Lindsay Hubbard put Andy Cohen on the spot while discussing her future on Bravo during Wednesday night’s (May 21) episode of Watch What Happens Live.

During the finale of Summer House Season 9, which aired last night, Danielle Olivera told Hubbard she was “delulu” if she believed her time on the show wasn’t ending. Hubbard, who was pregnant, shared she was experiencing an “identity crisis” as she navigated the new phase of her life, expressing concerns about living in a “party share house” with a baby. She questioned her future, wondering, “What does that mean? I don’t know. How am I going to earn an income? I haven’t a clue. Where do I proceed from here?” she pondered in her confessional.

The conversation continued on Watch What Happens Live with Kyle Cooke‘s take on Hubbard’s Summer House future.

“It’s only natural that some of us start families and think about what comes next,” he commented. “However, that doesn’t automatically imply, ‘Goodbye, see you later.’ I hope my words didn’t suggest that. After all, Amanda and I will eventually face similar circumstances.”

At this point, Hubbard, with strong support from fans who want her on The Real Housewives of New York City, turned to Cohen, an executive producer on the series, and posed the question everyone has been eager to hear answered.

“Yeah. So, where do we go from here, Andy? What do we do?” she wondered.

Cohen flashed an uncomfortable look on his face, before replying, “Alright. Let’s talk about it after the show.”

Some fans have been hoping for a Summer House spinoff series that follows Hubbard, Amanda Batula, Paige DeSorbo, and Ciara Miller in their everyday lives, while others would like to see the women to become the next generation of The Real Housewives of New York City.

When DECIDER caught up with Hubbard in March, she said she’d be open to joining RHONY.

“I see whatever decision everyone has for me,” she explained. “Unfortunately, I’m not the decision-maker for where my life is going on Bravo.”

“I have been going to the Hamptons since 2007 when I was interning in the city and working in the Hamptons well before we started shooting the show. I’m going to be out there — I’ll probably wind up at Erin [Lichy’s] house with our newborn kids together this summer,” she continued. “I’m waiting for somebody to tell me what my future is because I don’t make these decisions. But everyone asks me, and I’m like, ‘Ask the other guy!’ It’s literally not up to me.”

She added, “But what I can tell you is that I spent nine seasons proving that I make good TV.”

Watch What Happens Live airs Sunday through Thursday at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo. New episodes are available to stream the next day on Peacock.