Divided Supreme Court rejects public religious charter school in Oklahoma
Share this @internewscast.com


The Supreme Court deadlocked 4-4 on whether to approve the nation’s first publicly funded religious charter school Thursday, leaving intact a lower ruling that voided the Oklahoma school’s contract.

“The judgment is affirmed by an equally divided court,” the court wrote in its one-sentence, unsigned opinion. 

Only eight justices sat for the case, since Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused. 

The decision lets stand a ruling from the Oklahoma Supreme Court rejecting the bid to establish St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, which spurred a major constitutional battle over the role of religion in state-funded education. 

The deadlocked opinion from the nation’s highest court landed swiftly, just weeks after the justices heard the case at the end of April. 

It marks the culmination of a multiyear, high-profile legal battle over religious rights that began after the Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board approved St. Isidore’s contract. 

Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond (R) led the fight against the school, bringing the case directly to the state’s top court and winning. 

Both the charter school board and St. Isidore then appealed to the nation’s top court, saying the opinion was “riddled with missteps.”  

James Campbell, the attorney who argued on behalf of the charter school board, said in a statement that Thursday’s decision was “disappointing” but stressed the court could still return to the issue in the future.

“Oklahoma parents and children are better off with more educational choices, not fewer,” Campbell said. 

At the crux of the dispute was whether the school could be considered a state actor. 

The school argued its case was no different than recent ones from Maine, Montana and Missouri, where the justices said state programs that fund private education cannot carve out religious schools.  

Drummond’s office asserted the dispute fell into another line of Supreme Court precedent, where the court has long held that states can require their public schools to be secular. 

“The Supreme Court has ruled in favor of my position that we should not allow taxpayer funding of radical Islamic schools here in Oklahoma,” Drummond said in a statement. “I am proud to have fought against this potential cancer in our state, and I will continue upholding the law, protecting our Christian values and defending religious liberty.”

The court’s opinion does not provide reasoning or disclose how the individual justices voted. 

But at oral arguments, four of the court’s conservatives appeared sympathetic to the school’s contentions, while the court’s three liberal justices appeared to lean toward Drummond’s side. That would leave Chief Justice Roberts as the swing vote.

Barrett did not publicly explain her recusal from the case, but court-watchers believe it stems from her close friendship with Nicole Garnett, a professor at Notre Dame Law School, whose religious liberty clinic represented St. Isidore.

The decision was one of two opinions handed down by the Supreme Court on Thursday. 

In the other case, the court unanimously sided with the federal government in a wire fraud case it brought against Stamatios Kousisis and Alpha Painting & Construction over contracts Pennsylvania’s Transportation Department awarded them for painting projects in Philadelphia. 

The contracts required Alpha to include disadvantaged businesses as part of its work, which the company falsely claimed it was. Kousisis and the company argued the allegations against them, which relied on what is known as the “fraudulent inducement” theory, are not covered by the federal wire fraud statute, so the charges should be dismissed. 

“The fraudulent-inducement theory is consistent with both the text of the wire fraud statute and our precedent interpreting it,” Barrett wrote in the court’s opinion. 

Updated at 11:48 a.m. EDT

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Renegade Paws Adoption Story Gains Massive Attention and Is Highlighted on The Today Show

SAVANNAH, Ga. () — Renegade Paws Rescue has gone viral! A social…

Crime Stoppers in Sangamon and Menard Counties Request Information on Forgery and Theft Suspect

The Crime Stoppers of Sangamon and Menard Counties are seeking assistance in…

‘She’s Essential’: Green Praises Webber’s Fit for Illinois

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. (WCIA) – Shauna Green has a pattern of reconnecting with…

Savannah City Council Plans Meeting on Horse Carriage Safety

Alderman Nick Palumbo is actively voicing his concerns as the Savannah city…

New ‘Click-to-Cancel’ Rule to Simplify Subscription Cancellations Faces Setback

A “click-to-cancel” regulation, which aimed to ensure that businesses provide a straightforward…

Meeting on Ceasefire as 40 Palestinians Die in Gaza, Netanyahu and Trump Discuss

DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip (AP) At least 40 Palestinians were killed in…

Over 100 Lives Lost in Central Texas Flash Floods: What We Know About the Victims

AUSTIN (KXAN) — The tragic weekend of catastrophic flooding in Central Texas…

Intensifying Dispute Over Book Bans in Beaufort County

BEAUFORT COUNTY, SC () – A battle between one Beaufort County woman…

Trump Issues Tariff Notices to Seven Additional Countries, Avoids Main US Trade Allies

WASHINGTON (AP) President Donald Trump sent out tariff letters to seven smaller…

Utah Judge Sets Execution Date for Dementia Suffering Inmate by Firing Squad

SALT LAKE CITY – On Wednesday, a Utah judge scheduled the execution…

Community Gathers for Vigil Honoring Texas Flood Victims on Tuesday Evening

AUSTIN (KXAN) Dozens of University of Texas at Austin students and community…

Convicted murderer Derrick Groves remains at large as the only escapee still evading capture after New Orleans jail break

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Almost two months after 10 inmates broke out…