‘Not worth it’ – Newcastle told they overspent on Alexander Isak replacement

Bayern Munich’s honorary president, Uli Hoeness, has delivered a scathing swipe at Newcastle over the signing of Nick Woltemade.

The Bundesliga champions were heavily interested in the German striker prior to his club-record £69million move to the Magpies.

Newcastle replaced Isak with Woltemade

5

Newcastle replaced Isak with Woltemade

The transaction significantly surpassed the £63 million that Newcastle paid for Alexander Isak back in 2022, who notably set a British transfer record with his £125 million transfer to Liverpool on deadline day.

The arrival of Woltemade ended Eddie Howe’s summer-long hunt for a striker after missing out on multiple targets.

The 23-year-old appeared to be one of the names on that list, having been earmarked to stay in his homeland by joining Bayern Munich.

However, Vincent Kompany’s side failed to agree a fee with rivals Stuttgart, which opened the door for Newcastle to hijack the move.

Negotiations took a turn when Hoeness was displeased by Bayern legend Lothar Matthaus. Matthaus had apparently inflated Woltemade’s value by stating publicly that a fair price ranged between €80-100 million (£69-86 million), at a time when the Bavarians were offering considerably less.

The lower end of that estimation ultimately proved to be exactly what Stuttgart managed to extract from Newcastle.

During an interview with German TV channel SPORT1, Hoeness was asked about Matthaus’ correct prediction and replied: “He was just lucky.

“He [Woltemade] isn’t worth the €90million”, Bayern’s honorary president continued in a dig at Newcastle and their PIF owners.

“That only happened because of the money flowing from Saudi Arabia.”

The signing of Woltemade represented a huge coup for Newcastle, given Bayern saw three bids rejected for the 6ft 6ins forward.

Newcastle fended off competition from Bayern Munich

5

Newcastle fended off competition from Bayern MunichCredit: Getty
Hoeness claimed that the Toon overpaid

5

Hoeness claimed that the Toon overpaidCredit: getty

‘Bayern were prepared to go all in for him’

European football expert Andy Brassell was previously full of praise for Woltemade ahead of his arrival on Tyneside.

Last month on The Transfer Insiders, it was expressed: “He’s going to be a very significant addition, and it’s quite remarkable how they’ve managed to keep this under wraps since they often get outbid by other clubs.”

“Bayern was ready to push hard for him. Their interest was very clear. He was eager to join them, yet they couldn’t match the price Newcastle offered. His progress has been extraordinary, considering he joined on a free transfer from Werder Bremen, where he wasn’t a regular starter, and within less than a year at Stuttgart, he’s become this standout player.”

“If you’re searching for someone who could effectively fill Isak’s shoes and has great potential, there aren’t many players out there better suited than him.”

“He’s 6ft 6in, but he’s not your typical target man. He likes to drop and dribble.

“When Bayern wanted him, and Bayern were very keen, they thought he could play with Harry Kane.

Woltemade started Germany's shock loss to Slovakia

5

Woltemade started Germany’s shock loss to SlovakiaCredit: Getty

“Receiving such praise is quite rare, as he possesses impressive football intelligence. His ability to maintain possession and make continuous improvements is exceptional.”

‘Not ideal that the best German players are moving to England’

Woltemade began last season simply nicknamed ‘Big Nick’ due to his 6ft 6in frame, but ended it called the ‘Two Metre Messi’.

In 2023/24, he broke through at Werder Bremen, but only scored two goals in 30 games, and they both came in the same match.

Stuttgart saw enough to see him make the step up to a Champions League team, and were rewarded with 17 goals and a club-record sale.

While the opportunity to replace Isak at Newcastle is a huge one, Woltemade’s national team manager expressed his one big concern.

The striker followed Liverpool’s Florian Wirtz in surprisingly snubbing a move to Bayern for a Premier League transfer from the Bundesliga.

Woltemade and Florian Wirtz both favoured moves to England over staying in the Bundesliga

5

Woltemade and Florian Wirtz both favoured moves to England over staying in the BundesligaCredit: Getty

Julian Nagelsmann said: “I’m happy when they play a lot of games and get a lot of minutes, that’s the most important thing for me.

“It’s not ideal for the German Bundesliga that the best German players are moving to England. But that’s how it is.

“It’s kind of normal at this period of time.”

Nagelsmann’s comments come in the wake of Germany’s shock 2-0 loss in Slovakia – their first ever World Cup qualifying away defeat.

You May Also Like

USMNT Roster Announced for FIFA World Cup: Coach Mauricio Pochettino Selects Ten Defenders, Excludes Diego Luna

Thomas Tuchel has announced the England squad and there are some big…

Crystal Palace Triumphs in Conference League: Owner Steve Parish Takes Sharp Swipe at Nottingham Forest & UEFA

Crystal Palace chairman Steve Parish seemingly directed criticism at Nottingham Forest, Evangelos…

Milan Momcilovic Exits NBA Draft Consideration: Kentucky, Louisville, and Arizona Express Interest in Iowa State Standout

In a major development for college basketball, Iowa State’s standout sharpshooter Milan…

Explore the Top 25 Power Four College Football Coaches to Watch in 2026

In our 11th annual evaluation of Power Four coaches on CBSSports.com, this…

USWNT Roster Announcement: Mallory Swanson’s Return Highlights “Triple Espresso” Reunion for Upcoming Brazil Friendlies

Brace yourselves, because the dynamic “triple espresso” forward line of the U.S.…

Inside Roberto De Zerbi’s Transformative 54-Day Strategy: Late-Night Tactics, Team Cohesion, and YouTube Inspiration Propel Spurs to Safety and Future Ambitions

Tottenham Hotspur’s transformation from a winless streak of 15 matches to securing…

MLB Players Union Presents Initial Offer to Avoid Lockout: Key Details You Need to Know

Discussions over the forthcoming Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), which outlines the operational…

Hull City Owner Vows Legal Battle Over Championship Play-Off Outcome Minutes Before Kick-Off

Acun Ilicali, the owner of Hull City, has firmly stated that his…