Share this @internewscast.com

Kate Cox, the plaintiff in a high-profile legal challenge to Texas’ abortion laws, announced Monday that she was leaving the state to terminate her pregnancy. Under Texas law, some experts say, anyone who helped her do so could face legal risk.

Cox sought a court order to terminate her pregnancy in Texas after she learned that her fetus had a rare disorder that prevented it from surviving outside the womb. A state district court granted her request last week, but then the Texas Supreme Court ruled against her Monday, overturning the order.

The state Supreme Court had paused the lower court’s ruling as it considered the case, and while she waited for a decision, Cox determined that her pregnancy was too risky and sought an out-of-state abortion, her lawyers said.

Texas has two primary laws restricting abortion. One makes it a felony to perform an abortion from the moment of fertilization, except for situations in which doctors, using “reasonable medical judgement,” deem the procedure medically necessary to save the life of a pregnant woman or prevent “substantial impairment of a major bodily function.”

The other law was enacted in September 2021, before the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Roe v. Wade; it authorizes private citizens to file civil suits against anyone who provides or abets an abortion after about six weeks of pregnancy.

Since travel assistance could theoretically count as abetting an abortion, several legal experts said that Cox’s husband — or any friend or family member who helped her leave Texas — may still be vulnerable to lawsuits. Cox’s lawyers did not disclose her location or give additional details about who, if anyone, helped her seek an out-of-state abortion.

“Anybody with knowledge who’s actively participating to help the pregnant person achieve an abortion — driving them to the other state, flying with them, being there step by step with that person — those are the individuals that would be at risk,” said Joseph Veith, a criminal law attorney in El Paso.

Citizens who sue under that Texas law — known as SB 8 — are eligible to receive at least $10,000 in damages.

“This is such a high-profile case that it will probably attract people who are interested in filing these lawsuits,” Veith said.

However, the Center for Reproductive Rights, which represents Cox, said SB 8 is not a concern in her case, since it only applies to abortions within the state of Texas, not those obtained in other states.

Independent legal experts say it’s hard to know how a lawsuit would play out, because there’s little precedent. Late last year, a judge dismissed a case in which a Chicago resident sued a Texas doctor who had provided an abortion after SB 8 went into effect. The judge determined that people who are not directly affected by an abortion do not have standing to sue.

“SB 8 was a stopgap measure. It was passed in the face of uncertainty about whether criminal abortion laws would be legal. So it remains to be seen whether it was actually designed to be used,” said Khiara M. Bridges, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley.

There are also logistical barriers to bringing forward a lawsuit of this nature, experts said: People have to hire a lawyer, pay fees and gather substantial evidence that the person they are suing assisted in an abortion.

“They’re not going to have access to medical records, so unless it’s more high-profile or if it’s a family friend or a friend who provides information to another person, there’s just not going to be a lot of information obtainable,” Veith said.

As for what’s next in Cox’s lawsuit, legal experts said the Texas Supreme Court’s decision most likely ended it.

In its decision, the court wrote that Cox’s doctor had not clearly demonstrated her need for a lifesaving abortion. The court also said that if the doctor were to decide, based on “reasonable medical judgment,” that Cox’s situation did qualify for an exception to Texas’ abortion ban, there would be no need to seek a court order in the first place.

“They’re saying it’s up to the doctor, but they also seem to be saying that the doctor’s affidavit was not sufficiently harrowing,” said Wendy Parmet, the director of the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University in Boston. “That, I think, is going to put shivers down the spine of a lot of doctors.”

Many doctors and legal experts say it is often unclear which situations qualify as medical exceptions under Texas law and similar abortion bans in other states. Physicians who violate Texas’ abortion law can lose their medical licenses, face up to 99 years in prison or incur fines of at least $100,000.

“There’s nothing in that opinion that I think would assuage physicians, particularly given the severity of the penalties and risks that health care providers face in Texas [and] the court’s unwillingness really to acknowledge the incredible bind that physicians are being put in,” Parmet said.

Cox’s developing fetus was diagnosed with trisomy 18, a rare chromosomal disorder likely to cause stillbirth or infant death shortly after a baby is born. The disorder also elevates a mother’s risk of gestational diabetes, preterm delivery and cesarean section.

According to her petition, Cox was at risk for a cesarean section and gestational diabetes before the diagnosis. She visited the emergency room four times for pregnancy symptoms, her lawyers said, including severe cramps, leaking fluid and elevated vital signs.

Another ongoing lawsuit in Texas also seeks to define the types of emergency situations that qualify for abortions, but legal experts said they expect a similar opinion from the state’s highest court.

At the very least, Bridges said, that lawsuit will “give the state Supreme Court another opportunity to clarify its holding in Kate Cox’s case.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Accused killer caught in Missouri after California jail mistakenly freed him

Shocking Jail Blunder: Accused Killer Captured in Missouri After Erroneous Release in California

A murder suspect who was inadvertently set free from a California jail…
NYPD's Jessica Tisch rips verdict in slaying of NYC cop Jonathan Diller

NYPD’s Jessica Tisch Criticizes Court Decision in NYC Officer Jonathan Diller’s Murder Case

In a fervent response on Thursday, NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch expressed her…
Priceless 2500 year old golden helmet stolen from Dutch museum recovered

Stolen 2,500-Year-Old Golden Helmet Recovered: Priceless Artifact Returns to Dutch Museum

In a significant breakthrough, Dutch authorities have successfully recovered a priceless ancient…
Cigarette helps solve 60-year-old cold-case murder

Decades-Old Murder Mystery Finally Cracked with Cigarette Clue

In 1966, the affluent town of San Rafael was rocked by a…
7-Month-Old Baby Shot and Killed in Gun-Controlled NYC

Tragic Incident: Infant Fatally Shot in New York City

Tragedy struck in Brooklyn on Wednesday afternoon when a seven-month-old baby girl…
Lead detective in Nancy Guthrie investigation had 'never investigated a homicide before'

Unprecedented Challenge: Inexperienced Detective Leads High-Profile Nancy Guthrie Homicide Case

An Arizona investigator leading the probe into Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance reportedly had…
San Francisco human rights boss accused of corruption arrives in court

San Francisco Human Rights Leader Faces Corruption Charges in Court Appearance

Former San Francisco city official Sheryl Davis made a court appearance on…
American Airlines flight diverted to Detroit after passenger allegedly makes ominous threat

Mid-Air Drama: American Airlines Forced into Emergency Landing Over Passenger Threat

A tense situation unfolded mid-air when an American Airlines flight en route…
Brighton Park community meeting gets heated over alleged immigration collaboration between Chicago police officers, ICE agents

Tensions Rise at Brighton Park Meeting Over Suspected Collaboration Between Chicago Police and ICE

CHICAGO (WLS) — On Thursday evening, the Community Commission for Public Safety…
Kamala Harris refused to watch Trump's address to the nation — sparking conservative firestorm: 'Bullet dodged'

Kamala Harris Ignites Conservative Backlash by Skipping Trump’s National Address

Critics had a field day with former Vice President Kamala Harris after…
ICE nabs alleged machete-wielding MS-13 gangster wanted for murder: 'the witch'

ICE Captures Notorious MS-13 Member Known as ‘The Witch,’ Sought for Murder

The spotlight is once again on California’s sanctuary policies following the arrest…
Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul warns privacy is at risk due to loopholes with private data brokers, government surveillance

Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul Raises Alarm Over Privacy Risks from Data Broker Loopholes and Government Surveillance

CHICAGO (WLS) — Illinois’ chief legal officer is sounding the alarm over…