every sense for us. His leadership skills are invaluable to us. Dan has played left back a lot. Even though we haven’t started him there in a lot of games this season, he has ended up playing there because of how we’ve pressed or tactically built our game.

‘I am comfortable with all of the options (for Burn and Botman) and I’m sure I will use all of them through the season.’

Newcastle's Dan Burn struggles to keep up with Bukayo Saka of Arsenal on Sunday while playing at left back

Newcastle’s Dan Burn struggles to keep up with Bukayo Saka of Arsenal on Sunday while playing at left back 

4. Woltemade worries

The £69m German feels like both the problem and the solution for Newcastle at present. 

And that, it should be said, is not a criticism. He could not have done much more, scoring from the only two chances his new team-mates have created for him. But therein lies the concern, Woltemade does not seem the type to fashion openings on his own – at least not yet – and finds himself in an attacking unit next to under-performing personnel who look spooked by the change at centre forward. 

We mentioned Elanga above because there is focus given the recent price tag, but the form of Harvey Barnes and Anthony Gordon is worthy of equal inspection. Between the four wingers, there is one assist and one goal from eight matches.

‘It’s been a bit stop-start for all of them, there has not been much fluency for any of the four,’ said Howe. ‘We need them firing, in terms of goalscoring and creating. If you play with wingers, as we have done historically, if they are not performing then they hurt the system. That is something we really need to focus on.’ 

Some of Woltemade’s best work has been on halfway with his back to goal – but what Newcastle need more is a striker in the penalty area facing the goal! They need to miss some chances!

The concern is that Woltemade is a very good player but, in the immediacy of what Newcastle require post-Alexander Isak, perhaps not the right player. The transition was meant to be eased by the signing of Yoane Wissa – more like in Isak in style – but he is currently injured and not expected to return until after the international break.

So, as long as Woltemade is fit and scoring – two from three starts – he has to play. He has carried the shirt with personality and deserves huge credit for a pair of clinical finishes. The hope is that this early exposure accelerates his acclimatisation to the Premier League and his new colleagues – and, by extension, them to him.

Supporters, though, are worried that their team looks unlike the one defined by its front-foot intensity, where the playbook was as familiar to those in the stands as it was those on the pitch. Much like Woltemade’s baggy jersey, the fit of Howe’s team feels far less tailored than it once was.

Newcastle's new German striker Nick Woltemade heads home a cross to give his side the lead over Arsenal... but is he capable of creating goals for himself?

Newcastle’s new German striker Nick Woltemade heads home a cross to give his side the lead over Arsenal… but is he capable of creating goals for himself? 

5. The lesser-spotted sporting director

Ross Wilson is expected to arrive from Nottingham Forest in October, and that should mark the end of three months without a sporting director. 

It has been too long and does not reflect well on the running of the club that a position of such importance has been vacant during a key period. It sends the wrong message to those inside and outside Newcastle United.

There are contract issues to be addressed across the squad, including with star player Sandro Tonali. 

Ross Wilson is expected to become Newcastle's new sporting director in October but the position has been vacant for three months, leaving the club looking rudderless

Ross Wilson is expected to become Newcastle’s new sporting director in October but the position has been vacant for three months, leaving the club looking rudderless

Lessons should be learnt by what happened with Isak. His desire to leave was, ironically, in part motivated by the decision of former sporting director, Paul Mitchell, not to give him a new contract.

Newcastle need presence and direction from the top, not just with a new sporting director, but from a Saudi ownership whose communication with supporters continues to be more occasional than accountable.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Gordon Returns to Scotland Team as Clarke Opts for Stability in Attack for World Cup Matches

There is a renewed sense of belief among the Tartan Army that…

Jude Bellingham’s Family Feud: Parents Separated at Game Due to ‘Intense Atmosphere’ and Rising ‘Insecurity’ as England Coach Omits Him from Squad

Jude Bellingham is currently under scrutiny regarding his positions with both the…

Brentford’s Igor Thiago: From Bricklayer to Man United Conqueror, Overcoming Personal Loss, Keith Andrews’ Influence, and Aspiring to be Brazil’s Next No. 9 and Golden Boot Winner

Igor Thiago is currently at the peak of his form. He has…

Jamie Redknapp Apologizes to Lord Sugar on Sky Sports After Apprentice Star Considers Legal Action Over Tottenham Comments

Jamie Redknapp has offered an apology to Lord Sugar after the former…

Olympic Champion Selling Louisiana Home Due to Financial Struggles After Divorce

Olympic champion figure skater Oksana Baiul has announced she is putting her…

Bodo/Glimt 2-2 Tottenham Analysis: Spurs, Led by Thomas Frank, Held to Draw in Arctic Return

It won’t be remembered as a flawless performance. The return to Bodo…

Lando Norris Admits: “I’ll Never Match Max Verstappen’s Skill—Anyone Who Thinks Otherwise Can Get Lost!”

Lando Norris believes Max Verstappen is the top driver globally due to…