Premier League referees endured their most error-strewn weekend of the season after the league’s key match incidents panel identified six incorrect decisions from the latest round of fixtures.
The panel unanimously concluded that Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty when Kai Havertz was pulled back inside the area during their win over Hull City, even though the forward had been standing in an offside position.
Under the laws of the game, a foul committed before an offside offence must be punished with a penalty.
Havertz was in an offside position, but he had not committed an offside offence because he neither touched the ball nor interfered with play.
The key match incidents panel said: ‘Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded.’
The key match incidents panel ruled that Farai Hallam was wrong not to award Kai Havertz a penalty
Coventry were incorrectly denied a penalty against Everton after James Tarkowski pulled Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair
The panel did praise VAR for sending Hallam to the pitch-side monitor, although the referee maintained his original decision after reviewing the footage.
Tottenham Hotspur also contacted Pro Ref after Jayden Bogle’s forceful challenge caught Mathys Tel on the ankle and forced the Spurs player out of the match.
Tottenham believed Bogle should have been dismissed, particularly after Crystal Palace forward Jean-Philippe Mateta received a red card for a similar incident the previous week.
The KMI panel was divided over the incident but ultimately decided that the challenge did not contain enough ‘speed, force or intensity’ to meet the threshold for serious foul play.
Two of the five members nevertheless believed the tackle warranted a straight red card.
Crystal Palace were also incorrectly awarded a stoppage-time penalty in their 3-1 loss to Liverpool.
The panel unanimously ruled that the referee should not have pointed to the spot after Milos Kerkez and Dario Osorio collided while challenging for the ball. Both players were airborne, making the contact unavoidable.
VAR’s decision not to overturn the call was backed, however, because the error did not meet the definition of a ‘clear and obvious error’.
It marked the second successive week in which Liverpool were involved in a penalty decision that went against them, following Alexander Isak’s incorrect denial of a spot-kick against Arsenal.
Across Merseyside, Everton defender James Tarkowski escaped conceding a penalty after pulling Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair during the goalless period of the Toffees’ victory over Coventry City. The panel said Coventry should have been awarded a spot-kick and Tarkowski should have been shown a yellow card.
The same offence might have resulted in a straight red card last season, but this campaign’s guidance reserves dismissals for cases involving excessive force.
Everton’s opening goal, scored by Thierno Barry, was also examined. Three panellists felt it should have been disallowed, with the ‘balance of probability suggesting the ball accidentally struck Barry’s hand before directly entering the goal’.
Bournemouth’s 2-1 win over Ipswich Town produced two further incorrect decisions.
The panel said Bournemouth defender Marcus Tavernier should have been shown a second yellow card in the 96th minute for delaying the restart. It was a finely balanced decision, with the members voting 3-2 in favour of a dismissal.
Ipswich’s penalty was also judged to have been awarded in error because Abdoul Ouattara moved across Lewis Cook rather than being brought down by the Bournemouth defender.
The KMI panel includes representatives from the Premier League and ProRef, along with three former managers or players. It meets after each round of fixtures to review major refereeing decisions.
Refereeing chief Howard Webb is scheduled to address Premier League clubs at a routine meeting on Thursday
Although the panel has existed previously, this is the first season in which its findings have been published publicly as part of Pro Ref’s push for greater transparency and accountability.
Pro Ref chief Howard Webb is expected to meet Premier League clubs at a routine gathering on Thursday.
In more encouraging news for Webb, he will be able to report that VAR delays have fallen this season after officials raised the threshold for video interventions.
The KMI panel has reviewed 296 decisions this season, with only six ultimately classified as incorrect after VAR analysis.